Chullin 9:7חֻלִּיןA limb hanging loose

A limb left dangling on a living animal

The question

What is the impurity status of a limb or flesh dangling from an animal?

A ruling, Rabbi Meir versus Rabbi Shimon on slaughter, a ruling on death, then Rabbi Meir versus Rabbi Shimon on the limb.

Tap a Hebrew word for its meaning. Tap a bold phrase to see the words it translates.

  1. 1Dangling: food impurity

    A limb or flesh hanging loose from a live animal conveys food impurity in place, but first needs to be made susceptible.

    הָאֵבָר וְהַבָּשָׂר הַמְדֻלְדָּלִין בִּבְהֵמָה, מְטַמְּאִין טֻמְאַת אֳכָלִין בִּמְקוֹמָן, וּצְרִיכִין הֶכְשֵׁר.

    A limb or flesh hanging loose from an animal — torn, but still partly attached — can make [things ritually] impure as food while still in place, and needs to be made susceptible [to impurity] by getting wet, like any food.

    Concepts here

    3 notes

    הָאֵבָר וְהַבָּשָׂר הַמְדֻלְדָּלִין

    • Bartenura: a limb (flesh, sinew, and bone together) or just flesh has been torn from the animal but still clings to it slightly.
    • A detached limb of a live animal conveys impurity like a carcass; detached flesh of a live animal is wholly pure. Here they are still attached.

    Bartenura

    מְטַמְּאִין טֻמְאַת אֳכָלִין בִּמְקוֹמָן

    • Bartenura: if one intends the dangling limb or flesh as food for a gentile, it becomes food that can receive impurity and convey it to other foods, even while still in place on the animal.
    • It cannot become impure on its own as a carcass until it is fully detached, but it can receive impurity from a creeping creature and pass it on.

    Bartenura

    וּצְרִיכִין הֶכְשֵׁר

    • Bartenura: hechsher is being made susceptible to impurity by contact with water or one of the seven liquids. The dangling flesh must be wet after it was loosened before it can become impure.
    • Once made susceptible, it can receive impurity from then on.

    Bartenura

  2. 2Rabbi Meir: blood made susceptible

    If the animal was slaughtered, its blood makes the dangling parts susceptible — so says Rabbi Meir.

    נִשְׁחֲטָה בְהֵמָה, הֻכְשְׁרוּ בְדָמֶיהָ, דִּבְרֵי רַבִּי מֵאִיר.

    If the animal was slaughtered, they were made susceptible by its blood, which wets them; these are the words of Rabbi Meir.

    2 notes

    נִשְׁחֲטָה בְהֵמָה

    • Bartenura: the act of slaughter cleared the dangling parts of conveying carcass impurity, because slaughter does not 'sever' a dangling limb — it stays part of the slaughtered animal.
    • Even though the dangling meat is forbidden to eat (as 'flesh torn in the field'), it is no longer a carcass.

    Bartenura

    הֻכְשְׁרוּ בְדָמֶיהָ

    • Bartenura: Rabbi Meir holds the blood that flowed at slaughter made the dangling parts susceptible to impurity, with no further wetting needed — just as the blood makes a slaughtered animal's own flesh susceptible.

    Bartenura

  3. 3Rabbi Shimon: not susceptible

    Rabbi Shimon says they were not made susceptible by the blood.

    רַבִּי שִׁמְעוֹן אוֹמֵר, לֹא הֻכְשָׁרוּ.

    Rabbi Shimon says: they were not made susceptible; they need wetting by some other liquid.

    1 note

    לֹא הֻכְשָׁרוּ

    • Bartenura: Rabbi Shimon holds the slaughter-blood does not make the dangling parts susceptible; they are made susceptible only once wet by another liquid.

    Bartenura

  4. 4If the animal died

    If the animal died on its own, the dangling flesh still needs to be made susceptible.

    מֵתָה הַבְּהֵמָה, הַבָּשָׂר צָרִיךְ הֶכְשֵׁר.

    If the animal died — its death counts as tearing the hanging flesh away first, so it is not a carcass's flesh — the flesh needs to be made susceptible.

    1 note

    מֵתָה הַבְּהֵמָה הַבָּשָׂר צָרִיךְ הֶכְשֵׁר

    • Bartenura: death 'severs' the dangling part — it is treated as though the limb or flesh had already fallen off before death, so it does not become a carcass along with the animal.
    • Detached flesh of a live animal is pure, so this flesh has only the potential for food impurity, and still needs to be made susceptible by a liquid.

    Bartenura · Tosafot Yom Tov

  5. 5The limb: Rabbi Meir

    The dangling limb conveys impurity as a limb from a living animal, not as a limb of a carcass — Rabbi Meir.

    הָאֵבָר מְטַמֵּא מִשּׁוּם אֵבָר מִן הַחַי וְאֵינוֹ מְטַמֵּא מִשּׁוּם אֵבַר נְבֵלָה, דִּבְרֵי רַבִּי מֵאִיר.

    The limb makes impure as a limb from a living [animal], but not as a limb of a carcass, for its death counts as tearing it away while the animal lived; these are the words of Rabbi Meir.

    The picture
    The picture in words
    1. When the animal died, its death counts as tearing the hanging limb off while it lived. So Rabbi Meir says the limb makes impure as a limb from a living animal, not as a carcass limb. The hanging flesh still needs wetting by a liquid before it can become impure.
    2. While the animal is alive, the hanging limb and flesh can take food impurity where they are, if he meant them as food, such as for a non-Jew (Bartenura). First a liquid must wet them, which makes food able to become impure.
    3. When the animal was slaughtered, the hanging limb is not part of a carcass (Bartenura). Rabbi Meir says the slaughter blood wetted it and made it able to become impure. Rabbi Shimon says the blood did not.

    Concepts here

    1 note

    הָאֵבָר מְטַמֵּא מִשּׁוּם אֵבָר מִן הַחַי

    • Bartenura: since death severs the dangling limb, it does not become a carcass-limb. It therefore conveys impurity only as a limb from the living.
    • A practical difference: flesh that separates from a limb-from-the-living is pure, whereas flesh that separates from a carcass-limb is impure like the carcass itself.
    • Bartenura: the halacha follows Rabbi Meir in both disputes of this mishnah.

    Bartenura · Tosafot Yom Tov

  6. 6Rabbi Shimon: pure

    Rabbi Shimon rules the dangling limb pure.

    וְרַבִּי שִׁמְעוֹן מְטַהֵר.

    But Rabbi Shimon rules it pure. He holds the hanging limb does not count as food, since even a non-Jew may not eat it.

    1 note

    וְרַבִּי שִׁמְעוֹן מְטַהֵר

    • Bartenura: Rabbi Shimon's purifying ruling refers back to the opening clause — he holds that while still attached to a living animal, the limb does not even convey food impurity.
    • His reason: only food one may permissibly feed a gentile counts as 'food' for impurity, and a dangling limb is forbidden as ever min ha-chai. Bartenura rules that the halacha does not follow him here.

    Bartenura · Tosafot Yom Tov

Summary

When a limb or piece of flesh is torn from a living animal but still dangles from it, it occupies a middle ground. As food it can convey food impurity even while attached, but only after being made susceptible by contact with a liquid. If the animal is then slaughtered, Rabbi Meir holds the slaughter-blood makes the dangling parts susceptible, while Rabbi Shimon says it does not. If instead the animal dies on its own, death is treated as having severed the dangling part beforehand, so it never becomes carcass-flesh; the flesh stays pure and still needs to be made susceptible. For the same reason the dangling limb, once the animal dies, conveys impurity only as a limb from a living animal, not as a limb of a carcass — the view of Rabbi Meir. Rabbi Shimon rules the limb pure even as food while it is still attached.