Principle
kefelכֶּפֶל
KE-FEL
Double payment by a thief
Kefel is the double payment a convicted thief must make: he returns the stolen object (or its value) and pays an equal amount again as a fine, so the owner receives twice the value. It is the baseline penalty for theft and applies to movable goods — money, vessels, clothing, or any animal — once the theft is established by valid witnesses; slaves, documents, land and consecrated property carry no double payment (Bava Metzia 4:9). A thief who admits the theft on his own, before witnesses come, is exempt from kefel, since one who confesses to a fine is not made to pay it. Kefel is the floor; for a stolen ox or sheep that is then slaughtered or sold, the larger fourfold or fivefold payment replaces it.
Where it comes up
7 mishnayot
- Bava Kamma 7:1The double payment vs. four or five timesThe mishnah opens the chapter on theft by ranking the two fines: the double payment is the baseline fine owed by any caught thief, and the chapter spends its first units mapping exactly where it applies.
- Bava Kamma 9:8The guardian who swore it was stolenA guardian who falsely claims the deposit was stolen and is convicted by witnesses is treated as a thief, so he pays the double payment a caught thief owes.
- Bava Metzia 3:1The deposit, the oath, and the double paymentA convicted thief pays the double payment — twice the value. The chapter's question is who pockets that fine: here the guardian already paid the owner, so he steps into the owner's shoes and collects it.
- Shevuot 4:6Monetary claims for which a false oath of testimony is liableThe double payment a thief owes and the payment of four or five times the value are monetary penalties tied to the stolen principal, so testimony about them carries real financial stakes and the false oath is liable.
- Shevuot 6:5Slaves, documents, land, and consecrated property — outside the oathThe double payment for a thief does not apply to slaves, documents, land, or consecrated property, nor four or five times the value: one who steals them repays only what he took.
- Shevuot 8:3False claims that cost the unpaid guardian moneyThis is the chapter's payoff case: an unpaid guardian who clears himself with a false claim of theft and is then exposed by witnesses pays the double payment, exactly as a thief does — the rule derived from Shemot 22:7.
- Shevuot 8:4The thief in the marketplace and the four- or fivefold paymentA confirmed thief pays the double payment on the strength of witnesses alone — no oath required — which is exactly why this case differs from the guardian cases that drive the rest of the chapter.