Shevuot 2:4שְׁבוּעוֹתThe positive mitzvah concerning a menstruating woman
The contrasting case — a menstruating woman
The question
What is the positive mitzvah regarding a niddah for which one is liable?
A question, then a single case answering it, with its reason.
Tap a Hebrew word for its meaning. Tap a bold phrase to see the words it translates.
1Which mitzvah of niddah?
The contrast to the previous mishnah: a positive mitzvah for which the court IS liable.
וְאֵיזוֹ הִיא מִצְוַת עֲשֵׂה שֶׁבַּנִּדָּה שֶׁחַיָּבִין עָלֶיהָ,
And which is the positive mitzvah concerning a menstruating woman, for which they are liable? Here, unlike the Temple case, a court that rules wrongly does bring a bull-offering.
Concepts here
1 note
וְאֵיזוֹ הִיא מִצְוַת עֲשֵׂה שֶׁבַּנִּדָּה
- This question deliberately mirrors the previous mishnah's "positive mitzvah of the Temple, for which they are NOT liable."
- Bartenura: the two cases are alike — in each, he entered permissibly and the impurity arose while he was inside.
- A niddah is a woman in her menstrual state, forbidden to her husband. The matching positive mitzvah is the duty to separate from her once impurity sets in.
- Here, by contrast, if beit din (the court) ruled in error on this mitzvah, they ARE liable to bring the communal bull-offering — because its inadvertent violation carries a fixed sin-offering.
Bartenura
2Withdrawing at once: liable
The case: her period begins mid-act and he withdraws at once.
הָיָה מְשַׁמֵּשׁ עִם הַטְּהוֹרָה וְאָמְרָה לוֹ נִטְמֵאתִי, וּפֵרַשׁ מִיָּד, חַיָּב, מִפְּנֵי שֶׁיְּצִיאָתוֹ הֲנָאָה לוֹ כְּבִיאָתוֹ:
If he was having relations with a pure woman, and she said to him, "I have become impure," — her period had just begun — and he withdrew at once, he is liable — he should have stayed still until he was no longer aroused — because his withdrawal gives him pleasure, as his entry does.
2 notes
וּפֵרַשׁ מִיָּד
- At the moment she becomes a niddah, continued contact is forbidden. But pulling out instantly, while still aroused, is itself a pleasurable act of relations with a niddah — so an immediate withdrawal incurs liability.
- What he must do instead: hold still, without movement, until arousal subsides, and only then separate — so that the withdrawal carries no forbidden pleasure.
- This is the "positive mitzvah of the niddah": the prescribed manner of separating.
Bartenura
שֶׁיְּצִיאָתוֹ הֲנָאָה לוֹ כְּבִיאָתוֹ
- The principle: withdrawing gives the same forbidden enjoyment as entering. Both are "relations" with a niddah.
- Because the inadvertent violation here carries a fixed sin-offering, an erroneous court ruling on this mitzvah DOES make beit din liable for the communal bull — the exact opposite of the Temple case in the previous mishnah.
Bartenura
Summary
This mishnah supplies the counterpart promised at the end of the previous one. There, the "positive mitzvah of the Temple" did not make the court liable for an erroneous ruling. Here, the "positive mitzvah concerning a menstruating woman" does. The case: a man is with his wife when her period suddenly begins mid-act. If he withdraws instantly, while still aroused, he is liable — because the withdrawal itself is as pleasurable, and therefore as forbidden, as the entry. He must instead remain still until arousal passes and only then separate. Since this violation carries a fixed sin-offering, a mistaken court ruling about it triggers the communal bull-offering.