Keritot 6:3כְּרִיתוֹתMay one volunteer a guilt-offering for a doubt?
The guilt-offering of the pious
The question
May a pious person bring a provisional guilt-offering without any real doubt?
Rabbi Eliezer's view, a story of Bava ben Buti and his oath, then the Sages' opposing rule.
Tap a Hebrew word for its meaning. Tap a bold phrase to see the words it translates.
1Rabbi Eliezer: the pious asham
Rabbi Eliezer says one may volunteer a guilt-offering for a doubt any day, even with no doubt at all.
רַבִּי אֱלִיעֶזֶר אוֹמֵר, מִתְנַדֵּב אָדָם אָשָׁם תָּלוּי בְּכָל יוֹם וּבְכָל שָׁעָה שֶׁיִּרְצֶה, וְהִיא נִקְרֵאת אֲשַׁם חֲסִידִים.
Rabbi Eliezer says: A person may volunteer a guilt-offering for a doubt every day and every hour that he wishes, and it is called the guilt-offering of the pious. The pious brought it, fearing some sin they had not noticed.
Concepts here
1 note
מִתְנַדֵּב אָדָם אָשָׁם תָּלוּי
- R. Eliezer holds that the asham talui is essentially a freewill offering.
- His proof: if the asham talui were an obligation that atoned for the doubt, why must a person who later learns he truly sinned still bring a chatat? It must therefore be a freewill offering.
- The pious would bring it constantly out of worry that they might have stumbled into some unnoticed sin.
Bartenura
2Bava ben Buti's daily offering
They told of Bava ben Buti, who volunteered a guilt-offering for a doubt every day except the one day right after Yom Kippur.
אָמְרוּ עָלָיו עַל בָּבָא בֶן בּוּטִי, שֶׁהָיָה מִתְנַדֵּב אָשָׁם תָּלוּי בְּכָל יוֹם, חוּץ מֵאַחַר יוֹם הַכִּפּוּרִים יוֹם אֶחָד.
They said of Bava ben Buti, a man famed for his care to avoid sin, that he would volunteer a guilt-offering for a doubt every day, except for the one day after Yom Kippur, when Yom Kippur had just atoned and there was nothing to fear.
1 note
חוּץ מֵאַחַר יוֹם הַכִּפּוּרִים
- On every other day of the year one might worry he had stumbled into some doubtful sin.
- But right after Yom Kippur there is nothing to suspect, since Yom Kippur has already atoned — so even the famously scrupulous Bava ben Buti did not bring it that one day.
Bartenura
3His oath: they wouldn't let me
Bava ben Buti swore he would have brought it that very day, but the Sages told him to wait until an actual doubt arose.
אָמַר, הַמָּעוֹן הַזֶּה, אִלּוּ הָיוּ מַנִּיחִים לִי, הָיִיתִי מֵבִיא, אֶלָּא אוֹמְרִים לִי, הַמְתֵּן עַד שֶׁתִּכָּנֵס לְסָפֵק.
He said: By this Dwelling, the Temple, if they had let me, I would have brought [it then too], but they tell me: Wait until you come into a doubt.
1 note
הַמָּעוֹן הַזֶּה
- "This Dwelling" means the Temple, and he swears by it: so Tosafot Yom Tov explains (on Ketubot 2:9), following the Arukh.
Tosafot Yom Tov
4Sages: only for real doubt
The Sages disagree with Rabbi Eliezer: a guilt-offering for a doubt is brought only for a sin that, done deliberately, brings being cut off, and unwittingly, a sin-offering.
וַחֲכָמִים אוֹמְרִים, אֵין מְבִיאִים אָשָׁם תָּלוּי אֶלָּא עַל דָּבָר שֶׁזְּדוֹנוֹ כָרֵת וְשִׁגְגָתוֹ חַטָּאת.
But the Sages say: One brings a guilt-offering for a doubt only for a matter for which [one who does it] deliberately is liable to be cut off, and unwittingly, to a sin-offering. For them it shields one in real doubt; it is no freewill gift.
Concepts here
1 note
אֵין מְבִיאִים אָשָׁם תָּלוּי
- The Sages hold the asham talui is not a freewill gift. Its purpose is to shield a person from suffering during the time he does not yet know whether he sinned — the Torah has mercy on the body of a Jew.
- So it may be brought only where there is a real doubt about a sin serious enough to require a chatat — one whose intentional form would carry karet.
- The halacha follows the Sages.
Bartenura
Summary
This mishnah records a dispute over what the guilt-offering for a doubt is. Rabbi Eliezer says a person may volunteer one every day and every hour he wishes, and it is called the guilt-offering of the pious, for the pious brought it, fearing some sin they had not noticed. Bava ben Buti brought one every day except the day after Yom Kippur, when Yom Kippur had just atoned, and swore by the Temple that he would have brought it then too had they let him; but they told him to wait until he came into a doubt. The Sages say it is brought only for a sin that brings being cut off when done deliberately and a sin-offering when done unwittingly: it shields one in real doubt and is no freewill gift.