Eduyot 3:11עֵדֻיּוֹתThree lenient rulings on Yom Tov
Three leniencies of Rabban Gamliel
The question
Which three lenient rulings did Rabban Gamliel give?
A heading, three leniencies, then the Sages forbidding all of them.
Tap a Hebrew word for its meaning. Tap a bold phrase to see the words it translates.
1Three lenient rulings
Rabban Gamliel also gave three lenient rulings.
אַף הוּא אָמַר שְׁלֹשָׁה דְבָרִים לְהָקֵל.
He too said three things, to be lenient — Rabban Gamliel, who was strict in three other matters.
1 note
אַף הוּא אָמַר שְׁלֹשָׁה דְבָרִים לְהָקֵל
- Bartenura: the mishnah balances the previous one: just as Rabban Gamliel had three stringencies, so he had three leniencies.
- This mishnah is taught also in tractate Beitzah chapter 2.
- In these three festival matters Rabban Gamliel permits, while the Sages forbid.
Bartenura · Tosafot Yom Tov
2Sweeping, incense, roasted kid
The three: sweeping between the dining-couches, putting incense on coals, and a young goat roasted whole on the nights of Pesach.
מְכַבְּדִין בֵּין הַמִּטּוֹת, וּמְנִיחִין אֶת הַמֻּגְמָר בְּיוֹם טוֹב, וְעוֹשִׂים גְּדִי מְקֻלָּס בְּלֵילֵי פְסָחִים.
One may sweep between the couches, the floor where people reclined to eat; and one may set out incense on Yom Tov, frankincense on coals, for its smell; and one may make a young goat roasted whole on the nights of Pesach, its legs and innards hung at its side, recalling the Pesach offering.
1 note
מְכַבְּדִין בֵּין הַמִּטּוֹת ... גְּדִי מְקֻלָּס
- Bartenura: 'sweeping between the couches' means sweeping the floor where they reclined to eat.
- 'Mugmar' is frankincense placed on coals to give off a pleasant smell; everyone agrees it is forbidden to perfume vessels this way, but Rabban Gamliel permits it for a person's scent.
- 'Gedi mekulas' is a kid roasted whole with its legs and innards hung at its side, done in memory of the Pesach offering, as Scripture says 'its head with its legs and its innards' (Ex. 12:9). The word means 'helmeted,' like a warrior in full armor.
- Rambam describes the kid the same way, as the form of the Pesach lamb eaten in Jerusalem.
Bartenura · Rambam Commentary
3The Sages forbid
The Sages forbid all three.
וַחֲכָמִים אוֹסְרִים:
But the Sages forbid [all three]: sweeping, lest he level the floor; incense, a luxury few need; the goat, as it looks like sacred meat eaten outside the Temple.
1 note
וַחֲכָמִים אוֹסְרִים
- Bartenura: the Sages forbid all three. Sweeping, lest one come to fill in holes in the dirt floor; the incense, since it serves only the most pampered or one with a bad odor, not a general need; and the whole kid, since it looks like eating sacred offerings outside the Temple.
- So each leniency carries a concern that leads the Sages to forbid it.
- The halacha follows the Sages.
Bartenura
Summary
Balancing his three stringencies, Rabban Gamliel is recorded giving three lenient rulings for Yom Tov. He permits sweeping the floor between the dining-couches, placing incense on coals for its fragrance, and making a young goat roasted whole — its legs and innards hung at its side — on the nights of Pesach, recalling the Pesach offering. The Sages forbid all three: sweeping might lead to leveling holes in the dirt floor, the incense serves only the pampered rather than a general need, and the goat looks like eating a sacred offering outside the Temple.