Principle

Bererahבְּרֵרָה

BE-RE-RAH

A later choice retroactively defines an earlier act

The principle that a designation left vague can be clarified by a later choice, which then takes effect retroactively as if it had been made from the start -- for example, declaring that whatever remains in the cup will count as the tithe, and treating it as already separated once the drinking is done. A distinction drawn in the Gemara (Beitzah 38a) holds that bererah works only for rabbinic obligations, such as demai, but not for Torah-level ones, such as the tithes owed on certain tevel, which must be actually separated before the produce is eaten.

Where it comes up

4 mishnayot

  1. Demai 7:4Naming the tithes on definitely-untithed wineBererah is the principle that a later choice can retroactively define an earlier vague designation. The whole permission to drink first and separate after rests on it.
  2. Eruvin 3:5The conditional eruvSince the non-Jews may not arrive until morning, the choice is made after twilight — the eruv works only by retroactive designation: the later event shows which eruv took effect.
  3. Nedarim 5:1May vow-bound partners enter their shared yard?Rabbi Eliezer ben Yaakov relies on bererah — a vague designation clarified retroactively. Wherever a partner happens to stand can be deemed, after the fact, to have been his own share all along.
  4. Nedarim 5:2An outsider vowed off one partnerEven with no ownership of his own, the outsider can lean on bererah: wherever he stands is retroactively the share of the permitted partner. This is the strongest stretch of the principle in the perek.