Kinnim 3:5קִנִּיםHalf valid, or less than half: which offering is doubled
A sin-offering bird mixed with unassigned obligatory pairs
The question
When a chatat or olah mixes into obligation pairs in unequal ratios, how many birds are valid?
Two parallel sets of three rulings: a chatat mixed into chovah pairs, then an olah mixed into chovah pairs.
Tap a Hebrew word for its meaning. Tap a bold phrase to see the words it translates.
1Chatat in chovah: its chatat count
Back to a rule from the first chapter, now counted out.
חַטָּאת שֶׁנִּתְעָרְבָה בְחוֹבָה, אֵין כָּשֵׁר אֶלָּא מִנְיַן חַטָּאת שֶׁבַּחוֹבָה.
A sin-offering [bird] that got mixed up with obligatory [pairs]: only the number of sin-offerings in the obligatory [pairs] is valid. That can come to half the birds, or to less.
Concepts here
1 note
חַטָּאת שֶׁנִּתְעָרְבָה בְחוֹבָה
- This rule was already stated in perek 1 — when a designated sin-offering bird is mixed with obligatory pairs (each obligatory pair containing one sin-offering and one burnt-offering), the only thing salvaged is the count of sin-offering birds within the obligatory pairs.
- Sometimes that count works out to exactly half valid, sometimes it works out to less than half. The mishnah now spells out which is which.
Bartenura
2Chovah double the chatat
First case: the obligatory birds left hold twice as many sin-offerings as burnt-offerings.
חוֹבָה שְׁנַיִם בְּחַטָּאת, מֶחֱצָה כָשֵׁר וּמֶחֱצָה פָסוּל.
[If] the obligatory [birds] are double in sin-offering — say, two sin-offerings and a burnt-offering are left of two pairs, with the stray among them — half are valid and half are invalid: of the four birds, two are offered, as sin-offerings.
1 note
חוֹבָה שְׁנַיִם בְּחַטָּאת
- "The obligatory [birds] are double in sin-offering" means the obligatory pairs now hold double in sin-offerings: two obligatory pairs mixed with one stray sin-offering bird, where the kohen has already offered one of the obligatory birds as a burnt-offering above.
- What remains is two sin-offering birds plus one leftover burnt-offering, with the original loose sin-offering hidden among them — four birds total to sort out.
- He cannot offer the leftover burnt-offering, since maybe it is the loose sin-offering; and he cannot offer a third sin-offering, since the bird he takes may be the leftover burnt-offering.
- So he can only offer two sin-offerings. Result: two birds valid (the two true sin-offerings), two birds invalid (the leftover burnt-offering and the inserted sin-offering) — exactly half.
Bartenura
3Chatat double the chovah
Second case: they hold twice as many burnt-offerings, and less than half are valid.
וְחַטָּאת שְׁנַיִם בְּחוֹבָה, הַמִּנְיָן שֶׁבַּחוֹבָה כָּשֵׁר.
and [if] the sin-offering is double in the obligatory [birds] — say, a sin-offering and two burnt-offerings are left of two pairs, with the stray among them — the number in the obligatory [birds] is valid: just the one sin-offering left in them, one bird of the four.
The picture The picture in words
- A burnt-offering was already offered from the two pairs, so two sin-offerings, one burnt-offering and the stray are left. He may offer two sin-offerings. The burnt-offering might be the stray, and a third sin-offering might be the bird owed as a burnt-offering, so half are valid.
- Here a sin-offering was already offered, so two burnt-offerings, one sin-offering and the stray are left (Bartenura). He may offer only one sin-offering. A burnt-offering might be the stray, and a second sin-offering might be a bird owed as a burnt-offering, so only one of the four is valid.
1 note
חַטָּאת שְׁנַיִם בְּחוֹבָה
- "The sin-offering is double in the obligatory [birds]" — per Bartenura, two obligatory pairs with one designated sin-offering mixed in, where the kohen has already offered one sin-offering of the obligatory pairs below.
- What remains: two burnt-offerings and one sin-offering of the obligatory pairs, with the loose sin-offering among them — four birds.
- He cannot offer the two burnt-offerings, since he might take the loose sin-offering; and he cannot offer two sin-offerings, since he might take the bird that is left to be a burnt-offering.
- So he can only offer one sin-offering — one valid bird out of four. That is what the mishnah means by "the number in the obligatory [birds] is valid": the obligatory birds' smaller count, which here comes to less than half.
Bartenura
4Olah in chovah: its olah count
The same two cases, for a burnt-offering bird mixed into obligatory pairs.
וְכֵן עוֹלָה שֶׁנִּתְעָרְבָה בְחוֹבָה, אֵין כָּשֵׁר אֶלָּא מִנְיַן עוֹלוֹת שֶׁבַּחוֹבָה.
And likewise a burnt-offering [bird] that got mixed up with obligatory [pairs]: only the number of burnt-offerings in the obligatory [pairs] is valid. Again, that can come to half, or to less.
Concepts here
1 note
וְכֵן עוֹלָה שֶׁנִּתְעָרְבָה בְחוֹבָה
- The entire mishnah's logic mirrors over for the burnt-offering and the obligatory birds. The two cases — the obligatory birds double in burnt-offering, and the burnt-offering double in the obligatory birds — produce the same divide.
Bartenura
5Chovah double the olah
Mirror case: the obligatory birds left hold twice as many burnt-offerings, and half are valid.
חוֹבָה שְׁנַיִם בְּעוֹלָה, מֶחֱצָה כָשֵׁר וּמֶחֱצָה פָסוּל.
[If] the obligatory [birds] are double in burnt-offering — say, two burnt-offerings and a sin-offering are left of two pairs, with the stray among them — half are valid and half are invalid: of the four birds, two are offered, as burnt-offerings.
1 note
חוֹבָה שְׁנַיִם בְּעוֹלָה
- Same as the sin-offering case mirrored. With two obligatory pairs and one inserted burnt-offering, after one sin-offering of the obligatory pairs has already been offered, four birds remain: the kohen can offer two burnt-offerings but cannot risk the rest. The fraction comes out to half valid.
Bartenura
6Olah double the chovah
Second mirror case: they hold twice as many sin-offerings, and less than half are valid.
עוֹלָה שְׁנַיִם בְּחוֹבָה, הַמִּנְיָן שֶׁבַּחוֹבָה כָּשֵׁר:
[if] the burnt-offering is double in the obligatory [birds] — say, a burnt-offering and two sin-offerings are left of two pairs, with the stray among them — the number in the obligatory [birds] is valid: just the one burnt-offering left in them, one bird of the four.
1 note
עוֹלָה שְׁנַיִם בְּחוֹבָה
- Parallel to the case of the sin-offering double in the obligatory birds — only one burnt-offering can be safely offered, leaving most of the birds invalid.
- The takeaway: when the obligatory birds that remain hold twice as many of the mixed-in bird's own type, exactly half is valid; when the double is of the opposite type, the valid count drops below half.
Bartenura
Summary
Perek 1 taught that when a sin-offering bird is mixed into obligatory pairs, only as many birds as the pairs' own sin-offerings are valid. Mishnah 5 shows what fraction that comes to in two opposite cases. When the obligatory birds left hold twice as many sin-offerings as burnt-offerings, say two sin-offerings and a burnt-offering with the stray among them, two of the four birds are offered: exactly half. When they hold twice as many burnt-offerings, only the one sin-offering left is offered: one bird of four, less than half. The mishnah then gives the same two cases for a burnt-offering bird mixed into obligatory pairs. Throughout, a bird is offered only when it cannot be the wrong one.