Chullin 6:3חֻלִּיןA deaf-mute, one without understanding, a minor — watched or alone
Their slaughter — covering the blood, and it and its young
The question
Does slaughter by a deaf-mute, an imbecile, or a minor require covering or count for 'it and its offspring'?
Supervised versus unsupervised for covering, then for 'it and its offspring,' with Rabbi Meir and the Sages, and a concession.
Tap a Hebrew word for its meaning. Tap a bold phrase to see the words it translates.
1Supervised: must cover
If a deaf-mute, a person without understanding, or a minor slaughtered while others watched, those who watched must cover the blood.
חֵרֵשׁ, שׁוֹטֶה וְקָטָן שֶׁשָּׁחֲטוּ וַאֲחֵרִים רוֹאִין אוֹתָן, חַיָּב לְכַסּוֹת.
A deaf-mute, a person without understanding, or a minor who slaughtered while others watched them, making it a valid slaughter: one is obligated to cover [the blood] — those who watched cover it.
1 note
וַאֲחֵרִים רוֹאִין אוֹתָן
- Bartenura: when others watch over them, the slaughter of these three is valid, just as the Mishnah taught at the opening of the tractate.
- Bartenura: the "others" who watched are the ones obligated to cover the blood, as the Mishnah later teaches — "if one slaughtered and did not cover, and another saw, that other is obligated to cover."
Bartenura
2Unsupervised: exempt
If they slaughtered unsupervised, among themselves, there is no obligation to cover.
בֵּינָן לְבֵין עַצְמָם, פָּטוּר מִלְּכַסּוֹת.
[If they slaughtered] among themselves — a deaf-mute, a person without understanding, or a minor, with no one watching — one is exempt from covering, for most of what they do comes out botched.
1 note
בֵּינָן לְבֵין עַצְמָם, פָּטוּר
- Bartenura: this exemption is Rabbi Meir's view, who holds that an unsupervised slaughter by a deaf-mute, a person without understanding, or a minor is an outright carcass, since most of their acts come out botched — so there is nothing to cover.
- The Sages disagree even here: they regard it only as a doubtful carcass, so for covering they would hold one obligated.
- Tosafot Yom Tov: the Ran adds that one does not act stringently, since the animal stays in its prior forbidden status until we know it was properly slaughtered.
Bartenura · Tosafot Yom Tov
3Supervised: may not follow
The same holds for slaughtering it and its young: if they were watched, one may not slaughter the other the same day.
וְכֵן לְעִנְיַן אוֹתוֹ וְאֶת בְּנוֹ, שֶׁשָּׁחֲטוּ וַאֲחֵרִים רוֹאִין אוֹתָן, אָסוּר לִשְׁחֹט אַחֲרֵיהֶם.
And likewise for [slaughtering] it and its young [on one day]: if they slaughtered [one] while others watched them — a deaf-mute, a person without understanding, or a minor — it is forbidden to slaughter [the other] after them, for theirs was a valid slaughter.
1 note
אוֹתוֹ וְאֶת בְּנוֹ
- The Torah forbids slaughtering an animal and its offspring on the same day: "you shall not slaughter it and its young in one day" (Vayikra 22:28).
- Bartenura: since the supervised slaughter of these three counts as a valid slaughter, the day's prohibition takes effect — so one may not slaughter the mother's offspring afterward.
Bartenura
4Unsupervised: a dispute
If unwatched, Rabbi Meir permits slaughtering the other afterward; the Sages forbid it.
בֵּינָן לְבֵין עַצְמָן, רַבִּי מֵאִיר מַתִּיר לִשְׁחֹט אַחֲרֵיהֶן, וַחֲכָמִים אוֹסְרִים.
[If they slaughtered] among themselves — a deaf-mute, a person without understanding, or a minor, unwatched — Rabbi Meir permits slaughtering [the other] after them, for to him theirs was no slaughter, and the Sages forbid it, since it may have been a valid one.
The picture The picture in words
- A deaf-mute, one without understanding, or a minor slaughtered alone. Rabbi Meir says most of what they do comes out botched, so it was no slaughter, the blood needs no covering, and its young may be slaughtered today. The Sages say it may have been valid, so they forbid it.
- When others watched them, their slaughter is valid. Everyone agrees the watchers must cover the blood, and its young may not be slaughtered that day.
1 note
רַבִּי מֵאִיר מַתִּיר
- Bartenura: Rabbi Meir, consistent with his view that an unsupervised slaughter by these three is an outright carcass, holds it was no real slaughter — so the mother-offspring prohibition never took hold, and one may slaughter the offspring.
- The Sages treat it as a doubtful slaughter, so out of doubt they forbid slaughtering the offspring after them.
- Bartenura: here the halacha follows Rabbi Meir.
Bartenura
5Agreed: no lashes
The Sages agree that if one did slaughter the other, he does not receive the forty lashes.
וּמוֹדִים שֶׁאִם שָׁחַט, שֶׁאֵינוֹ סוֹפֵג אֶת הָאַרְבָּעִים.
And [the Sages] agree that if one did slaughter [the other] after their unwatched slaughter, he does not receive the forty lashes, for it is only a doubt.
1 note
שֶׁאֵינוֹ סוֹפֵג אֶת הָאַרְבָּעִים
- "The forty" are the lashes incurred for transgressing a Torah prohibition (in practice thirty-nine).
- The Sages forbid slaughtering the offspring only out of doubt, since perhaps the mother was properly slaughtered.
- But because it remains only a doubt, one who did slaughter the offspring is not flogged: lashes are never administered for a doubtful transgression.
Bartenura
Summary
When a deaf-mute, a person without understanding, or a minor slaughters a wild animal or bird under supervision, the slaughter is valid, and the supervisor is obligated to cover the blood. If they slaughtered unsupervised, among themselves, one is exempt from covering — because, in Rabbi Meir's view, an unsupervised slaughter by these three is presumed a carcass, since most of their acts come out botched. The same split governs the Torah's prohibition against slaughtering a mother and its young on one day: if supervised, the other may not be slaughtered afterward; if unsupervised, Rabbi Meir permits the other (the prohibition never took hold) while the Sages forbid it out of doubt. Even the Sages concede that one who did slaughter the other is not flogged, since lashes are never given for a doubtful transgression.