Menachot 13:9מְנָחוֹתWhen the animal is blemished or unspecified
Redeeming a blemished offering, and "one of my animals"
The question
What if a designated animal becomes blemished, or the consecrated animal was never specified?
Two exchanges of number and two of kind, each pair disputed by Rabbi, then three cases of unspecified consecration.
Tap a Hebrew word for its meaning. Tap a bold phrase to see the words it translates.
1One blemished bull: two
This ox got a blemish — with its redemption money he may bring two.
שׁוֹר זֶה עוֹלָה, וְנִסְתָּאֵב, אִם רָצָה, יָבִיא בְדָמָיו שְׁנָיִם.
"This ox is a burnt-offering," and it got a blemish — and was redeemed for money — if he wishes, he may bring two with its money. His vow was for this ox alone, so it lapsed with the blemish.
The picture The picture in words
- He said “this ox is a burnt-offering,” and it got a blemish and was redeemed. His vow was for this animal alone, so with its money he may bring two if he wishes.
- He vowed “an ox for a maneh” and brought two oxen worth almost a maneh each. Neither is the ox he vowed, so he has not fulfilled his vow.
Concepts here
1 note
וְנִסְתָּאֵב
- "Nista'ev" means a blemish befell it; Scripture calls a blemished animal "impure" (Vayikra 27:11), as that verse speaks of redeeming blemished offerings.
- Because he said "this ox," once it is blemished his vow lapses — he had no standing obligation beyond that one animal.
- So with its redemption money he may bring two animals if he likes, unlike the case earlier where a fixed vow of "an ox for a maneh" bound him to a single animal.
Bartenura
2Two blemished bulls: one
These two oxen got a blemish — with their money he may bring one.
שְׁנֵי שְׁוָרִים אֵלּוּ עוֹלָה, וְנִסְתָּאֲבוּ, אִם רָצָה, יָבִיא בִדְמֵיהֶם אֶחָד.
"These two oxen are a burnt-offering," and they got a blemish: if he wishes, he may bring one with their money. His vow was for these two alone, so it lapsed with the blemish.
1 note
יָבִיא בִדְמֵיהֶם אֶחָד
- The reverse case: he consecrated two specific oxen, and both became blemished.
- Since his vow was tied to those particular animals and has lapsed, he may bring a single animal with the combined redemption money if he wishes.
Bartenura
3Rabbi forbids merging
Rabbi forbids using the money for a different number of animals.
רַבִּי אוֹסֵר.
Rabbi [Yehudah HaNasi] forbids it. For him, the money may not buy a different number of animals.
1 note
רַבִּי אוֹסֵר
- Rabbi forbids buying a different number of animals with the money, two for one as well as one for two (Gemara 108b), but only at the outset; if one did so, it is valid after the fact, since he bears no continuing liability for the lapsed vow.
- The halachah does not follow Rabbi.
Bartenura
4Ram's money for a lamb
This ram became blemished — with its money he may bring a lamb.
אַיִל זֶה עוֹלָה, וְנִסְתָּאֵב, אִם רָצָה, יָבִיא בְדָמָיו כֶּבֶשׂ.
"This ram is a burnt-offering," and it got a blemish: if he wishes, he may bring a lamb with its money. The vow lapsed with the blemish, so he may change the kind of animal.
1 note
יָבִיא בְדָמָיו כֶּבֶשׂ
- Because the original vow lapsed with the blemish, he is free to spend the redemption money on a different species — here, a lamb in place of the ram.
Bartenura
5Lamb's money for a ram
This lamb became blemished — with its money he may bring a ram.
כֶּבֶשׂ זֶה עוֹלָה וְנִסְתָּאֵב, אִם רָצָה, יָבִיא בְדָמָיו אַיִל.
"This lamb is a burnt-offering," and it got a blemish: if he wishes, he may bring a ram with its money. Here too the vow lapsed, so he may change the kind.
1 note
יָבִיא בְדָמָיו אַיִל
- Likewise he may upgrade from a lamb to a ram with the redemption money, since he is no longer bound to the specific animal he vowed.
- Rabbi forbids switching from one species to another with redemption money, as in the earlier clause; the halachah does not follow Rabbi.
Bartenura
6Rabbi forbids switching
Rabbi forbids substituting one species for another.
רַבִּי אוֹסֵר.
Rabbi [Yehudah HaNasi] forbids it. For him, one kind may not be bought with another kind's money.
1 note
רַבִּי אוֹסֵר
- Rabbi forbids bringing one species with money that redeemed a different species.
- As before, the prohibition is only at the outset, and the halachah does not follow Rabbi.
Bartenura
7One of two: the larger
"One of my lambs is consecrated" and he has two — the larger is consecrated.
הָאוֹמֵר אַחַד מִכְּבָשַׂי הֶקְדֵּשׁ, וְאַחַד מִשְּׁוָרַי הֶקְדֵּשׁ, הָיוּ לוֹ שְׁנַיִם, הַגָּדוֹל שֶׁבָּהֶן הֶקְדֵּשׁ.
One who says, "One of my lambs is consecrated," or "One of my oxen is consecrated," and he had two: the larger of them is consecrated. One who consecrates gives generously, so he surely meant the better one.
1 note
הַגָּדוֹל שֶׁבָּהֶן הֶקְדֵּשׁ
- One who consecrates gives generously, so an unspecified consecration is assumed to fall on the choicest — "the choicest of your vows" (Devarim 12:11).
- If he has only two animals, the larger of the two is the consecrated one.
Bartenura
8One of three: the middle
If he has three, the middle one is treated as consecrated.
שְׁלשָׁה, הַבֵּינוֹנִי שֶׁבָּהֶן הֶקְדֵּשׁ.
[If he had] three, the middle one of them is consecrated. The largest is held holy, and the middle one too, since he may have meant the one better than the smallest.
The picture The picture in words
- With three animals, the middle one is treated as holy too.
- Bartenura explains that he waits for the middle one to get a blemish and redeems it onto the large one.
- Only the large one goes to the altar, so either way his gift holds.
1 note
הַבֵּינוֹנִי שֶׁבָּהֶן הֶקְדֵּשׁ
- With three animals, we cannot be sure whether the consecration fell on the largest (generous in the plain sense) or on the middle one (generous compared with the smallest).
- So both the large and the middle are treated as consecrated, and forbidden, to resolve the doubt safely.
- In practice only one is offered: the middle one is held until it develops a blemish and is then redeemed onto the large one, covering either possibility.
Bartenura
9Forgot which: the largest
Forgot which he chose, or his father told him and he does not know which — the largest is consecrated.
פֵּרַשְׁתִּי וְאֵינִי יוֹדֵעַ מַה פֵּרַשְׁתִּי, אוֹ שֶׁאָמַר, אָמַר לִי אַבָּא וְאֵינִי יוֹדֵעַ מָה, הַגָּדוֹל שֶׁבָּהֶן הֶקְדֵּשׁ.
"I specified [one], but I do not know which I specified," or he says, "My father told me, and I do not know which": the largest of them is consecrated. When one was singled out, it was surely the best.
1 note
הַגָּדוֹל שֶׁבָּהֶן הֶקְדֵּשׁ
- Here he knows a particular animal was consecrated — whether by himself (and forgotten) or by his father at death — but not which one.
- Because a definite animal was certainly intended, we resolve the doubt toward the largest, the one a generous consecration would have chosen.
- This differs from the three-animal case above, where no specific animal had ever been singled out.
Bartenura
Summary
When a person consecrates a specific animal as a burnt-offering and it becomes blemished, his vow was tied to that animal alone, so once it is redeemed he is free with the money: he may bring two in place of one, one in place of two, or even switch species — though Rabbi forbids changing the number or the kind of animal. The chapter then turns to vague consecrations: "one of my lambs" with two animals consecrates the larger; with three, the middle is treated as holy out of doubt; and when a definite animal was meant but forgotten — by oneself or by one's father — the largest is consecrated.