Keritot 6:2כְּרִיתוֹתA certain guilt-offering, an ox and a heifer
Other consecrations resolved by doubt
The question
What happens to other offerings or condemned animals when the reason for them vanishes?
Three contrasting cases, each before and after the act: a definite guilt-offering, the ox sentenced to stoning, and the eglah arufah.
Tap a Hebrew word for its meaning. Tap a bold phrase to see the words it translates.
1Definite asham: before slaughter
A guilt-offering for a certain sin is different from one for a doubt: before slaughter it simply goes back to the flock.
אָשָׁם וַדַּאי אֵינוֹ כֵן. אִם עַד שֶׁלֹּא נִשְׁחַט, יֵצֵא וְיִרְעֶה בָעֵדֶר.
A guilt-offering for a certain [sin] is different: if before it was slaughtered he learned he had not sinned, it goes out and grazes with the flock, for it was set aside by mistake and never became holy.
Concepts here
1 note
אָשָׁם וַדַּאי אֵינוֹ כֵן
- An asham vadai is brought for a sin one knows he committed — for instance, witnesses said he ate kodashim.
- If those witnesses are then shown to be lying, it emerges that he never sinned, so the consecration was a mistake from the start and never took effect.
- Unlike the asham talui, here there was never any inner uneasiness driving a real consecration — so the animal simply grazes as ordinary.
Bartenura
2After slaughter or dashing
Once slaughtered, the guilt-offering for a certain sin is buried; if its blood was already thrown, the meat is burned.
מִשֶּׁנִּשְׁחַט, הֲרֵי זֶה יִקָּבֵר. נִזְרַק הַדָּם, הַבָּשָׂר יֵצֵא לְבֵית הַשְּׂרֵפָה.
Once it was slaughtered, it is buried, like ordinary meat slaughtered in the courtyard. If the blood was thrown, the meat goes out to the place of burning.
1 note
הֲרֵי זֶה יִקָּבֵר
- Since the animal was never really consecrated, it counts as ordinary meat slaughtered in the courtyard — which requires burial.
- Bartenura, citing the Gemara: the ruling that the meat is burned once the blood is thrown comes from a different tanna; the one who rules that the slaughtered animal is buried, holding it was never consecrated, would bury it here too.
Bartenura
3The ox to be stoned
An ox sentenced to stoning is likewise different: before stoning it grazes, and once stoned, benefit from it is permitted.
שׁוֹר הַנִּסְקָל אֵינוֹ כֵן. אִם עַד שֶׁלֹּא נִסְקַל, יֵצֵא וְיִרְעֶה בָעֵדֶר. מִשֶּׁנִּסְקַל, מֻתָּר בַּהֲנָאָה.
An ox to be stoned is different: one sentenced for killing a person; if before it was stoned it is found that it did not kill, it goes out and grazes with the flock; once it was stoned, benefit from it is permitted, for it was never guilty, so the ban on a stoned ox does not apply.
1 note
שׁוֹר הַנִּסְקָל אֵינוֹ כֵן
- An ox that killed a person is sentenced to be stoned, and benefit from its carcass is then forbidden.
- If, before the stoning, the testimony is shown to be false, the ox never had that status and rejoins the flock.
- If the false testimony comes out only after the stoning, the sentence was never valid — so deriving benefit from the carcass is permitted.
Bartenura
4The eglah arufah
The heifer whose neck is broken returns to the flock if the killer is found first; once its neck is broken, it is buried, having atoned for its doubt.
עֶגְלָה עֲרוּפָה אֵינָהּ כֵּן. אִם עַד שֶׁלֹּא נֶעֶרְפָה, תֵּצֵא וְתִרְעֶה בָעֵדֶר. מִשֶּׁנֶּעֶרְפָה, תִּקָּבֵר בִּמְקוֹמָהּ, שֶׁעַל סָפֵק בָּאָה מִתְּחִלָּתָהּ, כִּפְּרָה סְפֵקָהּ וְהָלְכָה לָהּ.
A heifer whose neck is broken is different: it is brought when a slain man is found and the killer is unknown (Devarim 21:1-9); if before its neck was broken the killer is found, it goes out and grazes with the flock; once its neck was broken, it is buried in its place, for it came for a doubt from the start; it has atoned for its doubt and gone its way.
The picture The picture in words
If the truth comes out before the act, each animal is spared. Once its neck is broken, though, the heifer is buried and stays forbidden even if the killer is found, because it came for a doubt from the start and atoned for it. The first row follows the Sages.
1 note
כִּפְּרָה סְפֵקָהּ וְהָלְכָה לָהּ
- The eglah arufah comes precisely to address a doubt — the identity of an unknown murderer.
- If the killer is found before the neck is broken, the rite is no longer needed and the heifer grazes.
- But once the neck is broken while the doubt still stood, the heifer's purpose was fulfilled at that moment. So even if the killer turns up afterward, the heifer is buried in place like any eglah arufah, and benefit from it stays forbidden.
Bartenura
Summary
Having explained the guilt-offering for a doubt, the mishnah sets three other cases beside it: a guilt-offering for a certain sin, an ox sentenced to stoning, and the heifer whose neck is broken when a slain man is found and the killer is unknown. In each the question is the same: what if the truth comes out before the deciding act, and what if only after it? Before the act, each simply goes back to graze with the flock. After it, each has its own rule: the guilt-offering is buried, or its meat burned if the blood was thrown; benefit from the stoned ox is permitted, since it was never guilty; and the heifer is buried in its place, for it came for a doubt and has atoned for it.