Yevamot 13:5יְבָמוֹתA later refusal can't undo an earlier divorce

Five husbands — ask how she left each one

The question

After a chain of marriages ended by mi'un or divorce, to which husbands may she return?

A chain of five husbands left by mi'un or by get, then the ruling for each kind.

Tap a Hebrew word for its meaning. Tap a bold phrase to see the words it translates.

  1. 1Five husbands; get: forbidden

    Five husbands, some she refused and some who divorced her: she may not return to any husband she left with a bill of divorce.

    הַמְמָאֶנֶת בָּאִישׁ וְנִשֵּׂאת לְאַחֵר וְגֵרְשָׁהּ, לְאַחֵר וּמֵאֲנָה בוֹ, לְאַחֵר וְגֵרְשָׁהּ, לְאַחֵר וּמֵאֲנָה בוֹ, כֹּל שֶׁיָּצָאת הֵימֶנּוּ בְגֵט, אֲסוּרָה לַחֲזֹר לוֹ.

    If a girl refused a man, and married another, who divorced her, [then] another, and she refused him, [then] another, who divorced her, [then] another, and she refused him — five husbands, the second and fourth left by divorce — any [husband] she left with a bill of divorce, she is forbidden to return to him; she married others after his divorce, and refusing a later husband does not undo it.

    The picture
    The picture in words

    She refused her first, third and fifth husbands, and the second and fourth divorced her. She may not go back to the second or the fourth, since she married others after their divorces, and refusing a later husband does not undo an earlier divorce.

    1 note

    כֹּל שֶׁיָּצָאת הֵימֶנּוּ בְגֵט

    • Same principle as 13:4 — but applied across many husbands at once. The question for each man in the chain is: how did she leave HIM? If by get, she's barred from returning to him. If by mi'un, she may return.
    • Tosafot Yom Tov draws the deeper rule from the Gemara: only HER OWN later mi'un can erase HIS earlier get. A different husband's mi'un later in the chain doesn't undo this man's get.
    • Bartenura: although she left a later husband by refusal, that refusal does not cancel this husband's get.

    Bartenura · Tosafot Yom Tov

  2. 2Mi'un: may return

    But any husband she left by refusal, she may return to.

    בְּמֵאוּן, מֻתֶּרֶת לַחֲזֹר לוֹ.

    [Any she left] by refusal, she is permitted to return to him, for her refusal undid that marriage from the start.

    1 note

    בְּמֵאוּן, מֻתֶּרֶת לַחֲזֹר לוֹ

    • If she exited THIS particular husband by mi'un, the mi'un retroacts and erases the marriage to him entirely. There's no "machzir gerushato" issue because she was never his proper wife in the first place.
    • So even mid-chain — if husband #1 was exited by mi'un, even though there are gettin further down the line with other husbands, she can return to #1.

    Bartenura

Summary

Mishnah 5 stress-tests the rule from 13:4 with a long chain: she left husband #1 by refusal, #2 by divorce, #3 by refusal, #4 by divorce, #5 by refusal. May she return to each? The mishnah's answer is one-husband-at-a-time: ask how she exited THAT husband. The closing rule of the previous mishnah (last exit determines whether you can return) is now refined — it's not the LAST exit overall, it's how she exited the SPECIFIC man you're asking about. The subtle point: a refusal cancels a divorce only when she refuses that same man; refusing a later husband can't undo an earlier husband's divorce.