Eduyot 4:12עֵדֻיּוֹתThe man beneath the gap

A person under the crack

The question

Does a person lying under a split roof carry corpse impurity across the gap?

A dispute: Beit Shammai say he does not; Beit Hillel say he does, with their reason.

Tap a Hebrew word for its meaning. Tap a bold phrase to see the words it translates.

  1. 1Beit Shammai: he doesn't

    A person lying under a crack in a ceiling: Beit Shammai say his body does not carry the impurity across; Beit Hillel say it does.

    אָדָם שֶׁהוּא נָתוּן תַּחַת הַסֶּדֶק, בֵּית שַׁמַּאי אוֹמְרִים, אֵינוֹ מֵבִיא אֶת הַטֻּמְאָה.

    A person placed beneath the crack of a porch roof split in two, with a corpse under one half and vessels under the other: Beit Shammai say: he does not bring the impurity [across], for only something with a handbreadth of hollow space can carry it.

    The picture
    The picture in words

    The roof split, with a corpse under one half and vessels under the other, so the open crack keeps the impurity from crossing. A man lies right under the crack. Beit Shammai say he does not carry the impurity across, since only a hollow space a handbreadth high can carry it.

    Concepts here

    1 note

    אֵינוֹ מֵבִיא אֶת הַטֻּמְאָה

    • Bartenura: the case is a roofed porch (achsadrah) whose ceiling cracked in two, with a corpse on one side and vessels on the other; normally the open gap blocks the impurity from passing across. A man then lies on the floor beneath the crack.
    • Beit Shammai (lenient): nothing brings the impurity across unless it has a hollow space a tefach (handbreadth) high — and a person's body lying there does not.
    • A "tent" (ohel) only conveys corpse-impurity when there is a tefach-high air space; a solid body lacks it.
    • This case appears in tractate Ohalot ch. 11.

    Bartenura · Rambam Commentary

  2. 2Beit Hillel: a person is hollow

    Beit Hillel: a person is hollow, and his upper side carries the impurity across.

    וּבֵית הִלֵּל אוֹמְרִים, אָדָם חָלוּל הוּא, וְהַצַּד הָעֶלְיוֹן מֵבִיא אֶת הַטֻּמְאָה:

    But Beit Hillel say: a person is hollow, and his upper side brings the impurity [across]. Though full of organs, his body counts as a handbreadth of hollow, so his top is like a roof joining both sides.

    The picture
    The picture in words

    Beit Hillel say a person is hollow. Though full of organs, his body counts as a tefach (a handbreadth) of hollow space, so his upper side is like a roof joining both halves, and the vessels become impure.

    1 note

    אָדָם חָלוּל הוּא

    • Bartenura: Beit Hillel hold a person is "hollow" — even though his innards fill him, the cavity within the body counts as a hollow a tefach high.
    • So his upper surface functions as an ohel (tent), bridging the crack and bringing the corpse-impurity over to the vessels on the far side.
    • Rambam: the upper side of the body is like a tent over the lower side joined to the floor, with more than a tefach of hollow between — so it conveys the impurity across.
    • Treating the body as a conveying tent makes Beit Hillel the stricter side, closing the chapter's list.

    Bartenura · Rambam Commentary

Summary

The chapter's final dispute concerns corpse-impurity spreading under a shared roof. A roofed porch's ceiling has cracked in two; a corpse lies on one side and vessels on the other, and ordinarily the open gap keeps the impurity from crossing. Now a person lies on the floor beneath the crack. Beit Shammai rule his body does not carry the impurity across, since it lacks the handbreadth-high hollow that a 'tent' needs to convey impurity. Beit Hillel rule that a person is 'hollow' — the body cavity counts as that hollow — so his upper surface acts as a tent and brings the impurity over to the vessels. As throughout the chapter, Beit Hillel is the stringent school.