Menachot 1:4מְנָחוֹתTime, place, and combining
When piggul does not take hold
The question
When do mixed intentions block pigul, and do different intentions combine?
Cases where a place intent or wrong-sake intent blocks pigul, mixed place and time intents, Rabbi Yehudah versus the Sages, then eating and burning.
Tap a Hebrew word for its meaning. Tap a bold phrase to see the words it translates.
1Place intent blocks pigul
The flip side: cases where what permits it was not offered as prescribed, so it is not piggul.
כֵּיצַד לֹא קָרַב הַמַּתִּיר כְּמִצְוָתוֹ. קָמַץ חוּץ לִמְקוֹמוֹ, וְנָתַן בַּכְּלִי וְהִלֵּךְ וְהִקְטִיר חוּץ לִזְמַנּוֹ, אוֹ שֶׁקָּמַץ חוּץ לִזְמַנּוֹ וְנָתַן בַּכְּלִי וְהִלֵּךְ וְהִקְטִיר חוּץ לִמְקוֹמוֹ, אוֹ שֶׁקָּמַץ וְנָתַן בַּכְּלִי וְהִלֵּךְ וְהִקְטִיר חוּץ לִמְקוֹמוֹ.
How is what permits it not offered as prescribed? If he took the handful [intending] outside its place, and put [it] in the vessel, carried [it], and burned [it intending] past its time; or took the handful past its time, and put [it] in the vessel, carried [it], and burned [it] outside its place; or took the handful, put [it] in the vessel, carried [it], and burned [it, all] outside its place. In each, the intent about place is a flaw of its own, so it is invalid but never piggul, a spoiled offering.
The picture The picture in words
A time thought alone makes the offering piggul, a spoiled offering, and one who eats it is cut off. In this sentence a place thought is mixed in, before or after the time thought, and it is a flaw of its own. So the offering is invalid, but it never becomes piggul.
Concepts here
1 note
כֵּיצַד לֹא קָרַב הַמַּתִּיר כְּמִצְוָתוֹ
- This is the mirror image of the previous mishnah's 'how is the permitting factor offered properly'.
- Whenever a wrong-PLACE intention (chutz limkomo) joins the services alongside the wrong-time intention, the permitting act is no longer flawless.
- Bartenura: once there is a second disqualification, the offering is simply invalid — it never becomes pigul, and there is no karet for eating it.
Bartenura · Rambam Commentary
2Wrong-sake intent blocks too
For the sinner's and jealousy offerings, an intent not for their own sake also blocks piggul.
מִנְחַת חוֹטֵא וּמִנְחַת קְנָאוֹת שֶׁקְּמָצָן שֶׁלֹּא לִשְׁמָן וְנָתַן בַּכְּלִי וְהִלֵּךְ וְהִקְטִיר חוּץ לִזְמַנָּן, אוֹ שֶׁקָּמַץ חוּץ לִזְמַנָּן, וְנָתַן בַּכְּלִי וְהִלֵּךְ וְהִקְטִיר שֶׁלֹּא לִשְׁמָן, אוֹ שֶׁקָּמַץ וְנָתַן בַּכְּלִי וְהִלֵּךְ וְהִקְטִיר שֶׁלֹּא לִשְׁמָן, זֶה הוּא שֶׁלֹּא קָרַב הַמַּתִּיר כְּמִצְוָתוֹ.
The sinner's meal-offering and the meal-offering of jealousy, whose handful he took not for their own sake, and put [it] in the vessel, carried [it], and burned [it intending] past their time — for these two, not for their own sake is itself a flaw — or took the handful past their time, and put [it] in the vessel, carried [it], and burned [it] not for their own sake; or took the handful, put [it] in the vessel, carried [it], and burned [it, all] not for their own sake: this is [a case where] what permits it was not offered as prescribed. So it is invalid, but not piggul.
1 note
מִנְחַת חוֹטֵא וּמִנְחַת קְנָאוֹת שֶׁקְּמָצָן שֶׁלֹּא לִשְׁמָן
- Recall from mishnah 1 that for the sinner's and jealousy offerings, 'not for their sake' (shelo lishman) is itself a disqualification.
- So when one of the four services is done shelo lishmah, that is a second flaw alongside the wrong-time intention.
- Bartenura: this second disqualification removes the offering from the category of pigul — it is invalid, but eating it brings no karet.
Bartenura
3Mixed place and time intents
Mixing intents about place and time in one service, in whole or half olive's bulks, makes it invalid, and one who eats it is not cut off.
לֶאֱכֹל כַּזַּיִת בַּחוּץ וְכַזַּיִת לְמָחָר, כַּזַּיִת לְמָחָר וְכַזַּיִת בַּחוּץ, כַּחֲצִי זַיִת בַּחוּץ וְכַחֲצִי זַיִת לְמָחָר, כַּחֲצִי זַיִת לְמָחָר וְכַחֲצִי זַיִת בַּחוּץ, פָּסוּל וְאֵין בּוֹ כָרֵת.
[Intending] to eat an olive's bulk outside and an olive's bulk the next day, or an olive's bulk the next day and an olive's bulk outside — an intent about place and one about time in the same service — or half an olive's bulk outside and half an olive's bulk the next day, or half an olive's bulk the next day and half an olive's bulk outside: it is invalid, and [one who eats it] is not cut off. With the two intents mixed, it never becomes piggul.
1 note
כַּזַּיִת בַּחוּץ וְכַזַּיִת לְמָחָר
- Here both a wrong-place and a wrong-time intention are formed during a SINGLE service (whereas earlier they were split across two services).
- Because place-intent and time-intent are mixed together in one act, neither fully takes over.
- Bartenura: the result is that the offering is invalid, but it is not pigul and carries no karet. The first opinion holds this regardless of which intention was spoken first.
Bartenura
4Rabbi Yehudah: whichever came first
Rabbi Yehudah says the order matters — time first makes it piggul, place first does not — and the Sages disagree.
אָמַר רַבִּי יְהוּדָה, זֶה הַכְּלָל, אִם מַחֲשֶׁבֶת הַזְּמָן קָדְמָה לְמַחֲשֶׁבֶת הַמָּקוֹם, פִּגּוּל וְחַיָּבִים עָלָיו כָּרֵת. וְאִם מַחֲשֶׁבֶת הַמָּקוֹם קָדְמָה לְמַחֲשֶׁבֶת הַזְּמָן, פָּסוּל וְאֵין בּוֹ כָרֵת. וַחֲכָמִים אוֹמְרִים, זֶה וָזֶה פָּסוּל וְאֵין בּוֹ כָרֵת.
Rabbi Yehudah said: This is the rule: If the intent about time came before the intent about place, it is piggul, and [one who eats it] is liable to be cut off — the first intent decides — and if the intent about place came before the intent about time, it is invalid, and [one who eats it] is not cut off. And the Sages say: Either way, it is invalid, and [one who eats it] is not cut off, for with the intents mixed it never becomes piggul.
The picture The picture in words
He had both thoughts during one service, one after the other. Rabbi Yehudah says the first thought decides, so if the time thought came first the offering is piggul. The Sages say that with the thoughts mixed it is only invalid, whichever came first.
Concepts here
2 notes
אִם מַחֲשֶׁבֶת הַזְּמָן קָדְמָה לְמַחֲשֶׁבֶת הַמָּקוֹם
- Rabbi Yehudah holds the ORDER of the two intentions decides the outcome.
- If the wrong-TIME intention came first, it 'takes' and the offering is pigul, with karet — even though a wrong-place intention followed.
- If the wrong-PLACE intention came first, it takes instead, and the offering is merely invalid, with no karet.
- Bartenura notes Rabbi Yehudah disputes the first opinion whether the two intentions were in one service or two.
Bartenura
וַחֲכָמִים אוֹמְרִים, זֶה וָזֶה פָּסוּל
- The Sages reject Rabbi Yehudah's order-based rule.
- Whether time-intent or place-intent came first, the mixture leaves the offering invalid with no karet — it never becomes full pigul.
- Bartenura concludes the halacha is NOT like Rabbi Yehudah; we follow the Sages.
Bartenura
5Eating and burning don't combine
Intending to eat half and burn half: eating and burning don't combine, so it stays valid.
לֶאֱכֹל כַּחֲצִי זַיִת וּלְהַקְטִיר כַּחֲצִי זַיִת, כָּשֵׁר, שֶׁאֵין אֲכִילָה וְהַקְטָרָה מִצְטָרְפִין.
[Intending] to eat half an olive's bulk and to burn half an olive's bulk — the remainder eaten, the handful burned — it is valid, for eating and burning do not combine. Neither half makes the full olive's bulk an intent needs.
The picture The picture in words
When both half-olives are meant for eating, together they make the olive’s bulk a thought needs, and the offering is invalid. Here one half is to be eaten and one burned. Eating and burning do not combine, so the offering stays valid.
1 note
שֶׁאֵין אֲכִילָה וְהַקְטָרָה מִצְטָרְפִין
- A disqualifying wrong-time intention needs to concern at least a full olive's-bulk (kazayit). Here neither half reaches that measure on its own.
- 'Eating' (the leftovers a person consumes) and 'burning' (the fistful the altar consumes) are two different categories of action.
- Because they are different categories, the two half-measures do not join to make a full kazayit — so the offering remains valid.
Bartenura · Rambam Commentary
Summary
This mishnah completes the picture of piggul by showing when it does not take hold. Piggul (intent about time, which makes one who eats it liable to be cut off) attaches only if the handful, what permits the offering, was otherwise offered flawlessly. So if an intent about place also enters the service, or, for the sinner's and jealousy offerings, an intent not for their own sake, that second flaw blocks piggul: the offering is invalid, but no one is cut off for eating it. Where intents about place and time are mixed in a single service, the first opinion and the Sages say it is merely invalid; Rabbi Yehudah says the first intent decides. Finally, intending to eat half an olive's bulk and burn half leaves the offering valid, because eating and burning are separate and do not combine into a full olive's bulk.