Chullin 9:8חֻלִּיןA limb hanging from a person
The same dangling limb, now on a person
The question
What is the impurity status of a limb or flesh dangling from a person?
Two rulings of pure, then Rabbi Meir and Rabbi Shimon on the limb after death.
Tap a Hebrew word for its meaning. Tap a bold phrase to see the words it translates.
1Dangling from a person: pure
A limb or flesh hanging loose from a living person is pure.
הָאֵבָר וְהַבָּשָׂר הַמְדֻלְדָּלִין בָּאָדָם, טְהוֹרִין.
A limb or flesh hanging loose from a person is [ritually] pure, for impurity comes from 'a man who dies' (Bamidbar 19:14), and he is alive.
Concepts here
1 note
הָאֵבָר וְהַבָּשָׂר הַמְדֻלְדָּלִין בָּאָדָם
- Bartenura: this concerns a limb or flesh hanging from a living person — even in a state where it can never heal and reattach.
- While still attached to the living person it conveys no impurity, since the verse speaks of impurity 'when a person dies' (Bamidbar 19:14), and this person is alive.
Bartenura · Tosafot Yom Tov
2After death: flesh pure
If the person died, the flesh is pure, since it counts as flesh separated from a living person.
מֵת הָאָדָם, הַבָּשָׂר טָהוֹר.
If the person died — his death counts as tearing the flesh away while he lived — the flesh is pure.
1 note
מֵת הָאָדָם הַבָּשָׂר טָהוֹר
- Bartenura: death 'severs' the dangling part, so it is treated as flesh that separated from the living person — which is pure — rather than as part of the corpse.
Bartenura
3The limb: Rabbi Meir
The dangling limb conveys impurity as a limb from a living person, not as a limb from a corpse — Rabbi Meir.
הָאֵבָר מְטַמֵּא מִשּׁוּם אֵבָר מִן הַחַי וְאֵינוֹ מְטַמֵּא מִשּׁוּם אֵבָר מִן הַמֵּת, דִּבְרֵי רַבִּי מֵאִיר.
The limb makes impure as a limb from a living [person], but not as a limb from a corpse, for his death counts as tearing it away while he lived; these are the words of Rabbi Meir.
The picture The picture in words
The person’s death counts as tearing the hanging limb off while he lived, so Rabbi Meir calls it a limb from the living, not from a corpse. Both kinds make one impure by touch, carrying or sharing a roof. They differ in flesh that falls off, which is pure from a living person’s limb and impure from a corpse’s (Bartenura).
Concepts here
1 note
הָאֵבָר מְטַמֵּא מִשּׁוּם אֵבָר מִן הַחַי
- Bartenura: a complete limb severed from a living person conveys impurity by contact, by carrying, and by overshadowing (ohel), just as a limb from a corpse does.
- But an olive-bulk of flesh, or a barley-grain of bone, that separates from such a limb is pure — unlike the same separating from a limb of a corpse, which is impure.
Bartenura
4Rabbi Shimon: pure
Rabbi Shimon rules pure the flesh or bone that separates from such a limb, even when it counts as a limb from a corpse.
וְרַבִּי שִׁמְעוֹן מְטַהֵר.
But Rabbi Shimon rules [it] pure. He holds that flesh or bone coming off a limb, even a corpse's limb, is pure.
1 note
וְרַבִּי שִׁמְעוֹן מְטַהֵר
- Bartenura: Rabbi Shimon rules pure with a limb from the dead just as with a limb from the living — he holds that flesh or a bone separating from such a limb does not convey impurity either way.
- Bartenura: the halacha does not follow Rabbi Shimon.
Bartenura · Tosafot Yom Tov
Summary
The closing mishnah carries the dangling-limb question over from animals to people. A limb or piece of flesh torn from a living person but still hanging is pure while he lives, because corpse impurity attaches only 'when a person dies' (Bamidbar 19:14). When the person does die, the dangling flesh is still pure: death is treated as having severed it beforehand, so it counts as flesh separated from a living person rather than part of the corpse. The dangling limb, however, conveys impurity in its prior status — as a limb from the living — but not as a limb from a corpse, the view of Rabbi Meir. Rabbi Shimon rules pure the flesh or bone that separates from such a limb in either case.