Negaim 8:9נְגָעִיםLarge bright spot or small: a dispute

A dispute over the tips of the limbs

The question

If someone all white with healthy flesh blooms fully and then the limb tips return, how is he judged?

One case and two opinions: Rabbi Yishmael compares it to a large baheret, Rabbi Elazar ben Azariah to a small one.

Tap a Hebrew word for its meaning. Tap a bold phrase to see the words it translates.

  1. 1Rabbi Yishmael: a large baheret

    He came all white with a lentil of healthy flesh; it broke out over him, then his limb tips reappeared: Rabbi Yishmael likens it to a large bright spot.

    הַבָּא כֻלּוֹ לָבָן וּבוֹ מִחְיָה כָעֲדָשָׁה, פָּרְחָה בְכֻלּוֹ וְאַחַר כָּךְ חָזְרוּ בוֹ רָאשֵׁי אֵבָרִים, רַבִּי יִשְׁמָעֵאל אוֹמֵר, כַּחֲזִירַת רָאשֵׁי אֵבָרִים בְּבַהֶרֶת גְּדוֹלָה.

    One who comes [to the kohen] entirely white, with healthy flesh the size of a lentil in it: [if] it broke out over his whole body, and afterward the tips of the limbs reappeared on him, Rabbi Yishmael says: it is like the tips of the limbs reappearing in a large bright spot. The whole white body counts as one large mark, so he is only quarantined.

    Concepts here

    1 note

    רַבִּי יִשְׁמָעֵאל אוֹמֵר, כַּחֲזִירַת רָאשֵׁי אֵבָרִים בְּבַהֶרֶת גְּדוֹלָה

    • The case: the kohen had not yet confirmed the person when the bloom covered his whole body and then the limb-tips re-exposed.
    • Bartenura: Rabbi Yishmael likens him to one who came wholly white at the outset except for the limb-tips — a case that needs only hesger (quarantine), not condemnation.
    • 'Large baheret' here means treating the whole white body as the spot, so the re-exposed tips merely call for quarantine.

    Bartenura

  2. 2Rabbi Elazar: a small baheret

    Rabbi Elazar ben Azaryah likens it instead to a small bright spot — where the tips of the limbs reappearing make him impure.

    רַבִּי אֶלְעָזָר בֶּן עֲזַרְיָה אוֹמֵר, כַּחֲזִירַת רָאשֵׁי אֵבָרִים בְּבַהֶרֶת קְטַנָּה.

    Rabbi Elazar ben Azaryah says: it is like the tips of the limbs reappearing in a small bright spot. He compares it to a small spot with healthy flesh that broke out over him: there the tips showing again make him impure.

    The picture
    The picture in words

    He came all white with a lentil of healthy flesh, the white then covered it, and later his tips showed again. Rabbi Yishmael treats him like one who came all white, so he is quarantined. Rabbi Elazar ben Azaryah says the flesh alone would have confirmed him, so he is impure (Bartenura).

    1 note

    כַּחֲזִירַת רָאשֵׁי אֵבָרִים בְּבַהֶרֶת קְטַנָּה

    • Rabbi Elazar ben Azaryah reasons that since, had it not bloomed, the kohen would have confirmed him, his case is like a small baheret holding michyah.
    • In that comparison, if it had bloomed over the whole body and then the limb-tips re-exposed, he would be impure.
    • Bartenura develops the underlying logic about when re-exposed limb-tips condemn — only where the purity itself came 'through the practice of blooming.'
    • Rabbi Elazar ben Azaryah was the sage who for a time led the academy at Yavneh in place of Rabban Gamliel.

    Bartenura

Summary

This mishnah records a dispute over a borderline case: a person who came wholly white with a lentil-sized patch of healthy flesh, whose body the outbreak then covered completely, after which the tips of the limbs showed again. How is that classified? Rabbi Yishmael likens it to the tips of the limbs reappearing in a 'large bright spot' — treating the all-white body as the spot, so the case needs only quarantine. Rabbi Elazar ben Azaryah likens it instead to a 'small bright spot' with healthy flesh in it — where the tips showing again make him impure. The disagreement is whether he counts as one who came all white, or as one whose small spot broke out over him.