Person
shomer sacharשׁוֹמֵר שָׂכָר
SHO-mer sa-KHAR
Paid bailee — liable for theft and loss
A shomer sachar is a paid bailee — one who receives payment for guarding another's object. Because he benefits, he is held to a stricter standard than the unpaid guardian: he is liable not only for negligence but also for ordinary theft and loss of the deposit. He is still exempt, by oath, for unavoidable accidents (onsin) beyond his control. A renter (socher) is generally held to this same standard.
Where it comes up
6 mishnayot
- Bava Metzia 6:6Which kind of guardian is each one?A craftsman holding an object to repair it benefits by holding it as security for his pay, so he holds it as a paid guardian, liable for theft and loss, not merely negligence.
- Bava Metzia 6:7Is the lender a paid or unpaid guardian?The first opinion: a lender holding a borrower's pledge counts as a paid guardian, because the mitzvah of lending is itself the 'benefit' that raises his guardianship to the paid standard.
- Bava Metzia 6:8An oath that even the sage wondered atThe mishnah groups the unpaid and the paid guardian together: both who break a barrel they were carrying may clear themselves by oath, a leniency the Sages enacted so people would agree to carry barrels at all.
- Bava Metzia 7:8The four guardiansThis is the anchor mishnah for the paid guardian: he is paid to guard, so he is liable for theft and loss but exempt by oath for unavoidable accidents.
- Shevuot 8:1The four guardians — who swears and who paysThe paid guardian (and the renter alongside him) occupies the middle standard: he swears himself free of unavoidable accidents but must pay for ordinary loss and theft, the cases this very mishnah lists.
- Shevuot 8:6From liability to exemption — the rule that closes ShevuotThe paid guardian and renter share one middle standard, so swapping among their three exempting accidents — death, injury, capture — denies no money and brings no offering.