Principle
Safekסָפֵק
SA-FEK
Doubt — halachic uncertainty
Halachic doubt — a state in which the law's application is genuinely uncertain. Safek is treated rigorously: in matters of Torah-level prohibitions, doubt obligates strict behavior (safek d'Oraita le-chumra); in rabbinic matters, doubt obligates the lenient ruling (safek d'Rabbanan le-kula). For lineage, Rabbi Eliezer holds that safek-classes (shtuki, asufi) cannot marry vadai-classes — the doubt cuts both ways — while the first view in Kiddushin 4:3 permits all who are barred from the kahal to marry one another.
Where it comes up
62 mishnayot
- Pe'ah 4:11Grain in the ant holesRabbi Meir applies a presumption in favor of the poor: where it is genuinely doubtful whether grain is gleanings, it is treated as gleanings — a recurring rule that resolves uncertainty toward the gift.
- Terumot 8:8Guard it, expose it, or leave it beThe case is a genuine safek tum'ah — it is uncertain whether this jar became impure. Because its status hangs in the balance, the sages dispute whether to protect it like pure terumah or expose it like impure terumah.
- Orlah 3:9Doubtful orlah, and how far each law reachesThe closing mishnah hangs on doubt. Whether doubtful orlah is forbidden or permitted depends entirely on location, and the rule for it abroad is itself part of the Sinaitic tradition — making doubt the organizing idea of the whole mishnah.
- Shabbat 19:3Bathing the babyA doubtful obligation of circumcision does not push aside Shabbat, since only a certain mitzvah overrides it.
- Eruvin 3:4The eruv that rolled awayThe dispute is a classic question of doubt: when the facts at twilight are unknown, do we rule stringently from both directions, or lean on the eruv's prior intact status?
- Nazir 2:8If his wife miscarriedA miscarriage leaves a doubt (safek): was the fetus ever viable, in which case the vow took effect, or not? The mishnah splits on how to treat that uncertainty — the first view resolves it leniently, Rabbi Shimon stringently.
- Nazir 8:1Two nazirs, one doubtThe whole chapter turns on safek — genuine halachic doubt. Here the doubt is over WHICH of two people became impure, and the elaborate offering procedure exists to discharge every obligation despite that uncertainty.
- Nazir 8:2Layered doubts, stretched-out daysThis mishnah stacks TWO doubts at once — doubtful corpse-impurity and doubtful confirmed tzara'at. The whole timetable of sixty and a hundred-twenty days exists because each doubt must be handled without violating the others.
- Nazir 9:4When uncertainty turns strictSafek — halachic doubt — is the thread of this whole chapter. Here the rule flips by timing: a doubtful skin-affliction is pure at the outset, but once impurity has taken hold, the same doubt is ruled impure.
- Kiddushin 4:2Father unknown — Abba Shaul's leniencyWith only his mother known, his lineage is in doubt: he may be a mamzer, which is what the next mishnah weighs.
- Kiddushin 4:3Certain with certain is permitted; doubtful with anything is notA doubtful one, whose father is unknown, a foundling or a Samaritan, may really be of good lineage, so he may not marry one who is certainly a mamzer.
- Bechorot 1:3Doubt cases: how many lambs to giveBecause it is unknown whether the male or female emerged first, the case is a monetary doubt — and the owner keeps the lamb since the kohen cannot prove his claim.
- Bechorot 2:6Whose lamb when both heads emerge togetherThe leftover lamb is a doubtful firstborn — possibly the firstborn, possibly not. Because of that doubt it cannot be slaughtered unblemished; it grazes until it develops a blemish, then may be eaten.
- Bechorot 2:7Two ewes and their newbornsHere a doubt enters: one ewe may have borne the female first, making her male no firstborn. Only one male is certainly a firstborn, so just one goes to the kohen and the rest is settled by the dispute below.
- Bechorot 2:8When only one ewe is first-timeOnly the ewe that had never given birth can produce a firstborn, but we cannot tell which male is hers. One male is certainly the kohen's; the doubt over which one drives the dispute below.
- Bechorot 2:9Neither is a firstbornRabbi Tarfon is in genuine doubt over which of the two, if either — the one born through the side or the one after — counts as a firstborn. Because of the doubt, neither can be given to the kohen or slaughtered as holy, so both graze until blemished.
- Keritot 4:1The doubt that brings a guilt-offeringThe whole perek turns on doubt: a real doubt whether one did a sin punished by being cut off is exactly what the guilt-offering for a doubt is for.
- Ohalot 7:4The first house is doubtful, the second certainImpurity under one roof is decided house by house, so everything depends on where the dead child began to come out — and no one can say whether it had already begun in the first house. That open question is what leaves the first house impure only out of doubt, and the rest of the mishnah supplies the evidence that can settle it.
- Ohalot 16:2Worked cases of the three measures, then suspect moundsMounds are a classic case of doubt about a corpse's impurity: no one can see inside, so the Sages set rules for when to suspect a hidden grave.
- Ohalot 16:4Amah by amah, down to rock or virgin soilThe digging method resolves the doubt: only by reaching rock or virgin soil can he be sure no grave lies hidden below.
- Ohalot 16:5Stopping points and fields cleared bone by boneA natural or public barrier ends the doubt: since no one buries in a riverbed or public road, the search may halt there.
- Ohalot 17:3When plowing does not create a doubtful fieldBeit ha-peras is a rabbinic decree made out of doubt, imposed only on the common case of a single known grave being plowed. A field where the grave was lost is already a double doubt, and the unusual cases here fall outside the decree, so no fresh doubtful field is declared.
- Ohalot 18:9Colonnades, a ruined city, and towns the Sages clearedDoubt is the basis of the rabbinic impurity throughout this perek; here the Sages formally resolve a standing doubt about Akko's land in favor of purity.
- Negaim 5:1Every doubt about marks is pureSafek — halachic doubt — is the engine of this whole chapter. The default for marks of tzara'at is unusual: where most areas of law treat doubt strictly, here doubt almost always falls to the lenient side.
- Negaim 5:4Two men, one undecided spreadingThis restates the chapter's principle with its key qualifier: a doubt is pure only 'at the start,' before the case is bound to impurity. Once it is, the doubt flips strict.
- Negaim 5:5Both men impure — until both shrink backHere the same doubt that was lenient in 5:4 becomes strict. The mishnah is showing the precise hinge: once impurity is genuinely established, the doubt flips from pure to impure.
- Parah 8:1How one guard's keeping covers for the otherWhen both guards become impure at once, no fit guard is left to keep the water, so it is invalid for certain, not a matter of doubt.
- Parah 11:2Doubt, suspense, and the latticesThe comparison between doubt in terumah and doubt in the water of purification structures this whole mishnah — the water follows the terumah model but resolves doubt more strictly.
- Parah 12:2When doubt about the sprinkling invalidates itDoubt recurs throughout Seder Tohorot; here, doubt about whether the sprinkled water came from the hyssop itself is decisive enough to invalidate the whole act.
- Tohorot 2:1The woman pickling terumahTwo doubts pull opposite ways: a doubt about one who immersed that day is treated strictly (so the vegetables are lost), but a doubt about hands leniently (so the pot is spared).
- Tohorot 3:5Impurity is assessed at the moment of discoveryThis is a master rule for resolving doubt: when we cannot reconstruct the past, the present state we discover is treated as the state all along. The rest of the mishnah applies it to several cases.
- Tohorot 3:6The deaf-mute, the person without understanding, and the minorHere a doubt arises in a private domain, where doubtful impurity is normally ruled impure. The mishnah introduces the great exception: when the person in doubt cannot be asked, the doubt is resolved as pure.
- Tohorot 3:7A child with graveyard-liliesEven though the lilies suggest the child went into the impure area, a child cannot be asked — so the doubt is resolved as pure, applying the principle of the previous mishnah.
- Tohorot 3:8Dough, hens, and the clever dogEven when there was room to dry their beaks, we cannot know that they actually did. But hens cannot be asked, so this doubt about impurity is resolved leniently as pure.
- Tohorot 4:1The thrown loaf or keyThis whole perek turns on doubts about impurity. Here the doubt is resolved leniently because one who throws is treated like one who cannot be asked.
- Tohorot 4:3Passing past versus settled on the groundThis is the contrast case that sharpens the whole principle. Once the impurity settles on the ground and a person 'who can be asked' is unsure of his contact, the ordinary rule for doubtful impurity kicks in and the doubt is ruled impure.
- Tohorot 4:8Floating impurityFloating impurity is the model case of impurity with no fixed resting place — it drifts on the water's surface. So a doubt whether a person touched it is ruled pure, just like the passing-impurity cases earlier in the perek.
- Tohorot 4:9How so? The liquid casesThe lenient half: a doubt whether impure liquid defiled something else is ruled pure, because liquids defiling other things is only a rabbinic stringency.
- Tohorot 5:1The creeping creature, the frog, and two pathsThis is the textbook case of a doubt about impurity: a real doubt about whether he became impure. The whole chapter turns on how such doubt is resolved in a public versus a private place.
- Tohorot 5:2Doubtful touching, doubtful objectBoth cases are doubts about contact rather than location. The mishnah deliberately contrasts a doubt of touching with the earlier doubt of walking, because the two are resolved differently.
- Tohorot 5:3When the food stays pure — and when it is burnedThe setup is two doubtful walks by one person. Because each path on its own is treated as pure, the food handled after each can be pure — as long as the doubts are never weighed together.
- Tohorot 5:5Asked apart or asked togetherTwo men split between the two paths means one of them certainly walked the impure one. Whether that certainty counts depends entirely on how their cases are brought before the Sages.
- Tohorot 5:6The same dispute, now by eatingAs with the two paths, one of the two men certainly took in the impure loaf. The mishnah pairs this rabbinic-level doubt with the Torah-level path-doubt to show the same resolution applies to both.
- Tohorot 5:7Three doubts in a public placeThis establishes a master rule for resolving a doubt about impurity: it is judged as at the time it is found, not by guessing backward to an earlier moment.
- Tohorot 6:1Doubt follows the domain it arose inThe whole chapter rests on one rule: a doubtful impurity in a private domain is treated as impure, in a public domain as pure. Here the same spot flips between both, so the verdict flips with it.
- Tohorot 6:2Standing, passing, and two domainsIn the first two cases one stands while the other passes by; in the last two the impurity and the pure party stand in different domains. In all four the standard private-versus-public verdict is contested.
- Tohorot 6:4Even a chain of doubts follows the domainEven a long chain of compounded doubts — doubt upon doubt — does not soften the verdict: the domain alone decides, strictly in private and leniently in public.
- Tohorot 6:5A doubt about entry, in the rainy seasonThe man is sure he crossed the valley but cannot say whether his path took him into the one impure field — the precise "doubt about entering" that Rabbi Elazar declares pure.
- Tohorot 8:4Left locked, found openA locked house found open is a classic doubt: someone clearly entered, but did they touch the pure things? Rabbi Meir resolves the doubt strictly, the Sages leniently.
- Tohorot 9:9Separated clumps, the roof and vat, the burnt creatureBoth clauses resolve a doubt by timing. A dead creature found in the vat was there before the olives were carried up to the roof, so the roof olives are retroactively impure; but one found on the roof gives no reason to suspect the vat below.
- Tohorot 10:6A doubtful spray of spitThis is a classic case of a doubt about impurity: when it is genuinely uncertain whether the impurity reached the wine, the doubt is resolved leniently and the contents stay pure.
- Niddah 2:2When blood is foundA delayed sighting cannot be pinned to the moment of relations, so the case is a doubt: they are treated as impure to be stringent, yet exempt from the offering that only a certain sin would require.
- Niddah 3:2Is it blood? Is it a fetus?When the fetus's sex cannot be determined, she falls under a doubt and must keep the stringencies of both a male and a female birth at once.
- Niddah 3:3A sac — fluid or formedThe embryo's sex cannot be known, so she keeps the stringencies of both — impure like a female birth but with the shorter pure-days of a male.
- Niddah 3:4Sandal and afterbirthBoth the sandal and the afterbirth imply a fetus of unknown sex, so she keeps the doubtful combined schedule of a male and a female birth.
- Niddah 3:6Doubt upon doubtShe knows it was a fetus but not its sex, so she keeps the doubtful combined schedule — impure like a female birth, with the shorter pure-days of a male.
- Niddah 4:1Samaritans and their beddingThe whole leniency turns on the doubt: we do not know whether the Samaritan woman was truly menstruating, and a doubtful impurity is not strong enough to trigger Temple liability or the burning of terumah.
- Niddah 7:5The reach and limit of credibilityThe closing rule generalizes the whole list: wherever the matter is one the Samaritans are not careful about — Shabbat boundaries, wine poured to an idol, doubtful corpse-impurity — their testimony carries no weight.
- Niddah 9:1Standing vs. sittingRabbi Yosei is lenient precisely because the source of the blood is uncertain: a doubt resolved toward purity.
- Niddah 9:2Whose blood is it?There is a compound doubt — was the blood the man's or the woman's, and was it uterine or from a wound — and Rabbi Yosei resolves the double doubt toward purity.
- Niddah 10:8The woman who saw blood on the eleventh dayThe case is left in doubt: only a later sighting would join the days into a discharge, so the impurity and the offering stay in suspense until it is known.
- Yadayim 2:4Doubt about the hands is resolved as pureThis mishnah is the rule of doubt for hands. Unlike Torah-level doubts, every doubt about the impurity of hands is resolved leniently — the hands are pure.