Keilim 4:1כֵּלִיםShards that cannot stand

When a shard's own weight tips it over: a vessel or not

The question

Can a clay shard that cannot stand upright still be a vessel?

A tipping shard is pure and stays pure when fixed, with Rabbi Yehudah dissenting; then a broken jar, Rabbi Yehudah against the Sages.

Tap a Hebrew word for its meaning. Tap a bold phrase to see the words it translates.

  1. 1A shard that cannot stand

    A shard that can't stand on its own — handle-weighted or point-tipped: pure.

    הַחֶרֶס שֶׁאֵינוֹ יָכוֹל לַעֲמֹד מִפְּנֵי אָזְנוֹ, אוֹ שֶׁהָיָה בוֹ חִדּוּד וְהַחִדּוּד מַכְרִיעוֹ, טָהוֹר.

    A shard that cannot stand because of its handle — a piece broken off at the handle, whose weight tips it over — or that had a point, and the point tips it over — on its underside — is pure, since a broken piece counts as a vessel only if it sits without support.

    Concepts here

    2 notes

    הַחֶרֶס שֶׁאֵינוֹ יָכוֹל לַעֲמֹד מִפְּנֵי אָזְנוֹ

    • Picture a chavit-fragment that broke off in the region of the handle. The shard itself is otherwise viable, but the handle's weight is on one side — so when you set the shard down, it tips over.
    • That fails the 2:2 test (a gistra must sit upright shelo mesumakhin — without external support).
    • So the shard is pure.
    • Bartenura's framing: it's specifically a piece that separated from the jug at the handle, NOT a whole jug whose handle just happens to be heavier than the body.

    Bartenura

    אוֹ שֶׁהָיָה בוֹ חִדּוּד וְהַחִדּוּד מַכְרִיעוֹ

    • Chiddud: a sharp protrusion on the underside. (Bartenura: "sharp at its bottom"; Rambam: "a knob jutting out from its base.")
    • "Makhri'o" — "unbalances it." The protrusion prevents the shard from sitting flat; it leans to one side.
    • Same logic as the handle case: it fails the upright-sitting test, so no vessel-status.
    • Tosafot Yom Tov flags that "makhri'o" reads more naturally with the handle case than with the chiddud-case, and quotes an alternative reading ("hadad" = the spout potters made for drinking) for the second clause.

    Bartenura · Tosafot Yom Tov

  2. 2Handle or knob removed: still pure

    Even after the handle is removed or the point broken off, the shard stays pure.

    נִטְּלָה הָאֹזֶן, נִשְׁבַּר הַחִדּוּד, טָהוֹר.

    If the handle was removed, [or] the point broke off, so it can now stand, it is [still] pure, since earthenware that was pure even for a moment can never become impure again.

    1 note

    נִטְּלָה הָאֹזֶן, נִשְׁבַּר הַחִדּוּד, טָהוֹר

    • Take the shard from unit 1 (pure, because it couldn't sit upright). Now break off the offending handle or knob.
    • Now the shard CAN sit upright. So you'd think — it has now climbed back into vessel-status as a gistra.
    • The Sages: no. Bartenura's principle: "a klei cheres (earthenware vessels) that was pure for one moment can never again become tamei (impure)."
    • This is the same shem-klei reasoning as 3:3 unit 2: once vessel-status departs, only kiln-firing can restore it. Removing the bad feature doesn't count as restoration.
    • Tosafot Yom Tov: this is even sharper than the cheres-she-nikav case of 3:3, because here the shard didn't even have a NEW HOLE — only a fixable structural blemish — and still doesn't recover.

    Bartenura · Tosafot Yom Tov

  3. 3Rabbi Yehudah: impure

    Rabbi Yehudah disagrees: once it can stand, it can become impure.

    רַבִּי יְהוּדָה מְטַמֵּא.

    Rabbi Yehudah rules it can become impure. He does not hold that once pure, it stays pure.

    The picture
    The picture in words

    This shard could not stand, because its handle tipped it over, so it was pure. Once the handle is removed it stands, but the Sages say it stays pure, since earthenware that was pure even for a moment never becomes impure again (Bartenura). Rabbi Yehudah rules it can become impure.

    1 note

    רַבִּי יְהוּדָה מְטַמֵּא

    • R. Yehudah: removing the blocking feature DOES restore the shard's vessel-status — it can now sit upright, so it's now a gistra.
    • Bartenura: "he doesn't hold the [Sages'] line that a klei cheres (earthenware vessels) pure-for-a-moment is forever pure."
    • Rambam: the halacha follows the Sages.

    Bartenura · Rambam Commentary

  4. 4Jar on its side: a dispute

    A broken jar that holds things only on its sides: Rabbi Yehudah declares it pure; the Sages rule it can become impure.

    חָבִית שֶׁנִּפְחֲתָה, וְהִיא מְקַבֶּלֶת עַל דָּפְנוֹתֶיהָ, אוֹ שֶׁנֶּחְלְקָה כְמִין שְׁתֵּי עֲרֵבוֹת, רַבִּי יְהוּדָה מְטַהֵר, וַחֲכָמִים מְטַמְּאִין:

    A jar that was broken, and it holds [things] on its sides — it can no longer stand, only lie on its side — or that split into something like two troughs — lengthwise — Rabbi Yehudah declares it pure, for a broken piece must sit on its base as the whole vessel did, and the Sages rule it can become impure, for vessels are sometimes set on their sides.

    The picture
    The picture in words

    This broken jar holds things only while lying on its side, or it split lengthwise into two troughs. Rabbi Yehudah declares it pure, because a broken piece must sit on its base as the whole jar did. The Sages say it can become impure, because vessels are sometimes set on their sides (Bartenura).

    Concepts here

    3 notes

    חָבִית שֶׁנִּפְחֲתָה

    • "Nifchatah" — a piece broke off. Specifically the bottom (Maharam quoted by Tosafot Yom Tov).
    • So the jar can no longer sit on its base. But: tilt it onto its curved side, and the side becomes a working bottom. The jar now holds content while lying on its side.
    • Same case if the jar split lengthwise — each half is now an open trough sitting on what used to be its outer wall.

    Bartenura · Tosafot Yom Tov

    רַבִּי יְהוּדָה מְטַהֵר

    • R. Yehudah's principle (Bartenura): 2:2 said a gistra must sit shelo mesumakhin — without support. But "sitting" means sitting on its shulayim (its original base), not on its sides.
    • So a jar resting on its tilted side fails the gistra test. Pure.
    • Rambam: the halacha does not follow R. Yehudah.

    Bartenura · Rambam Commentary

    וַחֲכָמִים מְטַמְּאִין

    • Sages: vessels are made to sit on their sides periodically too. So sitting on a side is a legitimate use, and a tilted-bottom jar is still functioning as a vessel.
    • Bartenura's reading: kelim asuyin le-hoshivan al dafnoteihen li-frakim.
    • So the broken-bottom jar (and the split-into-troughs jar) is still tamei (impure).
    • Rambam: the halacha follows the Sages.

    Bartenura · Rambam Commentary

Summary

Three cases on whether a damaged earthenware vessel still counts as a vessel. First: a shard that cannot stand, because its handle or a point on its underside tips it over, is pure, since a broken piece counts as a vessel only if it sits without support. Second: if the handle was removed or the point broke off, so that it can now stand, it is still pure, since earthenware that was pure even for a moment can never become impure again; Rabbi Yehudah rules it can become impure. Third: a jar that was broken and holds things only on its sides, or that split into something like two troughs: Rabbi Yehudah declares it pure, for a broken piece must sit on its base as the whole vessel did, and the Sages rule it can become impure, for vessels are sometimes set on their sides.