Yevamot 2:10יְבָמוֹתMore suspicion-marriages — and the sons and brothers
Closing the perek — the sage who forbade her, and the court
The question
When may a sage who ruled on a woman, or the others suspected, still marry her?
A sage barred after a vow ruling, allowed after mi'un or chalitzah, then three general permissions covering all these cases.
Tap a Hebrew word for its meaning. Tap a bold phrase to see the words it translates.
1The sage who forbade her
A sage who upheld a wife's vow that forbade her to her husband — leading to her divorce — may not marry her himself. He acted alone, so suspicion attaches.
הֶחָכָם שֶׁאָסַר אֶת הָאִשָּׁה בְּנֶדֶר עַל בַּעְלָהּ, הֲרֵי זֶה לֹא יִשָּׂאֶנָּה.
A sage who forbade a woman to her husband through a vow — finding no grounds to release her vow, so they had to divorce — may not marry her, lest he be suspected of wanting her for himself.
1 note
הֶחָכָם שֶׁאָסַר אֶת הָאִשָּׁה בְּנֶדֶר
- Setup: a wife took a neder (vow) refusing benefit from her husband. The husband didn't annul it. She came to a chacham (a single qualified scholar) to release the vow — but he couldn't find a פֶּתַח לַחֲרָטָה (an opening to demonstrate she'd vowed under misunderstanding) and so the vow stood.
- Result: the vow forces the husband to divorce her (she may not benefit from him, so the marriage cannot go on).
- Bartenura: the chacham who upheld the vow himself can't now marry her. Same suspicion logic — did he find no "opening" because he wanted her free?
- Note: a single chacham can release vows alone — that's why the suspicion sticks here, vs. chalitzah/mi'un which require beit din.
Bartenura · Tosafot Yom Tov
2Mi'un or chalitzah: permitted
A woman freed by refusal or chalitzah before him is permitted, since those procedures need a court of three, removing suspicion.
מֵאֲנָה, אוֹ שֶׁחָלְצָה בְפָנָיו, יִשָּׂאֶנָּה, מִפְּנֵי שֶׁהוּא בֵית דִּין.
If she refused, or performed chalitzah, the release ceremony, before him — refusal being how a girl married off as a minor annuls the marriage — he may marry her, for it is a court: several judges, who would not all sin for one man's sake.
1 note
מִפְּנֵי שֶׁהוּא בֵית דִּין
- Mi'un and chalitzah both require multiple judges — they're beit-din procedures, not solo rulings. So no single judge could have manipulated the outcome alone.
- Bartenura: chalitzah and mi'un are done before two or three, and they are not suspected. Tosafot Yom Tov (Yerushalmi): two are not likely to sin for the sake of one. The shared structure of the panel rules out the suspicion of personal motive.
- So unlike the chacham who released vows alone, a member of a panel-decision can marry the woman.
Bartenura · Tosafot Yom Tov
3If their own wives died
Any of these men who had a wife at the time, who later died, may then marry the woman he once freed.
וְכֻלָּן שֶׁהָיוּ לָהֶם נָשִׁים, וָמֵתוּ, מֻתָּרוֹת לִנָּשֵׂא לָהֶם.
And all of them who had wives when they acted — the sage, the messenger, the witness — and [their wives] died, [the women] are permitted to marry them: being married at the time, they are not suspected.
1 note
שֶׁהָיוּ לָהֶם נָשִׁים, וָמֵתוּ
- If at the time he ruled, gave the get, or testified, he was already married — clearly he wasn't doing it to marry HER.
- Now (after his own wife dies naturally), the original suspicion is gone. He can marry her freely.
- Tosafot Yom Tov (from the Gemara): but if he DIVORCED his wife — and especially if she divorced because of his interest in this other woman — the suspicion comes roaring back. So mortality cleans the slate; voluntary divorce doesn't.
Bartenura · Tosafot Yom Tov
4If she married and was freed
And if these women later married someone else and were widowed or divorced from THAT marriage, they can now marry the original sage, witness or messenger.
וְכֻלָּן שֶׁנִּשְּׂאוּ לַאֲחֵרִים וְנִתְגָּרְשׁוּ אוֹ שֶׁנִּתְאַלְמְנוּ, מֻתָּרוֹת לִנָּשֵׂא לָהֶן.
And all [the women] who married others after these men freed them, and were divorced or widowed, are permitted to marry them: the marriage to another ended the suspicion.
1 note
שֶׁנִּשְּׂאוּ לַאֲחֵרִים
- Once she's actually married someone else and that second marriage ends, the suspicion-link to the original chacham/agent/witness is broken.
- The original concern was: he engineered her freedom in order to marry her. But she went and married someone else — proving (or at least demonstrating) the original act wasn't a setup.
- Tosafot Yom Tov adds: this works for divorce, but for widowhood she may be a קַטְלָנִית (a woman whose husbands die) and forbidden generally — so the rule applies cleanly only to divorce in the witness case.
Bartenura · Tosafot Yom Tov
5Permitted to sons and brothers
Even when the sage, witness or messenger himself may not marry her, his sons and brothers may: no one sins to win a wife for a relative.
וְכֻלָּן מֻתָּרוֹת לִבְנֵיהֶם אוֹ לַאֲחֵיהֶן:
And all of them are permitted to their sons or to their brothers: the men's sons and brothers, for no one sins to win a wife for a son or brother.
1 note
מֻתָּרוֹת לִבְנֵיהֶם אוֹ לַאֲחֵיהֶן
- The suspicion was personal: "did the chacham want her for HIMSELF?" That's plausible.
- "Did he engineer this so his son/brother could marry her?" Not plausible — Sages held that people don't commit sin for the sake of relatives.
- Rambam: his father and other relatives too; Tosafot Yom Tov: all the more so his father.
- Bartenura: in all these cases where "he may not marry her", if he did marry her he need not divorce — except the man suspected with a married woman whom beit din removed from her husband on clear evidence (2:8).
- So the prohibition is narrowly personal: only the chacham/agent/witness himself is excluded.
Bartenura · Rambam Commentary
Summary
The closing mishnah of perek 2 ties off the suspicion principle. A sage who could find no way to release a vow that forced a wife's divorce may not marry her himself — he ruled alone, so the suspicion of personal interest sticks. Refusal and chalitzah, both done before a court, carry no such suspicion: several judges won't all sin for one of them. Two ways the bar lifts: if the sage, witness, or messenger had a wife at the time he acted and she later died, the suspicion is gone and he may marry her; and if she married another man and was widowed or divorced from him, that too breaks the link. The final principle: the bar is strictly personal — his sons and brothers may marry her freely, for no one sins to win a wife for a relative.