Principle

Tnaiתְּנַאי

T'NAI

Stipulation — a formal condition

A formal condition attached to a halachic act (kiddushin, get, sale, gift). If the condition is met, the act is valid; if not, it never took effect — retroactive nullification. The structural template (tnai kaful) requires both sides stated explicitly: "If X happens, this stands; if X doesn't happen, this is void." Most tnai disputes turn on whether all formal requirements were satisfied — partial conditions don't bind.

Where it comes up

19 mishnayot

  1. Eruvin 3:5The conditional eruvThe mishnah lets the eruv's identity hang on a future event — a working condition whose outcome retroactively reveals which deposit was the real eruv at twilight.
  2. Eruvin 3:8Rabbi Yehudah's basket and eggRabbi Yehudah leverages the calendar doubt itself: since one of the two days is certainly a weekday, a condition makes the terumah take effect on whichever day is the weekday.
  3. Megillah 3:2Selling a synagogue — on what termsRabbi Meir hangs the whole sale on a stipulation of return — for him selling it outright would treat it as worthless, so the community may never fully let the building go.
  4. Gittin 7:3A bill of divorce timed to deathThe whole mishnah hinges on how a husband words his condition. "If I die," with no "from now," pins the divorce to a moment after death — too late to divorce.
  5. Gittin 7:5"On condition you give me 200 zuz""On condition" is the key conditional formula. It works like "from now": the divorce takes effect at once, and the payment merely fulfills a condition already attached.
  6. Gittin 7:7A bill of divorce tied to a journeyEverything turns on how he worded his condition: "if I do not return within thirty days." Coming back early means the condition was not met, so the bill of divorce never takes effect.
  7. Gittin 7:8"From now" rescues the bill of divorceThe single phrase "from now" reverses the outcome of the previous case. It makes the bill of divorce take effect from the moment of giving, so when the twelve months close without his return, the divorce is read back to before his death.
  8. Gittin 9:9A rumor of betrothal or divorceA conditional divorce is the model alternative explanation: the rumor "he divorced her" may rest on a bill of divorce given on a condition that was never met — so the report does not establish that she is actually divorced.
  9. Kiddushin 2:2When the betrothal gift turns out to be something else"On condition that" turns the betrothal into a formal condition — the act stands or falls with it. From here through Mishnah 5, the perek explores what counts as a binding condition.
  10. Kiddushin 2:5Two grounds for voiding marriage — vows and blemishes"On condition" makes the no-vows claim a formal condition. When it fails, the betrothal fails entirely — the cleanest case in this Mishnah.
  11. Kiddushin 3:1The deceitful friend and the delayed betrothalOne way to read his words is as a condition: "betrothed from now, on condition that I do not take it back within thirty days." How a condition's words are read is the perek's main question.
  12. Kiddushin 3:2Betrothal on a condition: paying, having, showingThe perek's main kind of condition: "on condition that" — the betrothal holds only if what he promised comes true.
  13. Kiddushin 3:3Betrothal on a condition: landThe same "on condition that" as the money cases in the last mishnah, but now the fact he claims is about land.
  14. Kiddushin 3:4The sons of Gad and Reuven: the model for every conditionThe mishnah turns from cases to the condition itself: what a condition must say to count.
  15. Kiddushin 3:5When a betrothal doesn't take hold — and when it doesTo make a betrothal depend on her family or wealth, he must say so as a condition when he betroths her; regret afterward is not a condition.
  16. Kiddushin 3:6Betrothal on a condition: deeds and a father's consentA condition of service: what he promises is a deed, speaking for her and working for her, not a payment.
  17. Bava Metzia 7:6Who can waive the right to eatThe worker's Torah right to eat is a default that a stipulation can override: he may set a condition trading the right to eat for higher pay — but only for those legally competent to agree to such a condition.
  18. Bava Metzia 7:10Accident, fault, and changing the termsBefore he takes the animal, each guardian may make a condition that frees him from his usual liability: an unpaid guardian from swearing, a borrower from paying, the paid guardian and renter from both, since he agreed to guard only on those terms.
  19. Bava Metzia 7:11The rules of a valid conditionThis mishnah states the basic rules for any condition. The first: a condition that runs against the Torah is void.