Principle

Vadaiוַדַּאי

VA-DAI

Definite — opposite of safek

Definite, certain — as opposed to safek (doubtful). A vadai mamzer is certainly disqualified from kahal; a safek mamzer is doubtful. The first view in Kiddushin 4:3 permits all who are barred from the kahal to marry one another, but Rabbi Eliezer permits only vadai with vadai (a mamzer with a mamzeret) and forbids vadai with safek, safek with vadai, and safek with safek — because the safek partner might in fact be kasher and would therefore be marrying down. The doubtful cases are the shtuki, the asufi and the kuti.

Where it comes up

4 mishnayot

  1. Demai 4:4Tithe-gifts on ShabbatThe poor man's tithe here is of produce known to be untithed, not demai — because for such produce the Israelite himself names and gives it, whereas demai's poor man's tithe need not even be separated, as the previous mishnah taught.
  2. Demai 5:11Tithing between demai and untithed produceProduce known to be untithed owes tithes by Torah law without any doubt. Pairing demai (doubtful) against it (certain) is the engine of this mishnah, exactly mirroring the pots without and with a hole.
  3. Kiddushin 4:3Certain with certain is permitted; doubtful with anything is notTwo people who are certainly of flawed lineage may marry, since neither might secretly be of good lineage.
  4. Ohalot 7:4The first house is doubtful, the second certainThe second house is the one place the birth is known to have happened, so it is impure for certain. The mishnah sets the two rooms side by side to sharpen the contrast — one stillborn child, certain impurity here and mere doubt there.