Menachot 3:2מְנָחוֹתOmissions that don't disqualify
Steps that were skipped — and a handful that got mixed
The question
Which skipped steps or mix-ups still leave a meal-offering valid?
A list of omissions that do not disqualify, a handful mixed into wholly burned offerings, then Rabbi Yehudah dissenting on two of them.
Tap a Hebrew word for its meaning. Tap a bold phrase to see the words it translates.
1Omissions that don't disqualify
A list of preparation steps the kohen failed to do — yet the meal-offerings remain valid.
לֹא יָצַק, לֹא בָלַל, לֹא פָתַת, לֹא מָלַח, לֹא הֵנִיף, לֹא הִגִּישׁ, אוֹ שֶׁפְּתָתָן פִּתִּים מְרֻבּוֹת, וְלֹא מְשָׁחָן, כְּשֵׁרוֹת.
He did not pour [the oil], did not mix [it], did not break [it] into pieces — the baked meal-offerings, broken up before the handful is taken — did not salt [it], did not wave [it], did not bring [it] near [the altar], or broke it into overly large pieces, or did not smear [the wafers with oil]: they are valid. Each step is the proper way, but leaving it out does not make them invalid.
The picture The picture in words
The kohen may leave out any of the steps at the top, and the meal-offering is still valid. Each is the proper way, but it does not hold the offering back. Bartenura notes that the pouring itself, which even a non-kohen may do, and salting the handful are required, and without them it is invalid.
3 notes
לֹא יָצַק לֹא בָלַל
- Preparing a minchah follows an order: oil is put in the vessel, then flour, then more oil is poured (yetzikah) and mixed in (belilah).
- These steps come before the handful is taken, from which point only a kohen may serve; pouring and mixing may even be done by a non-kohen.
- Bartenura first reads 'did not pour' as putting the whole log of oil in at the start, so nothing was left to pour yet no oil is missing (missing oil would disqualify). But the Gemara shows the pouring is indispensable, so 'did not pour' means a non-kohen poured it, and 'did not mix' means no mixing at all — mixing is not indispensable, and the offering is still fit.
Bartenura
לֹא פָתַת
- Petitah is breaking the baked minchah into small pieces before the kemitzah, learned from "break it into bits" (Vayikra 2:6).
- Though the verse speaks of one type, all baked menachot should be broken up first.
- If the kohen broke them only enough to scoop a handful, or even made the pieces too large, the offering is still fit — proper breaking is the ideal but not indispensable.
Bartenura
לֹא מָלַח
- This means he failed to salt the whole minchah, salting only the kometz itself.
- Salting the kometz, by contrast, IS indispensable — without it the offering would be invalid.
- Likewise: waving (tenufah) is required for the omer and the sotah's offering; bringing the offering near the altar (hagashah) is learned from Vayikra 2:8; smearing oil (meshichah) is needed for wafers, learned from Shemot 29:2 — yet failing these does not undo the offering after the fact.
Bartenura
2Handful mixed into burned offerings
If a handful gets mixed into another offering burned whole, it is still valid — for everything in the mixture goes on the altar fire anyway.
נִתְעָרֵב קֻמְצָהּ בְּקֹמֶץ חֲבֶרְתָּהּ, בְּמִנְחַת כֹּהֲנִים, בְּמִנְחַת כֹּהֵן הַמָּשִׁיחַ, בְּמִנְחַת נְסָכִין, כְּשֵׁרָה.
If its handful became mixed with the handful of another [meal-offering], with the kohanim's meal-offering — a kohen's own, burned whole — with the anointed kohen's meal-offering — the daily one of the kohen gadol, the High Priest — or with the meal-offering of the libations, it is valid. All of it goes on the altar fire, so nothing is lost.
1 note
בְּמִנְחַת כֹּהֲנִים
- A regular Israelite's minchah is split: a kometz is burned, the rest is eaten by kohanim.
- But several menachot are burned in their entirety — a kohen's own minchah, the High Priest's daily minchah (the "anointed kohen"), and the minchah that accompanies wine libations.
- If a kometz from a regular minchah falls into one of these, the whole mixture is simply burned, and the offering stays fit — nothing is lost, since all of it was headed for the fire anyway.
Bartenura
3Rabbi Yehudah: two are unfit
Rabbi Yehudah rules two of those cases invalid — the thick and thin oil mixtures absorb from each other, and the handful is lost in them.
רַבִּי יְהוּדָה אוֹמֵר, בְּמִנְחַת כֹּהֵן הַמָּשִׁיחַ וּבְמִנְחַת נְסָכִין, פְּסוּלָה, שֶׁזּוֹ בְּלִילָתָהּ עָבָה, וְזוֹ בְּלִילָתָהּ רַכָּה, וְהֵן בּוֹלְעוֹת זוֹ מִזּוֹ.
Rabbi Yehudah says: with the anointed kohen's meal-offering or the meal-offering of the libations, it is invalid, for this one's mixture is thick — one log of oil to a tenth of flour — and that one's mixture is thin — three logs to a tenth — and they absorb from one another. The handful soaks up their oil and is lost in it.
The picture The picture in words
Here the handful of an ordinary meal-offering, mixed thick with one log of oil, falls into the High Priest’s or the libations’ meal-offering, mixed thin with three logs. Rabbi Yehudah rules it invalid, because the handful soaks up their oil and is lost in it, as if never burned (Bartenura). The first opinion rules it valid.
1 note
שֶׁזּוֹ בְּלִילָתָהּ עָבָה וְזוֹ בְּלִילָתָהּ רַכָּה
- A log is a small liquid measure (the volume of six eggs).
- A regular Israelite's minchah is a "thick" blend — one log of oil to a measure (isaron) of flour.
- The High Priest's minchah and the libation-minchah are "loose" blends — three logs of oil to a measure.
- When the thick handful mixes with a loose offering, the extra oil seeps in: the kometz soaks up too much oil and is nullified within the larger amount, so the offering it came from is ruined. Rabbi Yehudah therefore disqualifies — but the halachah does not follow him.
Bartenura
Summary
First the mishnah lists preparation steps the kohen might skip — pouring, mixing, breaking, salting, waving, bringing near, smearing. Each is the proper way, but leaving it out does not make the meal-offering invalid. Then it turns to a handful mixed into other offerings. If it is mixed into another handful, or into a meal-offering burned entirely on the altar, the mixture is valid, since everything goes on the altar fire anyway. Rabbi Yehudah objects in two cases, where the oil mixtures differ in thickness and absorb from each other.