Keilim 27:7כֵּלִיםTreading-impurity mid-weaving: shrinking before vs. after
Order matters: weave the rest on, then take out a thread, or the reverse?
The question
If a midras-tamei square is woven into a garment and then reduced, what is its status?
Two orders of events: finishing the garment then removing a thread, or the reverse.
Tap a Hebrew word for its meaning. Tap a bold phrase to see the words it translates.
1Completed, then a thread removed
Cloth woven onto a treading-impure square of three by three tefachim is pure of treading-impurity once a thread is taken from that square, but impure by contact with it.
הַבֶּגֶד שֶׁאָרַג בּוֹ שְׁלֹשָׁה עַל שְׁלֹשָׁה, וְנִטְמָא מִדְרָס, וְהִשְׁלִים עָלָיו אֶת כָּל הַבֶּגֶד, וְאַחַר כָּךְ נָטַל חוּט אֶחָד מִתְּחִלָּתוֹ, טָהוֹר מִן הַמִּדְרָס, אֲבָל טָמֵא מַגַּע מִדְרָס.
Cloth on which one wove three by three [tefachim], handbreadths, the size cloth needs for treading, and it became treading-impure, when a man with a discharge sat on it, and [then] one finished the whole cloth onto it, so all of it, joined to that square, is treading-impure, and afterward took out one thread from its beginning, from that first square, it is pure of treading-impurity, for the trodden square is no longer full size, but impure by contact with treading-impurity. The rest touched that square while it was treading-impure, and keeps that lighter impurity.
The picture The picture in words
- He weaves a square of three by three tefachim, handbreadths, the size cloth needs for treading.
- A man with a discharge sits on it, so the square becomes treading-impure, a primary source of impurity.
- He weaves the rest of the cloth onto it, and the whole cloth, joined to the square, is treading-impure.
- He pulls one thread out of the first square, so it is pure of treading. The cloth touched it while it was treading-impure, so it stays impure by contact.
Concepts here
2 notes
הַבֶּגֶד שֶׁאָרַג בּוֹ שְׁלֹשָׁה עַל שְׁלֹשָׁה, וְנִטְמָא מִדְרָס, וְהִשְׁלִים עָלָיו אֶת כָּל הַבֶּגֶד
- Setup: on the loom, exactly three tefachim square is woven (the midras minimum). A zav treads on it — now it is a midras, an av ha-tum'ah (primary source of impurity).
- Bartenura: the weaver then completes the whole garment onto that tamei (impure) square. The entire garment becomes a midras, since it is joined (chibbur) to the three-square that was already defiled.
- Key distinction throughout: a midras is a primary source (av ha-tum'ah); something that merely TOUCHED a midras is one degree lower (a rishon, "maga midras").
Bartenura · Rambam Commentary
נָטַל חוּט אֶחָד מִתְּחִלָּתוֹ, טָהוֹר מִן הַמִּדְרָס, אֲבָל טָמֵא מַגַּע מִדְרָס
- Now one thread is pulled from the ORIGINAL three-square, shrinking it below the midras minimum.
- Bartenura: the whole garment is now "pure from midras" — it loses the av-ha-tum'ah (impurity) status, because its defiled core no longer holds the midras size.
- But it stays "tamei (impure) as midras-contact": the garment had TOUCHED the original three-square while that square was still a full midras, so it retains the lower contact-level tum'ah.
- Rambam: it becomes like a garment that touched a midras — a rishon, not an av.
Bartenura · Rambam Commentary
2Thread removed, then completed
Reverse the order, taking out the thread first and then weaving the rest, and the cloth is still impure by contact with treading-impurity.
נָטַל חוּט אֶחָד מִתְּחִלָּתוֹ, וְאַחַר כָּךְ הִשְׁלִים עָלָיו אֶת כָּל הַבֶּגֶד, טָמֵא מַגַּע מִדְרָס:
If one took out one thread from its beginning — from a treading-impure square of three by three tefachim, before the rest was woven on — and afterward finished the whole cloth onto it, it is impure by contact with treading-impurity. The shrunken square keeps that lighter impurity, and the cloth woven onto it shares it.
1 note
נָטַל חוּט אֶחָד מִתְּחִלָּתוֹ, וְאַחַר כָּךְ הִשְׁלִים עָלָיו... טָמֵא מַגַּע מִדְרָס
- Same pieces, reversed order: the thread is pulled FIRST (shrinking the three-square below midras size), and only afterward is the rest of the garment woven on.
- Bartenura: this tanna holds that a three-square that was shrunk after becoming a midras stays tamei (impure) as midras-CONTACT (taught further on in the perek). So even after shrinking, the core still carries contact-tum'ah (impurity).
- When the rest of the garment is then woven onto that core, the whole garment is joined to a midras-contact-tamei piece — and "whatever is joined to the tamei is tamei like it."
- Result: the whole garment is tamei by midras-contact (a rishon), but never reached full midras status, because the core was already below size before the weaving.
Bartenura · Rambam Commentary
Summary
A weaver starts a cloth with three by three tefachim, the size cloth needs for treading, and a man with a discharge sits on it, so the square becomes treading-impure. Two things can follow, in either order: weaving the rest of the cloth onto it, and taking one thread out of that first square, which leaves it short of the size. If he finishes the whole cloth first and then takes out the thread, the cloth is pure of treading-impurity but impure by contact with it, since the rest touched the square while it was treading-impure. If he takes out the thread first and then finishes the cloth, it is the same: the shrunken square keeps that lighter impurity, and the cloth woven onto it shares it. The theme of these mishnayot is the gap between being treading-impure and having touched what was.