Keritot 3:8כְּרִיתוֹתThe dangling limb of an animal
Does a dangling limb defile?
The question
Does a limb still dangling from an animal make things impure?
Rabbi Akiva's second question, a reply from a human case illustrated by a Jerusalem practice, then a kal vachomer.
Tap a Hebrew word for its meaning. Tap a bold phrase to see the words it translates.
1A dangling animal limb
Rabbi Akiva further asked them: what is the law of a limb dangling from a living animal — does it impart impurity?
וְעוֹד שְׁאָלָן רַבִּי עֲקִיבָא. אֵבָר הַמְדֻלְדָּל בִּבְהֵמָה, מַהוּ.
And Rabbi Akiva further asked them: a limb dangling from an animal, what is [the law]? It hangs by a little flesh: is it impure like a limb cut from a living animal?
1 note
אֵבָר הַמְדֻלְדָּל בִּבְהֵמָה
- "Dangling" means mostly detached but still connected by a shred of flesh.
- The question: is it treated as fully severed — imparting impurity like a limb cut from a living animal, which defiles like a carcass?
Bartenura
2A person's dangling limb is pure
They had no tradition for an animal, but had heard that a dangling limb on a person stays pure.
אָמְרוּ לוֹ, לֹא שָׁמַעְנוּ. אֲבָל שָׁמַעְנוּ בְּאֵבָר הַמְדֻלְדָּל בְּאָדָם, שֶׁהוּא טָהוֹר.
They said to him: We have not heard [about that], but we have heard about a limb dangling from a person, that it is [ritually] pure. A limb cut off completely from a living person is impure like a corpse.
1 note
בְּאֵבָר הַמְדֻלְדָּל בְּאָדָם
- A limb fully cut from a living person defiles like a corpse, but one still partly attached stays pure.
- This is the precedent the sages offer, and from it they reason to the animal's limb.
Bartenura
3The boil patients' Pesach eve
Those with boils in Yerushalayim proved it, having the limb almost cut off by a doctor and then torn off on a thorn so no one became impure.
שֶׁכָּךְ הָיוּ מֻכֵּי שְׁחִין שֶׁבִּירוּשָׁלַיִם עוֹשִׂין, הוֹלֵךְ לוֹ עֶרֶב פֶּסַח אֵצֶל הָרוֹפֵא וְחוֹתְכוֹ עַד שֶׁהוּא מַנִּיחַ בּוֹ כִשְׂעֹרָה, וְתוֹחֲבוֹ בְסִירָה, וְהוּא נִמְשָׁךְ מִמֶּנּוּ,
For this is what those with boils in Yerushalayim would do, their limbs coming loose: one would go on the eve of Pesach to the doctor, and he would cut [the limb] until he left [only] a barley grain's worth [attached], so as not to be holding it when it came off; he would stick it on a thorn, and [the sick man] would pull himself away from it. So it tore off with no one touching it.
1 note
מֻכֵּי שְׁחִין שֶׁבִּירוּשָׁלַיִם
- People with boils whose limbs were dangling needed them removed before bringing the Pesach offering, lest the loose limb be repulsive at the festival.
- The doctor cut until only a barley-grain of flesh held it, so as not to defile himself at the moment of severing.
- The limb was then fixed on a thorn attached to the ground, and the afflicted person yanked himself away — tearing it off with no one touching it at the instant it separated.
Bartenura
4Both bring their Pesach
Both the afflicted man and the doctor then offered their Pesach, since neither had become impure.
וְהַלָּה עוֹשֶׂה פִסְחוֹ, וְהָרוֹפֵא עוֹשֶׂה פִסְחוֹ.
And that one would offer his Pesach [offering], and the doctor would offer his Pesach [offering]. Neither had become impure from the dangling limb.
Concepts here
5Another kal vachomer
Rabban Gamliel and Rabbi Yehoshua conclude, all the more so: if a person's dangling limb is pure, surely an animal's is too.
וְרוֹאִין אָנוּ שֶׁהַדְּבָרִים קַל וָחֹמֶר.
And we see that it follows all the more so. If a person, who can become impure while alive, has a pure dangling limb, surely an animal, which cannot, does too.
Concepts here
1 note
שֶׁהַדְּבָרִים קַל וָחֹמֶר
- A living person is susceptible to impurity, yet a limb dangling from him stays pure.
- An animal is not even susceptible to impurity while alive — so all the more so its dangling limb is pure.
Bartenura
Summary
Rabbi Akiva's second question to the same sages concerns purity: does a limb dangling from a living animal, held on only by a shred of flesh, impart impurity as if fully severed? Again they had no direct tradition, but reported that a dangling limb on a living person stays pure. They proved it from a practice in Yerushalayim: those afflicted with boils would have a doctor nearly cut the loose limb on Pesach eve, leaving a barley's worth of flesh, then impale it on a thorn and tear themselves free — so that neither doctor nor patient touched it at the moment of severing, and both could bring their Pesach offering. From this they reason, all the more so, that an animal's dangling limb is pure as well.