Seder Kodashim · 15 mishnayot
Kinnimקִנִּים
Kinnim, "bird-pairs," closes Seder Kodashim. Some people, such as a poor woman after childbirth, owed a bird-pair: two turtledoves or two young pigeons, one bird a sin-offering and one a burnt-offering. The two went to opposite places on the altar, the sin-offering's blood below a red line around its middle and the burnt-offering's above. Birds look alike, so once one woman's birds were mixed with another's, no one could tell them apart. The first chapter sets out which pairs are owed and which are vowed gifts, all burnt-offerings, and counts how many birds stay valid in each kind of mix-up. The second follows birds that fly from one woman's pair to another's, back and forth and down a row of women. The third asks what stays valid when the kohen offered mixed birds without asking first. It closes with a woman's vow and a ladder of doubts, and with Rabbi Shimon ben Akashya's teaching that the elders of Torah grow more settled in mind as they age.
Also known as Kinim and Qinnim.
The frameworkיְסוֹד הַדִּין
Perek 1חַטָּאת הָעוֹף
"The bird sin-offering" — the framework
SimanMixed bird pairsתַּעֲרוֹבוֹת
Two things help before you start. Some offerings could be brought as birds instead of animals: a pair of turtledoves or young pigeons. A poor woman after childbirth, for example, owed such a pair, one bird a sin-offering and one a burnt-offering, and the two had opposite places on the altar: a sin-offering's blood went below a red line around its middle, a burnt-offering's above. And birds look alike, so once they got mixed up no one could tell them apart. The perek sets out which pairs are owed and which are gifts, then counts how many birds stay valid when they get mixed together.
- 1:1Obligatory vs. freewill — the foundationWhere a bird sin-offering and a bird burnt-offering are performed on the altar, what an obligatory pair and a freewill pair contain, and how a vow differs from a freewill offering: the grammar of the whole tractate.Simanחטאת העוף נעשית למטה — above or below
- 1:2A sin-offering mixed into obligatory pairsA sin-offering bird mixed with a burnt-offering dooms every bird, even one in ten thousand; a single sin-offering or burnt-offering bird mixed into obligatory pairs leaves valid only the pairs' own number of that offering, whatever the ratio.Simanחטאת שנתערבה בעולה — chatat mixed with olah
- 1:3Equal numbers, unequal numbersWhen two women's obligatory pairs get mixed with each other: with equal numbers half are valid and half invalid, and with unequal numbers only the smaller number is valid.Simanחובה שנתערבה — two obligations mixed
- 1:4When stipulation mattersIf two women bought their pairs together, Rabbi Yosei says the kohen may offer the sin-offering and the burnt-offering for whichever woman he chooses.Simanמשם אחד / משני שמות — one type or two
Flights & errorsפְּרִיחָה וְטָעוּת
Perek 2קֵן סְתוּמָה
"The unassigned pair" — flights and crossings
SimanFrom pair to pairמִקֵּן לְקֵן
One idea helps before you start. In a pair whose birds are not yet named the sin-offering and the burnt-offering, a stray does limited damage; a bird already named carries its role with it. A bird that flies into another woman's birds can no longer be told apart. The perek counts what each flight costs: from pair to pair, back and forth between two women, down a row of seven, and between a named sin-offering and a named burnt-offering. It ends with two rules: a pair's birds must be of one kind, and what heirs bring when a woman dies.
- 2:1Lost or dead — the recovery rulesIf a bird of an unassigned pair flew into the air, flew among birds that must die, or died, a new partner is taken for the one left; if it flew among birds to be offered, it is invalid and makes one opposite it invalid.Simanקן סתומה שפרח — a bird flies off
- 2:2The first crossing — between two stocksTwo women each have two unassigned pairs: the first flight across and the first flight back each cost a bird on each side, and after that nothing more is lost, since even fully mixed at least two valid pairs remain.Simanפרח מזו לזו — back and forth
- 2:3Cascading flights — the seven-women caseA bird flies down a row of seven women's pairs and one flies back: each round costs pairs, and after three rounds only the seventh has any left.Simanלזו אחת לזו שתים — seven women's pairs
- 2:4One unassigned pair beside one designated pairWhen a bird flies from an unassigned pair to a designated one, only that bird is lost; when one flies back, or one from the designated pair flies first, they must all die.Simanקן סתומה וקן מפרשת — unassigned & assigned
- 2:5Sin-offering, burnt-offering, and a pair betweenBirds flying between a sin-offering, a burnt-offering and an unassigned pair, then why a pair's two birds must be of one kind, and what the heirs bring when a woman dies.Simanסתומה באמצע — the middle pair
Perek 3בְּכֹהֵן נִמְלָךְ
"The kohen who decides without asking" — and the closing of Kodashim
SimanSplitting above & belowלְמַעְלָה וּלְמַטָּה
Two ideas help before you start. The first perek said what to do with mixed-up birds when the kohen asks first; this one asks what counts if he simply offered them without asking. And place matters: a sin-offering belongs below the red line on the altar and a burnt-offering above, and a pair whose birds are not yet named takes their roles from where the kohen put them. The perek counts what stays valid for mixed pairs and for named birds, and ends with a woman's vow, a ladder of doubts, and the closing teaching of Kodashim: elders of Torah grow more settled in mind with age.
- 3:1The kohen who did not consultWhen a kohen who did not consult offers two women's equal sets of mixed pairs all above, all below, or half above and half below, half the birds are valid and half invalid.Simanכהן שאינו נמלך — the unconsulted kohen
- 3:2The rule: when a woman's birds are splitUnequal numbers offered all above or all below leave half valid and half invalid; offered half above and half below, where no division keeps each woman's pairs on one side, the larger number is valid.Simanהמרבה כשר — uneven counts
- 3:3A sin-offering for one, a burnt-offering for the otherOne woman's sin-offering mixed with another woman's burnt-offering: offered both above or both below, half are valid, but one above and one below, both are invalid, since the sin-offering may have gone above and the burnt-offering below.Simanחטאת לזו ועולה לזו — chatat and olah pairs
- 3:4Only the unassigned pair survivesA sin-offering, a burnt-offering, an unassigned pair and a designated pair, mixed: done half above and half below, only the unassigned pair stays valid.Simanסתומה ומפרשת — four kinds mixed
- 3:5Half valid, or less than halfOnly the obligatory birds' own sin-offerings are valid: half when the birds left hold twice as many sin-offerings as burnt-offerings, less than half when they hold twice as many burnt-offerings; likewise for a burnt-offering bird.Simanחובה שנים בחטאת — doubled ratios
- 3:6A mother's vow — and the close of KodashimThe tractate's climax piles doubt upon doubt over a mother's extra vow, closing with the teaching that Torah scholars grow wiser with age.Simanכשאלד זכר / קולו שבעה — vowed pair, seven voices