Yevamot 5:2יְבָמוֹתLevirate betrothal, then divorce, chalitzah or relations
Three combinations with one widow
The question
After a ma'amar with his yevamah, what does a get, chalitzah, or bi'ah each require?
A question, then three sequences beginning with ma'amar: followed by a get, by chalitzah, or by bi'ah.
Tap a Hebrew word for its meaning. Tap a bold phrase to see the words it translates.
1How so?
How it works with one brother-in-law and one widow: three combinations.
כֵּיצַד.
How so? Take one brother-in-law and one widow.
1 note
כֵּיצַד
- Bartenura: "keitzad" here is NOT continuing the dispute of mishnah 1. It launches a separate question: in what scenarios do we encounter these issues?
- The default case for this mishnah: one yavam, one yevamah. Multi-yevamah cases come in mishnah 4.
- Each clause below pairs the rabbinic ma'amar with one of the three downstream actions — get, chalitzah, or bi'ah — and tells you what's still required.
Bartenura
2Ma'amar, then a get
A levirate betrothal, then a bill of divorce — she still needs chalitzah from him to go free.
עָשָׂה מַאֲמָר בִּיבִמְתּוֹ, וְנָתַן לָהּ גֵּט, צְרִיכָה הֵימֶנּוּ חֲלִיצָה.
If he made a levirate betrothal with his brother's widow — betrothing her with money, as the Sages enacted — and then gave her a bill of divorce, she still needs chalitzah, the release ceremony, from him — the bill undid the betrothal, but not her bond to him from his brother's death.
The picture The picture in words
- A levirate betrothal adds a betrothal on top of the levirate bond.
- The bill undoes the betrothal, and Bartenura explains that he may no longer marry her.
- The levirate bond is still there, so she needs chalitzah.
Concepts here
1 note
צְרִיכָה הֵימֶנּוּ חֲלִיצָה
- Why both? The ma'amar made her partly his "wife" (kiddushin); the get cancels that kiddushin. But the underlying zikah of yibum is not removed by a get — it requires either bi'ah (which would complete yibum) or chalitzah (which would end it).
- Bartenura: he can no longer choose yibum at this point. Once he started with a get, the verse "who will not build up his brother's house" (Devarim 25:9) locks him out. Chalitzah is the only path forward.
Bartenura
3Ma'amar, then chalitzah
A levirate betrothal, then chalitzah — she needs a bill of divorce from him to undo the betrothal.
עָשָׂה מַאֲמָר וַחֲלִיצָה, צְרִיכָה הֵימֶנּוּ גֵט.
If he made a levirate betrothal and then performed chalitzah — that frees her from the levirate tie, but his betrothal still binds her — she needs a bill of divorce from him.
The picture The picture in words
- A levirate betrothal adds a betrothal on top of the levirate bond.
- Chalitzah ends the levirate bond, but not the betrothal.
- The betrothal remains, so she needs a bill of divorce.
1 note
צְרִיכָה הֵימֶנּוּ גֵט
- Bartenura: chalitzah ends the zikah, but it does not undo kiddushin. The ma'amar created kiddushin, and only a get clears kiddushin.
- So she walks away with a chalitzah-shoe ceremony AND a get — the chalitzah for the bond, the get for the betrothal he created with the ma'amar.
Bartenura
4Ma'amar, then bi'ah: the ideal
A levirate betrothal, then relations — the proper way to do levirate marriage.
עָשָׂה מַאֲמָר וּבָעַל, הֲרֵי זוֹ כְמִצְוָתָהּ:
If he made a levirate betrothal and then had relations with her — betrothal first, then marriage, as with any bride — this is the proper way to do the mitzvah.
1 note
הֲרֵי זוֹ כְמִצְוָתָהּ
- The Chachamim instituted ma'amar specifically as the proper opening — kiddushin first, then bi'ah, just like a normal marriage.
- If the yavam skipped ma'amar and went straight to bi'ah, he still acquires her, but the Gemara says he gets makat mardut (rabbinic stripes) for treating the act lightly.
- So this clause is the model — ma'amar followed by bi'ah is yibum done with proper rabbinic dignity.
Bartenura · Tosafot Yom Tov
Summary
The mishnah opens a systematic map. With one brother-in-law and one widow, the Sages instituted the levirate betrothal (betrothing her with a coin) as the proper start of levirate marriage, with relations at the end. This mishnah pairs the levirate betrothal with each of the three possible follow-ups: a bill of divorce cancels its betrothal but leaves her bound to him, so chalitzah is still needed; chalitzah ends the bond but doesn't undo a betrothal, so a bill of divorce is still needed; relations complete the levirate marriage the proper way. Each pairing teaches what the act did and what it didn't do — the perek is built on tracking what is left.