Negaim 9:3נְגָעִיםWhy quarantine? Rabbi Yehudah ben Beteira saves the sages' ruling
A debate over a bright spot on a boil's scar
The question
Why quarantine a spot on a palm scar when no sign of impurity could seem to appear?
A question to Rabbi Eliezer, his ruling, two rounds of challenge, his admission, then Rabbi Yehudah ben Beteira's reason and Rabbi Eliezer's praise.
Tap a Hebrew word for its meaning. Tap a bold phrase to see the words it translates.
1A spot on a palm scar
A case put to Rabbi Eliezer: a bright spot the size of a sela on the palm, on a boil's scar.
שָׁאֲלוּ אֶת רַבִּי אֱלִיעֶזֶר, מִי שֶׁעָלְתָה לְתוֹךְ יָדוֹ בַּהֶרֶת כַּסֶּלַע וּמְקוֹמָהּ צָרֶבֶת שְׁחִין.
They asked Rabbi Eliezer: — a sage who taught only what he had received from his teachers — one on whose palm a bright spot the size of a sela came up, — a sela, a coin larger than a split bean — and its place is a boil's scar? So the boil's rules apply: one week, and only two signs.
Concepts here
2 notes
שָׁאֲלוּ אֶת רַבִּי אֱלִיעֶזֶר
- Rabbi Eliezer ben Hyrcanus was one of the great Tannaim of the generation after the Temple's destruction, a student of Rabban Yochanan ben Zakkai.
- The questioners bring him a tricky case to test the rule that a boil or burn is quarantined.
- Tosafot Yom Tov notes that Rabbi Eliezer would never state a law he had not received from his teachers — important for the exchange that follows.
Bartenura · Tosafot Yom Tov
בַּהֶרֶת כַּסֶּלַע וּמְקוֹמָהּ צָרֶבֶת שְׁחִין
- A baheret is the brightest, snow-white shade of a tzaraat-mark.
- A sela is a coin; here it measures the area of the baheret, larger than the minimum gris (split bean).
- The baheret sits entirely on the scar of a healed boil, so the lighter boil-law governs it.
- That setting is what makes the case puzzling: on a boil-scar the usual roads to impurity seem closed off, as the next lines press.
Bartenura · Rambam Commentary
2Rabbi Eliezer: quarantine
Rabbi Eliezer rules: quarantine him.
אָמַר לָהֶם, יַסְגִּיר.
He said to them: Let him be quarantined. For one week, as with any boil.
Concepts here
3Why? No sign can appear
They challenge: no sign can ever arise here — not white hair, not spreading, not healthy flesh.
אָמְרוּ לוֹ, לָמָּה, לְגַדֵּל שֵׂעָר לָבָן אֵינָהּ רְאוּיָה, וּלְפִשְׂיוֹן אֵינָהּ פּוֹשָׂה, וּלְמִחְיָה אֵינָהּ מִטַּמָּא.
They said to him: Why? It cannot grow white hair, — no hair grows on the palm — and as for spreading, it cannot spread, — it fills the scar, and a boil's mark does not spread into the skin of the body — and through healthy flesh it does not become impure. A boil has only two signs.
Concepts here
3 notes
לְגַדֵּל שֵׂעָר לָבָן אֵינָהּ רְאוּיָה
- The palm of the hand never grows hair, so white hair can never appear in this baheret.
- That closes off the first of the two signs available to a boil or burn.
- Bartenura states the point plainly: a palm simply does not grow hair, ever.
Bartenura
וּלְפִשְׂיוֹן אֵינָהּ פּוֹשָׂה
- A boil or burn does not spread into ordinary skin — exactly the rule of the previous mishnah.
- Since the baheret already fills the scar, there is nowhere within the boil for it to grow.
- So the second sign, spreading, also appears to be impossible here.
Bartenura
וּלְמִחְיָה אֵינָהּ מִטַּמָּא
- Michyah (a patch of healthy flesh) is not a sign for a boil or burn at all — our perek opened by listing only two signs, white hair and spreading.
- So the third sign cannot apply either.
- With all three roads closed, the questioners ask why a quarantine is worth anything.
Bartenura
4It may shrink and spread
Rabbi Eliezer answers: perhaps the spot will shrink and then spread again.
אָמַר לָהֶן, שֶׁמָּא תִכְנֹס וְתִפְשֶׂה.
He said to them: Perhaps it will shrink and [then] spread. The kohen, finding it smaller, would release him; if it then grew back over the scar, he would confirm him.
The picture The picture in words
- A sela-sized white spot fills a boil scar on his palm.
- It shrinks to a split bean, so the kohen sees it and releases him.
- Then it spreads again within the scar, and he is confirmed even after the release.
1 note
שֶׁמָּא תִכְנֹס וְתִפְשֶׂה
- Rabbi Eliezer answers that the large baheret could shrink toward the size of a gris.
- When the kohen sees it smaller at the end of the week, he releases the person.
- But then it could spread again within the boil whose area is a full sela — and spreading still defiles even after a release.
- So the quarantine is not pointless: it keeps the case open for this later spreading.
Bartenura · Rambam Commentary
5But it fills the scar
They press harder: but what if the boil's scar is only the size of a split bean?
אָמְרוּ לוֹ, וַהֲלֹא מְקוֹמָהּ כַּגְּרִיס.
They said to him: But what if its place is [only] the size of a split bean? Then the scar is no bigger than the spot, with no room to shrink and grow back.
1 note
וַהֲלֹא מְקוֹמָהּ כַּגְּרִיס
- Now they sharpen the case: suppose the boil-scar itself is only a gris, with the baheret filling all of it.
- Then there is no surrounding boil for it to shrink into and later spread back across.
- So Rabbi Eliezer's answer of "shrink and spread again" does not fit this smaller case.
- Tosafot Yom Tov notes the commentators differ on whether they are asking "why quarantine" or "should he quarantine at all" in this case.
Bartenura · Tosafot Yom Tov
6I have not heard
Rabbi Eliezer concedes he has heard no reason, though he still holds it is quarantined.
אָמַר לָהֶן, לֹא שָׁמַעְתִּי.
He said to them: I have not heard. He still holds it is quarantined, but no teacher gave him the reason.
1 note
לֹא שָׁמַעְתִּי
- Rabbi Eliezer holds that this smaller case is also quarantined, yet he admits he never received the reason why.
- Bartenura: he means "this one is quarantined too, but I have not heard the explanation for it."
- Tosafot Yom Tov stresses that he said "I have not heard," not "I do not know" — Rabbi Eliezer would never invent a law he had not received.
Bartenura · Tosafot Yom Tov
7Rabbi Yehudah ben Beteira asks
Rabbi Yehudah ben Beteira asks permission to offer a reason.
אָמַר לוֹ רַבִּי יְהוּדָה בֶן בְּתֵירָא, אֲלַמֵּד בּוֹ.
Rabbi Yehudah ben Beteira said to him: May I teach something about it? He asks leave to offer a reason.
1 note
אָמַר לוֹ רַבִּי יְהוּדָה בֶן בְּתֵירָא
- Rabbi Yehudah ben Beteira was a respected Tanna, here a younger colleague before Rabbi Eliezer.
- He asks permission to supply the missing reason for quarantining the small-scar case.
- Bartenura: "alamed bo" means "permit me to teach a point in this law."
Bartenura
8Only to uphold the sages
Rabbi Eliezer agrees — but only if it upholds the sages' ruling, not overturns it.
אָמַר לוֹ, אִם לְקַיֵּם דִּבְרֵי חֲכָמִים, הֵין.
He said to him: If it is to uphold the words of the Sages, yes. But not to overturn what he had received from his teachers.
1 note
אִם לְקַיֵּם דִּבְרֵי חֲכָמִים הֵין
- Rabbi Eliezer sets a condition: if Rabbi Yehudah's reason confirms the sages' ruling that quarantine is required, let him say it.
- But if it would teach that quarantine is not needed, he should stay silent.
- Bartenura: "I will not set aside what I received from my teachers to listen to you."
- It is a model of how a master guards received tradition while still welcoming a good supporting argument.
Bartenura
9Another boil may spread in
Rabbi Yehudah's reason: another boil might come up outside it, and the mark spread into it.
אָמַר לוֹ, שֶׁמָּא יִוָּלֵד לוֹ שְׁחִין אַחֵר חוּצָה לוֹ וְיִפְשֶׂה לְתוֹכוֹ.
He said to him: Perhaps another boil will come up outside it, and [the mark] will spread into it. A mark can spread from one boil into another, so spreading is still possible.
The picture The picture in words
- The scar is only a split bean, and the white fills it. Why quarantine?
- A new boil may come up right beside it.
- Then the white can spread into it, since a mark spreads from boil to boil (Bartenura).
Concepts here
1 note
שֶׁמָּא יִוָּלֵד לוֹ שְׁחִין אַחֵר חוּצָה לוֹ וְיִפְשֶׂה לְתוֹכוֹ
- Rabbi Yehudah supplies the missing reason: a new boil might form just outside the scar, and the mark then spread into the new boil.
- Although a boil's mark does not spread into ordinary skin, it does spread into another boil.
- So even a gris-sized scar keeps a live path to pisyon, which justifies the quarantine.
- Bartenura rules that this is the halacha — shechin spreads to shechin — and Rambam calls Rabbi Yehudah's statement true.
Bartenura · Rambam Commentary
10You are a great sage
Rabbi Eliezer praises him for confirming the sages' words.
אָמַר לוֹ, חָכָם גָּדוֹל אַתָּה שֶׁקִּיַּמְתָּ דִּבְרֵי חֲכָמִים:
He said to him: You are a great sage, for you have upheld the words of the Sages. A reason that upholds the tradition is worth more than a clever one against it.
1 note
חָכָם גָּדוֹל אַתָּה שֶׁקִּיַּמְתָּ דִּבְרֵי חֲכָמִים
- Rabbi Eliezer praises Rabbi Yehudah for supplying a reason that upholds the sages' ruling.
- Tosafot Yom Tov (citing Korban Aharon): giving a sound reason for the tradition is greater than cleverly arguing against it.
- A second reading: he is great for not letting the difficulties confuse him into overturning the received law.
- The mishnah closes the perek on this ideal — defending the tradition, not displacing it.
Bartenura · Tosafot Yom Tov
Summary
The perek ends with a vivid exchange. The sages bring Rabbi Eliezer a hard case: a bright spot the size of a sela on the palm, sitting on a boil's scar. He rules to quarantine. They object that no sign can ever arise here — the palm grows no hair, a boil's mark does not spread into ordinary skin, and healthy flesh is not a sign for boils at all. Rabbi Eliezer answers that the mark might shrink and later spread again, but when pressed on a scar only the size of a split bean he admits he has not received the reason. Rabbi Yehudah ben Beteira then supplies it: another boil could come up beside it, and the mark spread into it, since a mark spreads from boil to boil. Rabbi Eliezer praises him for upholding the Sages' ruling rather than overturning it.