Keilim 2:8כֵּלִיםWhen small recesses count as a true "inside"
Three subtle cases of an inside: torch, lamp socket, water jug's comb
The question
Do small hollows like a torch cup or lamp cradle make a clay item a vessel?
Two rulings of susceptibility, then a dispute: Rabbi Eliezer purifies the jar's comb, the Sages declare it susceptible.
Tap a Hebrew word for its meaning. Tap a bold phrase to see the words it translates.
1The torch is susceptible
A clay torch can become impure, even though its pointed base cannot stand on its own.
הַלַּפִּיד, טָמֵא.
A torch — a clay bowl of oily rags, its pointed base set on top of a pole — can become impure. Its seat on the pole counts, though it cannot stand on its own.
1 note
הַלַּפִּיד
- A lapid was an outdoor light. A clay dish with a sharpened underside, used to spike onto the top of a tall wooden pole (kundes).
- Inside the dish: rags soaked in oil and pitch. Lit on top of the pole, it spread light over a wide area at night.
- You might assume it's pure — its pointed bottom prevents it from standing on its own.
- But the mishnah teaches: it has a fixed, designated place to sit (the top of the pole). That's enough to give it vessel-status. So it can become impure.
- Principle: a vessel's stability isn't measured in absolute terms but by whether it has a real intended seating-spot.
Bartenura
2The lamp's recessed cradle
A lamp's socket becomes impure through its inside, shallow as it is.
וּבֵית שִׁקְעוֹ שֶׁל נֵר, מִטַּמֵּא בַאֲוִיר.
And the socket of a lamp — a clay holder the lamp sits a little way down in — becomes impure through its inside. That shallow hollow counts as an inside.
2 notes
בֵית שִׁקְעוֹ שֶׁל נֵר
- Beit shik'o — "the place where it sinks in." A clay base or saucer with a small depression in which an oil-lamp sits, partially sunk.
- Most of the lamp protrudes above the saucer; only a small portion is sunk into the recess.
- You might think this isn't enough of an "inside" to count as a toch — the lamp isn't truly inside the saucer.
- The mishnah teaches: it IS considered a real toch. Even though only a bit of the lamp sinks in, the recess functions as a vessel and is defiled by airspace.
Bartenura
מִטַּמֵּא בַאֲוִיר
- "By airspace" — meaning a sheretz (dead creeping creature) suspended ABOVE the recess (without touching its walls) is enough to defile the saucer.
- The full klei-cheres airspace rule (2:1) applies.
- Practical consequence: the saucer must be guarded against any tum'ah (impurity) suspended above the recessed area, even if the cheap clay walls are clean.
Bartenura · Tosafot Yom Tov
3The jar's comb: a dispute
The comb of teeth around a water jug's mouth: Rabbi Eliezer declares it pure, the Sages impure.
הַמַּסְרֵק שֶׁל צַרְצוּר, רַבִּי אֱלִיעֶזֶר מְטַהֵר, וַחֲכָמִים מְטַמְּאִין:
The comb of a water jug — the ring of decorative teeth around the strainer at its mouth — Rabbi Eliezer declares it pure, and the Sages declare it impure. They differ over whether the space among the teeth counts as the jug's inside.
The picture The picture in words
Decorative clay teeth ring the strainer at the jug’s mouth, and a dead creeping creature hangs between them. The Sages count that space as the jug’s inside, so the jug is impure. Rabbi Eliezer says it is not its inside, so the jug stays pure.
3 notes
הַמַּסְרֵק שֶׁל צַרְצוּר
- A tzartzur was a common middle-eastern clay water-jar with a built-in strainer-mesh just below the mouth. The drinker would pour, and the mesh held back debris.
- Around the mouth, above the mesh, the jar had decorative pointed clay protrusions arranged like the teeth of a comb (masrek).
- The dispute: when an unclean creature is suspended in the airspace BETWEEN those teeth (above the mesh) — does that count as the inside (toch) of the jar?
- Visual: imagine a jar with a flat strainer-platform; around its edge, vertical clay teeth like a crown.
Bartenura
רַבִּי אֱלִיעֶזֶר מְטַהֵר
- R. Eliezer: pure. The teeth aren't a real "inside" — they're just decorative protrusions ringing the rim.
- The space between the teeth is open on all sides; it isn't truly contained.
- So a sheretz (dead creeping creature) in that space hasn't really entered the jar's inside.
Bartenura
וַחֲכָמִים מְטַמְּאִין
- The Sages: it can become impure. The teeth ARE a real toch.
- Their reasoning: the teeth bound a defined airspace above the mesh — that's the working "inside" of this jar.
- Bartenura: the halacha follows the Sages.
- Same toch-question that 2:6 asked about the titros, played out one mishnah later on a related design.
Bartenura · Tosafot Yom Tov
Summary
Three subtle cases that test what counts as an earthenware vessel's inside. A torch, a clay bowl with a pointed base set on a pole, cannot stand on its own, but its seat on the pole counts, so it can become impure. A lamp's socket holds only a little of the lamp, but that shallow hollow counts as an inside, and it becomes impure through it. And the decorative teeth around the strainer at a water jug's mouth: Rabbi Eliezer says the space among them is not the jug's inside, and the Sages say it is. Each case sharpens the rule: an inside needs a defined space, not just any inward shape.