Place
Reshut ha-rabimרְשׁוּת הָרַבִּים
re-SHUT ha-ra-BIM
Public domain
The public domain — an open, unenclosed thoroughfare such as a street or marketplace at least sixteen cubits wide and traversed by the public. Carrying an object out into it from a private domain, or four cubits within it, is a Torah-level violation of Shabbat. It stands opposite the private domain (reshut ha-yachid); between the two lie intermediate spaces such as the karmelit and the exempt area (makom petur). Determining whether a given space — a street, a shallow pool the public wades through, the airspace below ten handbreadths — counts as reshut ha-rabim is decisive for liability.
Where it comes up
35 mishnayot
- Shabbat 10:5When two share a labor — and when an item is "secondary"The public domain is the destination that makes carrying-out a completed, liable labor.
- Shabbat 11:1One who throwsThe public domain is one of the two domains whose boundary a thrown object must cross to incur liability.
- Eruvin 2:4Public road, public wellThe question here is whether the public's path can defeat a partition: if the masses march straight through the boards, does the enclosure remain a private domain or revert to public ground?
- Eruvin 8:10The covered gutterThe whole worry is water escaping into the public domain by the pourer's own force — the covered stretch of drain is where it gets absorbed before emerging.
- Eruvin 9:2Large roof, small roofThe fallen wall makes the street's status contagious: Rabbi Eliezer extends the public domain right into the breached courtyard, so carrying between it and a house is full-scale carrying out.
- Eruvin 10:4A ledge before the windowAll movement here stays inside the public domain itself — the one hard limit being its own internal rule of four amot.
- Sukkah 3:14One who forgot and carried the lulav outThe whole case turns on carrying into the public domain — the classic Shabbat labor of carrying out — committed by someone whose mind was on the lulav, not on the street.
- Bava Kamma 2:2Eating: the injured party's property, and 'what it benefited'The Torah exempts eating and trampling done in the public domain, for it speaks of grazing "in another's field"; only damage on the injured party's property is paid.
- Bava Kamma 2:5Rabbi Tarfon and the Sages: "it is enough"For an unwarned ox, even goring in the public domain brings liability, half the damage, unlike eating and trampling, which are exempt there; that is what powers the dispute that follows.
- Bava Kamma 3:1The jug in the public domainThe whole case turns on the jug being left in the public domain, where people walk freely and don't expect obstacles — that is why the one who trips is not blamed for breaking it.
- Bava Kamma 3:2Hazards left where people walkThe water is poured into the public domain, where others have every right to walk; even an act done with permission becomes a liability once it injures a passerby there.
- Bava Kamma 3:5Two carriers collide — who had to yield?Both carriers are exercising the same right to walk in the public domain; when neither was negligent and each had equal permission, the resulting breakage falls on neither.
- Bava Kamma 3:6A runner and a walker in the streetThe case is set in the public domain, where the question is who was using the road improperly; when neither has a clear advantage of fault over the other, both walk away exempt.
- Bava Kamma 5:5The pit, its openings, and the depth that killsLiability for a pit classically attaches to one opening into the public domain; the mishnah extends it even to a pit dug in one private domain and opening into another.
- Bava Kamma 6:4The laws of fire that spreadsA public road, like a fence four amot high or a river, is wide enough to be a natural firebreak; if the fire still leaps it, the spread is beyond the kindler's expectation, so he is exempt.
- Bava Kamma 6:6The spark, the camel, and the lampThe camel was passing through the public domain where it had a right to be; the question of liability turns on whose flax and whose lamp caused the fire, not on trespass.
- Bava Kamma 7:5Incomplete sale or slaughter — and the owner's domainThe whole rule turns on domain: a theft is completed only by removing the animal from the owner's domain, so when the thief never takes it out, there was no completed theft and neither the double payment nor four or five times applies.
- Bava Metzia 10:4Press-arches, and damage from a falling wallA wall or tree topples into the reshut ha-rabim — the public thoroughfare — and injures a passerby. The question is whether the owner pays for damage done by his own collapsing property in a shared public space.
- Bava Metzia 10:5Stones, wages, and the public domainThe public domain (reshut ha-rabim) belongs to everyone, so no one may obstruct it by letting his materials sit. Manure carried out to the street must be moved onward at once, not left to pile up.
- Bava Batra 2:14A tree overhanging the public domainHere the injured party is not a single neighbor but the public road itself — branches that hang too low block travelers, so they are cut high enough for a mounted camel to pass.
- Bava Batra 3:7Windows and doors onto a joint courtyardThe privacy rules guard a shared courtyard, not the public domain. There a person already expects to be seen by passersby, so he may open or align his doors and windows freely.
- Bava Batra 3:8Hollows and projections over the public domainThe public domain belongs to everyone, so no individual may weaken or obstruct it. Digging a hollow beneath the road risks collapse under travelers, so it is forbidden outright.
- Bava Batra 6:7A public path through his fieldA public thoroughfare is a right the public holds by long use — so once they have it, the owner cannot quietly take it back even by offering a substitute.
- Tohorot 4:5The six doubtsThe Sages set the dividing line at doubtful contact: in a private domain the terumah is neither eaten nor burned but suspended, and in a public domain the doubt is simply pure.
- Tohorot 4:7The lenient listA doubt about impurity that arose in a public domain is the classic lenient case — derived from the fact that the community brings the Pesach offering even in certain impurity, so all the more so is a mere doubt resolved to pure.
- Tohorot 4:11Doubts of the ScribesThe master rule of doubtful impurity: a doubt that arose in a public domain is pure, while a doubt in a private domain is impure. Here the perek restates it as one of the lenient cases.
- Tohorot 5:2Doubtful touching, doubtful objectRabbi Yosei accepts the public-domain leniency only where the doubtful act is unavoidable. Walking a path cannot be avoided, so its doubt stays lenient; touching can be avoided, so its doubt is strict.
- Tohorot 5:9One says yes, he says noThis is the chapter's governing rule restated: a doubtful impurity is impure in a private domain and pure in a public one. Balanced testimony reduces the whole case to exactly that doubt.
- Tohorot 6:3What counts as a private domain for doubtBecause the impure shop opens onto the street, the whole shop is treated like impurity lying out in the public domain — so a doubt about entering or touching is judged leniently, pure.
- Tohorot 6:7Public for impurity in the dry seasonThe valley flips with the season: in the dry months people cut across it to harvest and plow, so for impurity it is a public domain — and a doubt there is pure.
- Tohorot 6:8The basilicaA basilica is a broad, busy hall where merchants and crowds gather, so for impurity it counts as a public domain — and a doubt there is ruled pure.
- Tohorot 6:9The covered forum and its sidesThe forum has two doorways facing each other, and crowds pass through it from one to the other, so for impurity it counts as a public domain where doubt is ruled pure.
- Tohorot 6:10Closing the list of domainsThe raised ledge runs in front of a row of shops where merchants and customers gather, so for impurity it counts as a public domain where a doubt is ruled pure.
- Tohorot 8:3When a night of doubt passes over itThe whole doubt is whether a passing non-Jew or am ha-aretz touched the wash. In a public domain, a doubt is ruled pure, so the spread clothes stay pure.
- Tohorot 10:8Closing the tractate at the pressDoubtful impurity in a public domain is ruled pure; in a private domain, impure. This whole mishnah classifies winepress spaces so the doubt-cases of mishnah 6 and elsewhere can be decided.