Principle

midrasמִדְרָס

mid-RAHS

Seat-impurity; is it still sittable?

Midras is the impurity a surface made for sitting, lying, or leaning on (a moshav or mishkav) takes on when a zav, zavah, niddah, or yoledet sits, lies, or leans on it. The recurring test throughout Keilim's furniture chapters is whether a damaged seat is still fit to be sat on: a chair, bench, or stool that can still be used as a seat remains susceptible to midras, while one no longer fit to sit on (or nullified into a non-seat, like a chair fixed into a kneading-trough) is tahor from midras. Decoration alone does not create a midras-seat; only real function — shaping or use that people accept — does. A single composite item can carry midras together with ordinary tum'ah at once, and when its parts separate, midras follows the part still fit for sitting.

Where it comes up

67 mishnayot

  1. Chagigah 2:7Clothes, from the am ha-aretz up to sacred foodThe perek's closing ladder treats each lower group's clothes as treading-impure — as if one with a discharge had sat on them — for the rung above; here an am ha-aretz's clothes are treading-impure for those who eat ordinary food in purity.
  2. Chagigah 3:1Sacred food is held stricter than terumahOne may carry something treading-impure — such as the sandal of a man with a discharge — together with terumah but not with sacred food, one of the perek's stringencies for sacred food.
  3. Eduyot 2:8A sandal, an oven's remnant, and a chairMidras is the impurity an object catches when a man with an impure discharge, or the like, treads, sits, or leans on it. Whether an object is 'made for treading' determines if it is susceptible — the crux here.
  4. Keilim 15:3The sieve's frame, and impurity as a seatRabbi Yehudah says the hair-braider's frame can become impure as a seat because girls actually sit inside it to have their hair braided: the recurring test of whether it is sat on.
  5. Keilim 15:6Vessel-status by use: harps, scrolls, and instrumentsRabbi Yehudah says the drum can become impure as a seat because the wailing woman actually sits on it as she leads the laments: the logic of a seat.
  6. Keilim 18:5A treading-impure bed losing a short or long sideMishnayot 5–9 all run on treading-impurity, the impurity a bed takes when a man with a discharge lies, sits or leans on it. Their whole question is when taking a bed apart or repairing it ends that impurity.
  7. Keilim 18:6Repairing a treading-impure bed one long side at a timeThis mishnah continues the treading sequence, asking what happens when a treading-impure bed has its long sides broken and repaired one at a time. The step down from treading-impure, to impure by contact with it, to pure only makes sense once you hold treading-impurity in view.
  8. Keilim 18:7How a leg's impurity passes to the bed and backThe mishnah runs the same join-then-separate test at three levels of impurity, and treading-impurity is the strongest of them. How it behaves on the leg sets the pattern for the corpse and evening cases that follow.
  9. Keilim 18:9The half-bed; one bundle or part by partThis closing mishnah returns to the bed and to when its impurity ends. A bed can become treading-impure when a man with a discharge sits or leans on it: his weight alone makes it impure. Here the bed is split with no one meaning to put it back together, and that is what decides whether its impurity survives.
  10. Keilim 20:1Bags one can lie on: their sizes, and when a torn one is purePerek 20 is built on treading: the impurity a man with a discharge gives what he lies or sits on. These things can still become treading-impure after they tear, because they are also made to lie on, and that use outlasts the lost receptacle.
  11. Keilim 20:2When a cracked trough can become treading-impure, and when a worn-down basket still can become impureThe treading test recurs: a thing can become treading-impure only if it is fit to lie on. A bag of air for music is never lain on, so it cannot, the same reasoning that runs through the whole perek.
  12. Keilim 20:3When a vessel fixed into a big timber stays a vessel, and when a seat carved out of the timber cannot become impureA chair is made for sitting, so it can become treading-impure in its own right. Fixing it into a post does not change that, but the post, not made for sitting, does not share it. Treading reaches only what is made for sitting.
  13. Keilim 20:4When a broken oversized trough becomes a seat, and why fixing a vessel to a wall doesn't purify itThe dispute is whether setting a broken trough up for sitting makes it a seat that can become treading-impure. Rabbi Akiva: setting it up is enough; the Sages: only trimming it into shape makes it a thing made for sitting.
  14. Keilim 20:5When a vessel becomes part of a building (pure) and when it stays a vessel (can become impure)A seat-block is made for sitting, so it can become treading-impure. The unit asks what it takes to make a seat mere wall: half-measures leave it a seat; only being fixed and built over makes it part of the building.
  15. Keilim 20:6A sheet made into a curtain can no longer become treading-impure: from when?A sheet is fit to lie on, so it can become treading-impure; a curtain is not lain on. Made into a curtain, it can no longer become treading-impure, though it is still a garment that can become impure from a corpse: the test is whether one lies on it.
  16. Keilim 20:7When an altered or split mat can become impure, and from when a new one canA mat is normally something to lie on, so it can become treading-impure. The whole mishnah asks what makes it unfit to lie on (added reeds, narrow gaps, splits), the treading test that runs through the perek.
  17. Keilim 22:3Bench, footstool, and the chair before a great chairFrom here through the end of the perek the question is whether a damaged seat is still fit to sit on. A seat fit for sitting can become treading-impure, if a man with a discharge sits on it; one no longer fit to sit on cannot. This 'is it still a seat?' test drives every case below.
  18. Keilim 22:4Beit Shammai and Beit Hillel on a stripped chair and a chair set in a kneading troughThe chair is a seat, which can become treading-impure. The whole dispute between Beit Shammai and Beit Hillel is whether, stripped of its fittings, it is still fit to sit on, and so can still become impure, or counts as broken.
  19. Keilim 22:5When losing the seat-boards leaves the chair usable on its sideAgain the test is whether a damaged seat is still fit to sit on. Here, because the side-boards were flush rather than protruding, the stripped chair can be tipped on its side and used — so it can still become treading-impure.
  20. Keilim 22:6Which seat-boards can go and still leave a usable seatThe same treading test continues: as long as enough seat boards remain that the chair is still fit to sit on, it can still become treading-impure. Here the chair's seat is made of three boards, and the question is which can be lost.
  21. Keilim 22:7When the seat is lost, a leftover receptacle does not rescue itContinuing the seat-board cases: when two boards side by side are gone, the gap may be too wide to sit across. The treading test, whether a usable seat is left, decides the dispute between Rabbi Akiva and the Sages.
  22. Keilim 22:8When a chest loses top and bottom; the stonecutter's seatA closing one-liner: the seat a stonecutter shapes to sit on as he works is a real seat, so it can become treading-impure, impure when a man with a discharge sits on it.
  23. Keilim 22:9Decoration alone does not make a seat; what makes a basket a seatThe dispute is whether decorating a block of wood is enough to make it a seat that can become treading-impure, or whether it must be cut into shape for sitting.
  24. Keilim 22:10Seats of two parts: which impurity each part can takeThe mishnah's closing cases turn on a seat of two parts that can take two impurities at once: treading, because it is sat on, and impurity from a corpse, like any vessel. Which part keeps which when they come apart is the theme.
  25. Keilim 23:4A corpse's bed; three seats Rabbi Yosei exemptsThe perek now turns to treading: the impurity a man with a discharge gives what he sits or lies on. The test is whether a thing is actually used for sitting: even a corpse's bedding counts, because mourners sit on it, while Rabbi Yosei says the seats in the next lines do not.
  26. Keilim 24:1Three kinds of shield, sorted by how they can become impurePerek 24 sorts ordinary objects into three degrees. The highest is treading, which applies only to something a person uses to sit, lie or lean on. Whether each item can become treading-impure is the question all through the perek.
  27. Keilim 24:2Three kinds of wagon: chair-cart, bed-cart, stone-cartThe armchair wagon earns the top degree for the same reason a chair does: it is made for sitting, and that is what lets a thing become treading-impure.
  28. Keilim 24:3Three kinds of kneading trough: cracked, whole, and giantA trough is normally a receptacle, not a seat, but once it cracks and can no longer knead, people sit on it. Setting it aside for sitting is what makes it able to become treading-impure.
  29. Keilim 24:4Three kinds of box: opening on the side, on top, and giantA box is mainly a receptacle, but one opening on the side doubles as a seat: you can sit on its top while reaching in at the side. That second use, for sitting, is what lets it become treading-impure.
  30. Keilim 24:5Three kinds of leather mat: barbers', dining, oliveLeather can become treading-impure only when made to bear a person's weight. The barbers' mat is large enough to sit or lean on, so it can, unlike the mat they eat on that follows.
  31. Keilim 24:6Three kinds of stand: footstool, side-table stand, cabinet standA stand earns the top grade only when a person uses it to bear his weight. The bedside footstool and the scribes' footrest both support the body, so they can become treading-impure.
  32. Keilim 24:7Three kinds of writing tablet: dust, wax, and smoothEven a writing tablet can earn the top grade if it is big enough to sit on. The dust tablet is, and that is what lets it become treading-impure.
  33. Keilim 24:8Three kinds of bed: for sleeping, glaziers', saddlers'A bed made for lying on is the plainest case of treading impurity, which is about what a man with a discharge lies or sits on with his full weight.
  34. Keilim 24:9Three kinds of carrying basket: dung, straw, camels' rope netA carrying basket is a receptacle, but the basket for dung is also fit to sit on, and that is what lets it become treading-impure.
  35. Keilim 24:10Three kinds of reed mat: for sitting, dyers', winepresses'This is the perek's three-way sort, and it runs on one question: is the item made to sit on? The reed mat made for sitting can become treading-impure; the dyers' and the winepresses' mats never serve as a seat, so they fall to a lower degree or none.
  36. Keilim 24:13Three kinds of sheet, sorted by useA sheet made for lying on is plain bedding, so of the three sheets it alone can become treading-impure.
  37. Keilim 24:15Three kinds of hand guard: hunters', locust catchers', fruit dryers'The hunters' guard can become treading-impure because the hunter leans on it: leaning, not only sitting, lets a thing become treading-impure.
  38. Keilim 24:16Three kinds of hairnet, sorted by who wears themA young woman's hairnet is fit to sit on, so unlike the old woman's it can become treading-impure: whether it is fit to sit on decides between them.
  39. Keilim 26:4A sandal stops being treading-impure; knotted waterskinsA sandal is trodden on, so a man with a discharge who walks in it makes it treading-impure. The mishnah asks at what point of damage it stops being the same usable sandal and loses that impurity.
  40. Keilim 26:5Hides that can become treading-impureThe mishnah's idea: each of these hides is made or intended for sitting or lying on, and that is what lets a man with a discharge make it treading-impure.
  41. Keilim 26:6Garment wraps; a cover cannot become impure, one for weights canThe mishnah continues the last one: what bears the weight of a man with a discharge can become treading-impure. Here it turns to thick garment-cloth and wrappers, then to whether a mere cover counts as a vessel.
  42. Keilim 26:9Cutting up a treading-impure hide; five tefachimThe hide was treading-impure, a seat a man with a discharge sat on. The mishnah asks at what stage of being cut up for things no one sits on it becomes pure.
  43. Keilim 27:1The five-four-three-two-one ladder of materialsThe way wood has and earthenware lacks is as a seat: if a man with a discharge sits on it, it becomes treading-impure. This treading-impurity recurs through the rest of the perek.
  44. Keilim 27:2The size thresholds: 3, 4, 5, 6 tefachimThe whole mishnah sets the large size for treading against the small size for impurity from a corpse. Treading needs a piece big enough to sit on, so its size is never the smaller: for cloth it is far larger, while for sacking, leather and a mat the two are the same.
  45. Keilim 27:4Trimming a tefach-square to make a seatThe sizes of three to six tefachim are not the whole story: a piece trimmed to sit on is a seat, and can become treading-impure, at just a tefach by a tefach.
  46. Keilim 27:5Repurposed sifters, a child's seat, a child's shirtThis continues the thread of seats: Rabbi Akiva and the Sages disagree whether setting a worn piece aside for sitting makes it a seat, or it must first be trimmed.
  47. Keilim 27:7Treading-impurity mid-weaving: shrinking before vs. afterThe mishnah turns on the difference between being treading-impure, a primary source of impurity, and having touched what is treading-impure, a lighter, first-degree impurity. Shrinking the first square below three by three tefachim ends the first but not the second.
  48. Keilim 27:9A treading-impure sheet made into a curtainMade into a curtain, the sheet is no longer for lying or sitting on, so its treading-impurity ends, but the lighter impurity of contact with treading-impurity stays.
  49. Keilim 27:10A treading-impure cloth split in twoSplitting the cloth so neither piece is three by three tefachim ends its treading-impurity, but, as in mishnayot 7 and 9, the lighter impurity of contact with it stays, though Rabbi Yosei disagrees.
  50. Keilim 28:5Its own purpose or another: when remaking makes it pureTreading-impurity comes only to something one sits or lies on. Once a woman's head-cloth is set aside to wrap a scroll, no one sits on it, so it cannot become treading-impure, though it can still become impure from a corpse.
  51. Keilim 28:6Where a treading-impure patch keeps its strength, and where it is absorbedThe whole mishnah follows a patch that is already treading-impure. Whether it stays a primary source of impurity, weakens, or is absorbed depends on what it is sewn onto: a basket, which cannot become treading-impure, or cloth, which can.
  52. Keilim 28:7Does the border count? And which stitched sides connect?Whether a treading-impure patch makes the garment under it treading-impure depends on whether the sewing makes them connected. Which sides are sewn decides it.
  53. Keilim 28:8When three by three fingerbreadths does and doesn't applyTreading-impurity goes by the whole garment, not its scraps. So a garment sewn of pieces too small to count can still become treading-impure as a whole.
  54. Keilim 28:9A porter's pad, a strainer, a hairnet, and net-work garmentsThe first clauses of this mishnah turn on the same test: is the item actually made to be sat on? A porter's pad passes (he sits on it), a wine-strainer fails (no one sits on it because of the dregs).
  55. Parah 10:1The special stringency of the purification watersTreading — the impurity a man or woman with a discharge, or a menstruating woman, gives a thing made for lying, sitting or riding on by pressing on it — is the line here: anything that can become impure by treading is madaf for the purification water.
  56. Tohorot 5:7Three doubts in a public placeTreading is how someone with a discharge makes impure whatever he steps on. The question is whether the unknown person who trod on the clothes had a discharge — answered here by majority.
  57. Tohorot 5:8One woman without understanding, and asking herA menstruating woman, or one with a discharge, makes clothes impure by treading on them — and even those of one who shares a boat with her. The question is only whether this particular woman was impure.
  58. Tohorot 7:5When he can be seenBedding and seats become treading-impure when a man with a discharge sits or lies on them — but an am ha-aretz has no discharge, and the Sages did not decree this on him, so these stay pure.
  59. Tohorot 7:6Who searched, who only steppedOrdinary Jewish thieves are careless about purity but have no discharge, so they do not make bedding and seats impure by lying or sitting on them; these stay pure.
  60. Tohorot 8:2What impurity a deposit picks upHis wife may have sat on the vessels while menstruating, making them treading-impure. This is the ever-present worry that no recognition can remove.
  61. Tohorot 10:1Treading-impure vessels among the press workersA treading-impure vessel is a primary source of impurity: it makes a person impure by touch, by carrying, and even by being shifted. That severity is exactly why the locked-in workers are at risk.
  62. Niddah 6:3If treading-impure, then impure from a corpseOnly a thing made for sitting or lying can become treading-impure from a man with a discharge, and any such thing is a real vessel — so it can also become impure from a corpse.
  63. Zavim 2:4How bedding becomes impureTreading is the impurity a man with a discharge gives by his weight pressing on an object. These five postures all bear that weight, so each makes the bedding or seat treading-impure.
  64. Zavim 3:1When shifting makes impureTreading is the impurity a man with a discharge gives to what bears his weight for sitting or lying. Here the pure man's clothes become treading-impure through his movement.
  65. Zavim 4:1The cap, the mast, and the falling loafTreading-impurity is what a menstruating woman or a man with a discharge passes on by leaning their weight on something. Rabbi Yehoshua's surprise is that the cap is treading-impure though she never sat on it.
  66. Zavim 5:2The row of stonesBedding or a seat a man with a discharge lies on becomes treading-impure, itself a primary source of impurity. That is why, even below the stones, it makes two impure and one unfit, rather than one.
  67. Yadayim 4:1On that day: the cracked foot-washing basinImpurity by treading is the recurring test of the furniture chapters: people sat in this basin even when it was whole, so once it cracked, what remains is a thing to sit on, and a seat takes on the impurity a man with a discharge passes on by sitting. The crack changes the verdict by changing the function.