Menachot 3:4מְנָחוֹתA lost remainder, and other defects

When the remainder is gone — does the handful still go up?

The question

What if the remainder is lost, no service vessel is used, or the handful is burned twice?

Three defects: a lost remainder (by Rabbi Eliezer's and Rabbi Yehoshua's principles), no service vessel (Rabbi Shimon dissents), and burning in two parts.

Tap a Hebrew word for its meaning. Tap a bold phrase to see the words it translates.

  1. 1A lost remainder

    If the remainder is lost or burned, two sages disagree whether the handful can still be offered — by analogy to blood and meat.

    נִטְמְאוּ שְׁיָרֶיהָ, נִשְׂרְפוּ שְׁיָרֶיהָ, אָבְדוּ שְׁיָרֶיהָ, כְּמִדַּת רַבִּי אֱלִיעֶזֶר, כְּשֵׁרָה. וּכְמִדַּת רַבִּי יְהוֹשֻׁעַ, פְּסוּלָה.

    If its remainder became [ritually] impure, or was burned, or was lost — so none is left for the kohanim to eat — by the rule of Rabbi Eliezer it is valid — he lets the blood be thrown even with no meat left, and the handful is like the blood — and by the rule of Rabbi Yehoshua it is invalid: to him, without the meat, the blood is not thrown.

    The picture
    The picture in words

    The handful goes on the altar like an animal’s blood, and the remainder is eaten like its meat, but here the remainder is gone. Rabbi Eliezer lets the blood be thrown even with no meat left, so the offering is valid. Rabbi Yehoshua says that without the meat the blood is not thrown, so it is invalid.

    1 note

    כְּמִדַּת רַבִּי אֱלִיעֶזֶר

    • In an animal-offering, the blood is dashed on the altar and the meat is eaten. A parallel question: if the meat is gone, may the blood still be dashed?
    • Rabbi Eliezer holds the blood is dashed even if there is no meat. By the same logic, the handful (parallel to the blood) may be burned even though the remainder (parallel to the meat) is gone — so the offering is fit.
    • Rabbi Yehoshua holds the opposite: "if there is no meat, there is no blood" — so here too, with no remainder, the handful is not burned and the offering is unfit. The halachah follows Rabbi Yehoshua.
    • Bartenura: this is only when none of the remainder is left pure; if any of it survives, the handful is burned.

    Bartenura

  2. 2Without a service vessel

    A handful not put in a sacred vessel is invalid, though Rabbi Shimon rules it valid.

    שֶׁלֹּא בִכְלִי שָׁרֵת, פְּסוּלָה. רַבִּי שִׁמְעוֹן מַכְשִׁיר.

    [A handful] not [put] in a sacred vessel is invalid; Rabbi Shimon rules it valid, for the Torah likens it to a sin-offering (Vayikra 6:10), whose blood the kohen puts on with his finger.

    1 note

    שֶׁלֹּא בִכְלִי שָׁרֵת

    • A kli sharet is a consecrated Temple service-vessel; placing the kometz into one sanctifies it for the altar.
    • The first opinion: a handful not put into a service vessel is unfit. (Everyone agrees the minchah's flour must first be sanctified in a vessel at the start.)
    • Rabbi Shimon validates it, learning from a verse that likens the minchah to the sin-offering: just as the sin-offering's blood is applied by the kohen's own finger, the kometz too may be handled by hand — provided it is his right hand. The halachah does not follow Rabbi Shimon.

    Bartenura

  3. 3Burning in two installments

    Burning the handful in two parts is valid — each part is still an olive's bulk.

    הִקְטִיר קֻמְצָהּ פַּעֲמַיִם, כְּשֵׁרָה.

    If he burned its handful in two [parts], it is valid. A handful holds at least two olives' bulk, so each half is still at least one.

    The picture
    The picture in words

    He burned the handful in two parts. A handful holds at least two olives’ bulk, so each part is still an olive’s bulk, and the offering is valid.

    1 note

    הִקְטִיר קֻמְצָהּ פַּעֲמַיִם

    • He burned half the handful at one time and half at another.
    • This works specifically for two installments and no more, because a full kometz is never less than two olives' bulk — so each of the two halves is still a whole kezayit.
    • Had he split it into three or four times, each portion would be less than a kezayit, and the burning would be invalid.

    Bartenura

Summary

If the remainder of a meal-offering is lost, burned, or made impure before the handful is offered, may the handful still go up? Rabbi Eliezer says yes — just as blood is thrown even without meat; Rabbi Yehoshua says no — without the meat, the blood is not thrown. The mishnah adds two more cases: a handful not put in a sacred vessel is invalid (Rabbi Shimon rules it valid), and burning the handful in two parts is valid, since each half is still a full olive's bulk.