Person

Ed echadעֵד אֶחָד

ED e-CHAD

A single witness

A single witness. As a rule one witness cannot establish a contested fact, since testimony normally requires two. But in certain areas the Sages accepted a lone witness — for example, to restore a captive woman's permitted status (where even a slave, maidservant, or minor may serve), and, according to some views, to confirm a man's priestly lineage where no challengers contest it. Ketubot perek 2 debates exactly when a single witness suffices for elevating a man to the priesthood.

Where it comes up

10 mishnayot

  1. Ketubot 2:6Two captive women: each testifying for the otherFor a captive woman the Sages were lenient and accepted even a single witness — including a woman — so each captive can serve as the lone witness vouching for the other.
  2. Ketubot 2:7And likewise two men: each vouching for the other as a kohenJust as one witness suffices for a captive, a single witness can elevate a man to priestly status — so each of the two can be the lone witness for the other.
  3. Ketubot 2:8Elevating to priesthood on a single witness — the disputeRabbi Yehudah is the strict view that rejects a lone witness for priesthood, anchoring the dispute that follows.
  4. Ketubot 2:9Captivity over money or lives; and a person cannot testify for himselfThe captive-leniency reappears: even a slave or maidservant, normally invalid, is accepted as the lone witness to a woman's purity.
  5. Ketubot 9:7When a woman collects her ketubah only by swearingA single witness cannot extract money on his own, but he can obligate the other party to swear. Here one witness claiming the ketubah was paid forces the woman to swear before she collects.
  6. Ketubot 9:8How so? The five cases, one by oneShe fully denies any payment, but one witness contradicts her. A lone witness cannot defeat her claim outright — yet his testimony is enough to force her to swear before collecting.
  7. Shevuot 4:11Hearsay testimony and disqualified witnesses bring no liabilityLiability depends on the witnesses' knowledge being legally usable. Testimony by hearsay ('a witness from the mouth of a witness') or from a disqualified person could never establish the claim, so falsely denying it carries no offering.
  8. Shevuot 7:2One who was robbed — when witnesses saw the break-inThe whole enactment rests on testimony: because witnesses saw the defendant enter to seize collateral without right, his denial is undercut and the robbed party may swear and collect.
  9. Shevuot 7:7Just as the Sages said — the parallel oaths to collectA single witness cannot decide money, but he can shift the oath: where one witness says the ketubah was paid, the woman must swear before she may collect.
  10. Eduyot 6:1Five received traditionsNormally Torah law requires two witnesses, yet to free a woman whose husband's death is unconfirmed the Sages accept a single witness. This testimony preserves that exceptional leniency.