Category
Demaiדְּמַאי
DE-MAI
Doubtfully-tithed produce
Produce bought from an am ha-aretz, a common person not trusted to be scrupulous about tithes. Because it is uncertain (the name is read da-mai, 'what is this?') whether the tithes were taken, the buyer must separate them himself out of doubt — but only terumat ma'aser and ma'aser sheni, not the gifts he could withhold by demanding proof. Since most amei ha-aretz actually do tithe, the obligation is only rabbinic, so demai is treated with many leniencies: no added fifth at redemption, no third-year biur, it may be eaten by a mourner, used for an eruv, and separated at twilight or even while naked.
Where it comes up
32 mishnayot
- Demai 1:1Wild produce exempt from demaiThe tractate's opening line names its subject: produce bought from an am ha-aretz that must be tithed out of doubt. This mishnah carves out the exceptions — cheap wild fruits the Sages did not subject to that doubt.
- Demai 1:2Seven leniencies in demaiThe mishnah turns from which produce is demai to how its tithes are handled, listing seven leniencies that flow from the underlying assumption that most amei ha-aretz do in fact tithe — so demai's obligations are only rabbinic.
- Demai 1:3More cases exempt from demaiThese exemptions turn on intended use: because demai is only a rabbinic doubt, produce bought for purposes other than human eating was never swept into the decree.
- Demai 1:4Eruv, blessings, and separating demaiThe mishnah keeps building the picture of demai as a light, doubt-based category: because it is technically edible to the poor and most amei ha-aretz tithe, it may serve uses that truly forbidden food cannot.
- Demai 2:1Produce that betrays its Land-of-Israel originThe whole tractate turns on demai — produce bought from an am ha-aretz that must be tithed out of doubt; this mishnah names foods so distinctively Israeli that the doubt follows them anywhere.
- Demai 2:4Bakers, shopkeepers, and bulk sellersThis mishnah governs who, when selling demai, must separate its tithes and who may pass that duty to the buyer; the shopkeeper rule is the practical core of how demai moves through the marketplace.
- Demai 3:1Demai for the poor, the troops, and the charity collectorsDemai is produce bought from an am ha-aretz that may or may not have been tithed; out of doubt the buyer must tithe it himself. This whole tractate works through that doubt, and the perek opens with the people for whom the Sages waived it.
- Demai 3:2Trimming, returning, and when you may not let go of demaiThe whole chain of cases in this mishnah turns on a single rule of demai: a person may not let doubtfully-tithed produce out of his hand and into circulation, because someone else may eat it untithed. Even discarding leaves counts as letting it go.
- Demai 4:1The Shabbat leniencyThe whole tractate turns on produce bought from an am ha-aretz, which the buyer must tithe out of doubt. This perek explores the rare moments such a seller is believed — and Shabbat is the first.
- Demai 4:3Naming the poor man's tithe of demaiThe case is specifically demai — doubtfully tithed produce bought from an am ha-aretz. Because the doubt is only rabbinic and a poor person could anyway not force a payment on doubt, the question of the poor man's tithe is treated more leniently here than in produce known to be untithed.
- Demai 5:1How to tithe the baker's breadProduce bought from a baker is demai — we are unsure the baker tithed it — so the buyer must separate the tithes himself out of doubt. The whole chapter walks through how to do this cleanly.
- Demai 5:6Don't tithe across two purchasesA grain merchant stocks grain from many farmers, so two separate purchases may come from different sources — one tithed, one not. Tithing across them could draw from exempt onto obligated produce, the recurring demai danger.
- Demai 5:11Tithing between demai and untithed produceDemai behaves like the pot without a hole in the last mishnah — obligated only by doubt, the lighter status. Produce known to be untithed is the heavier, Torah-level status. The whole rule turns on never separating the lighter for the heavier.
- Demai 6:7When a tither's grapes mix with a non-tither'sBecause the two crops were poured together, we can no longer be sure which grapes are whose. The non-tither's untithed share lurks in the mixture, so whatever the tither holds is treated as demai and must be tithed out of doubt.
- Demai 6:9Splitting an am ha-aretz father's produceBecause the father was an am ha-aretz, everything he left is doubtfully-tithed (demai) and held to be ritually impure. That status is exactly what constrains how the heirs may divide the estate.
- Demai 6:12A chaver shopping for an am ha-aretzThe whole question is whether the am ha-aretz's item is demai. When the chaver buys both bunches without marking which is whose, we may say the one handed over was always the am ha-aretz's, so it stays exempt — no demai worry attaches.
- Demai 7:1A guest who tithes by a declaration before ShabbatThe whole tractate is about produce one is unsure was tithed. Here the guest cannot rely on his host, so the food is treated as demai that the guest must tithe himself.
- Demai 7:3The worker, the dried figs, and the set-aside figA laborer paid in figs cannot rely on his employer to have tithed them, so the figs are demai he must fix while still earning his wage.
- Demai 7:5Declaring on figs at home while awayThe contrast is the whole point: demai needs a lighter formula than certainly untithed produce, since terumah is presumed already given and the second tithe is only doubtfully owed.
- Terumot 11:8Three last drops, and how little must be carried to the kohenDemai is produce of an unreliable seller, doubtfully tithed; because the obligation here is only a doubt, a tiny quantity may simply be set aside rather than carried.
- Ma'asrot 2:1Take figs — gift versus 'bring home'Because the giver claimed (by directing them home) that he had tithed the figs, but an am ha-aretz cannot be trusted, the result is doubtful produce — demai — needing only its limited separations.
- Ma'aser Sheni 3:3Redeeming tithe money onto a friend's produceDemai is produce bought from someone untrusted about tithing, where the tithe-status is only a doubt. Because the coins may not really be second tithe at all, the leniency allows the arrangement even with an am ha-aretz.
- Ma'aser Sheni 3:6When the wall locks produce inDemai is doubtfully-tithed produce, whose second tithe rests only on a doubt. Because its obligation is uncertain, the strict wall-rules are relaxed: untithed demai may pass through the city, leave, and have its second tithe redeemed outside.
- Ma'aser Sheni 5:15Abolishing the declaration, wakers, and knockersThe tractate ends on demai, doubtfully-tithed produce: Yochanan's standardized procedure meant a buyer no longer had to interrogate the seller, closing Maaser Sheni on the practical handling of tithes in everyday commerce.
- Challah 4:6Separating challah for demaiBecause demai's challah is only a rabbinic doubt, the Sages eased it — one standing pure portion can cover many later demai doughs, even ones not beside it.
- Shabbat 2:7Three things to ask at home before ShabbatTithing demai, produce of doubtful tithing status bought from an am ha-aretz, is permitted even at twilight, unlike tithing produce that certainly needs it.
- Shabbat 18:1Clearing room for guestsDemai (doubtfully-tithed produce) may be moved because the poor are permitted to eat it as-is, so it qualifies as food.
- Eruvin 1:10Warp, woof, and the soldiers' exemptionsDemai — produce bought from someone not trusted on tithes — normally requires tithing out of doubt. The camp exemption shows how far the Sages relaxed their own decrees for soldiers.
- Eruvin 3:2Demai, tithes, and who carries the eruvDemai is technically forbidden until tithed, yet it anchors an eruv — because in a pinch the poor may eat it, it counts as edible food for this purpose.
- Pesachim 2:5Grains that fulfill the matzah obligationDemai is produce that may not have been tithed. It still serves for matzah, because the poor may be fed demai, and anyone could give up his property and become poor.
- Sukkah 3:5Disqualifications of the etrog — originDemai's whole legal personality — forbidden to you, yet permitted to the poor — decides this dispute: Beit Hillel count that sliver of permitted eating as enough to make the etrog "yours."
- Makhshirin 2:10Produce on the road and a mixed storehouseDemai is produce of uncertain tithe-status; the buyer must separate the tithes himself out of doubt. An even split between the two practices leaves the find in exactly this doubt.