Pe'ah 3:4פֵּאָהTwo disputes with Rabbi Yosei

Seed-onions and onion beds

The question

Do seed onions owe pe'ah, and do onion beds among vegetables each need their own?

Two disputes with Rabbi Yosei: the first opinion against him on seed onions, then the Sages against him on onion beds.

Tap a Hebrew word for its meaning. Tap a bold phrase to see the words it translates.

  1. 1Seed onions: Rabbi Yosei exempts

    Onions kept in the ground to grow seed are still liable for pe'ah; Rabbi Yosei exempts them.

    הָאִמָּהוֹת שֶׁל בְּצָלִים חַיָּבוֹת בְּפֵאָה, וְרַבִּי יוֹסֵי פּוֹטֵר.

    Mother onions — big onions left in the ground to grow seed — are obligated in pe'ah, the corner for the poor, but Rabbi Yosei exempts them, since after so long in the ground they are barely fit to eat.

    Concepts here

    2 notes

    הָאִמָּהוֹת שֶׁל בְּצָלִים

    • Bartenura: the "mother-onions" are large onions left in the ground to produce seed. Because they stay in the soil so long, they are barely fit to eat — only with difficulty.
    • Bartenura: for that reason Rabbi Yosei exempts them from pe'ah; in his view a crop barely edible is not real food.
    • Bartenura: but the halacha is not like Rabbi Yosei — the first opinion holds them liable.

    Bartenura

    חַיָּבוֹת בְּפֵאָה

    • Tosafot Yom Tov: the first opinion reasons that since ordinary onions, which were not left in the ground, are certainly food, the mother-onions kept for seed do not lose that status — they remain liable for pe'ah.
    • This contrasts with crops whose entire species is barely edible (like a certain dye-plant taught in mishnah 1:4), which are exempt; here the species itself is good food.
    • The halacha follows this first opinion, not Rabbi Yosei.

    Bartenura · Tosafot Yom Tov

  2. 2Onion beds: Rabbi Yosei, each

    Onion beds planted among other vegetables: Rabbi Yosei says a pe'ah from each bed.

    מַלְבְּנוֹת הַבְּצָלִים שֶׁבֵּין הַיָּרָק, רַבִּי יוֹסֵי אוֹמֵר, פֵּאָה מִכָּל אַחַת וְאֶחָת.

    Square beds of onions that are among the vegetables — onion plots set in a field of other greens — Rabbi Yosei says: pe'ah from each and every one — to him the greens are a different crop, which divides a field.

    The picture
    The picture in words

    Beds of onions are planted in a field of other vegetables. Rabbi Yosei says the other vegetables are a different crop, which divides a field, so each onion bed gives its own pe'ah.

    1 note

    מַלְבְּנוֹת הַבְּצָלִים שֶׁבֵּין הַיָּרָק

    • Bartenura: Rabbi Yosei holds that the surrounding vegetable counts as a different crop, and people do not normally set onion beds inside a field of other greens.
    • Bartenura: an earlier teaching (perek 2) established that a different crop interrupts a field. So for Rabbi Yosei each onion bed is its own field and gets its own pe'ah.
    • Bartenura: here too the halacha is not like Rabbi Yosei.

    Bartenura

  3. 3The Sages: one for all

    The Sages disagree: one pe'ah covers all the onion beds together.

    וַחֲכָמִים אוֹמְרִים, מֵאַחַת עַל הַכֹּל:

    But the Sages say: from one for the whole — one corner for all the beds; the greens between them do not divide.

    The picture
    The picture in words

    The Sages disagree with Rabbi Yosei. The vegetables between the onion beds do not divide them, so one pe'ah covers all the beds together.

    1 note

    וַחֲכָמִים אוֹמְרִים מֵאַחַת עַל הַכֹּל

    • Bartenura: the Sages hold the intervening vegetables do not divide the onion beds into separate fields, so a single pe'ah covers all the onion beds together.
    • Rambam: the halacha is not like Rabbi Yosei in either of his two rulings in this mishnah — neither exempting the seed-onions nor splitting the beds.
    • The unifying principle: only a genuine break makes scattered plantings count as separate fields.

    Bartenura · Rambam Commentary

Summary

This mishnah records two disputes with Rabbi Yosei. First, are "mother-onions" — onions left in the ground to grow seed and barely fit to eat — liable for pe'ah? The first opinion says yes, since onions are clearly food; Rabbi Yosei exempts them as scarcely edible. Second, when onion beds are set among other vegetables, Rabbi Yosei treats each bed as its own field needing its own pe'ah, while the Sages say one pe'ah covers them all. The shared question, as throughout the perek, is what truly counts as a single field and a single crop.