Chullin 7:6חֻלִּיןSinai, written in its place

Kosher animals only — or non-kosher too?

The question

Does the ban on the sciatic nerve apply to a non-kosher animal?

A ruling and Rabbi Yehudah's dissent, his proof from Yaakov's sons, then the Sages' answer.

Tap a Hebrew word for its meaning. Tap a bold phrase to see the words it translates.

  1. 1Kosher only; Rabbi Yehudah dissents

    The prohibition applies to a kosher animal but not a non-kosher one; Rabbi Yehudah says it applies even to a non-kosher animal.

    נוֹהֵג בִּטְהוֹרָה, וְאֵינוֹ נוֹהֵג בִּטְמֵאָה. רַבִּי יְהוּדָה אוֹמֵר, אַף בִּטְמֵאָה.

    [The ban on the sciatic nerve] applies to a kosher animal and does not apply to a non-kosher animal, which is already entirely forbidden. Rabbi Yehudah says: even to a non-kosher animal.

    1 note

    וְאֵינוֹ נוֹהֵג בִּטְמֵאָה

    • Bartenura: the first opinion holds the sciatic-nerve prohibition has no force on a non-kosher animal at all — the whole animal is already forbidden as non-kosher.
    • If one ate the nerve of a non-kosher animal, the view that the nerve imparts flavor would say he is flogged for eating non-kosher meat, not for the nerve; the view that it has no flavor exempts him entirely.
    • In a kosher animal the nerve itself is like mere wood, with no taste, and the Torah nonetheless made eating it punishable; in a non-kosher animal the nerve law does not apply.

    Bartenura

  2. 2Rabbi Yehudah's proof

    Rabbi Yehudah argues: the nerve was forbidden to Yaakov's sons while non-kosher meat was still permitted to them.

    אָמַר רַבִּי יְהוּדָה, וַהֲלֹא מִבְּנֵי יַעֲקֹב נֶאֱסַר גִּיד הַנָּשֶׁה, וַעֲדַיִן בְּהֵמָה טְמֵאָה מֻתֶּרֶת לָהֶן.

    Rabbi Yehudah said: was not the sciatic nerve forbidden from the time of Yaakov's sons (Bereishit 32:33), while non-kosher animals were still permitted to them? So its ban covers non-kosher animals too.

    1 note

    מִבְּנֵי יַעֲקֹב נֶאֱסַר

    • Bartenura: Rabbi Yehudah's proof — the nerve was already forbidden to the children of Yaakov, yet non-kosher animals were still permitted to them until the Torah was given at Sinai.
    • Since the nerve of a non-kosher animal was forbidden back then, when its meat was permitted, that prohibition never lapsed — so it should still apply to non-kosher animals today.

    Bartenura

  3. 3Said at Sinai, written here

    The Sages reply: the law was stated at Sinai, only recorded in its narrative place in the Yaakov story.

    אָמְרוּ לוֹ, בְּסִינַי נֶאֱמַר, אֶלָּא שֶׁנִּכְתַּב בִּמְקוֹמוֹ.

    They said to him: it was said at Sinai, but written in its place, in the story of Yaakov, to tell why it was forbidden.

    The picture
    The picture in words
    1. The Sages say the nerve was commanded at Sinai, when non-kosher animals were already forbidden. It is only written in its place, in the story of Yaakov, to tell why. So it does not apply to a non-kosher animal.
    2. Rabbi Yehudah says the nerve was forbidden to Yaakov’s sons, when even non-kosher animals were permitted to them. So the ban applies to a non-kosher animal too.
    1 note

    בְּסִינַי נֶאֱמַר, אֶלָּא שֶׁנִּכְתַּב בִּמְקוֹמוֹ

    • Bartenura: the Sages answer that the prohibition was commanded only at Sinai — Yaakov's sons were not actually warned against the nerve before then.
    • When Moshe came to set the Torah in order, he wrote this verse alongside the story of Yaakov and the angel — its narrative 'place' — so we would know why the nerve was forbidden.
    • So Rabbi Yehudah's proof falls: before Sinai the prohibition was not in force at all, for any animal. Bartenura rules that the halacha does not follow Rabbi Yehudah.

    Bartenura

Summary

The perek closes with a dispute over whether the sciatic-nerve prohibition reaches a non-kosher animal. The first opinion says no — the whole animal is already forbidden, so the nerve law has nothing to add. Rabbi Yehudah disagrees, arguing from history: the nerve was forbidden to Yaakov's sons (Bereishit 32:33) at a time when non-kosher meat was still permitted to them, so its prohibition must have covered non-kosher animals and never lapsed. The Sages answer that the law was in fact only commanded at Sinai; Moshe merely recorded it in its narrative place beside the story of Yaakov's struggle. On their reading it never bound the patriarchs at all.