Bechorot 8:4בְּכוֹרוֹתCounting the redemptions

Two wives, mixed-up sons

The question

How many redemptions does a man owe when his two wives give birth?

Four cases for two first-time wives, then four when only one is first-time, including Rabbi Meir and Rabbi Yehudah on heirs.

Tap a Hebrew word for its meaning. Tap a bold phrase to see the words it translates.

  1. 1Two males: ten sela

    Two first-time mothers married to one man each bore a son; both are certainly firstborn, so he gives ten sela.

    שְׁתֵּי נָשִׁים שֶׁלֹּא בִכְּרוּ וְיָלְדוּ שְׁנֵי זְכָרִים, נוֹתֵן עֶשֶׂר סְלָעִים לַכֹּהֵן.

    Two wives who had not given birth before, and they bore two males — wives of one man, each son opening his own mother's womb — he gives ten sela to the kohen.

    Concepts here

    1 note

    נוֹתֵן עֶשֶׂר סְלָעִים לַכֹּהֵן

    • Each wife is a first-time mother, so each son certainly opened his own mother's womb.
    • Both are therefore firstborn, even if the babies were mixed up, so the father owes two full redemptions — ten sela.

    Bartenura

  2. 2One dies: one or two kohanim

    If one son dies within thirty days: if he paid one kohen ten sela, the kohen returns five; if he paid two kohanim, he cannot reclaim from either.

    מֵת אֶחָד מֵהֶן בְּתוֹךְ שְׁלשִׁים יוֹם, אִם לְכֹהֵן אֶחָד נָתַן, יַחֲזִיר לוֹ חָמֵשׁ סְלָעִים. אִם לִשְׁנֵי כֹהֲנִים נָתַן, אֵינוֹ יָכוֹל לְהוֹצִיא מִיָּדָם.

    If one of them dies within thirty days — that son was never due to be redeemed — if he gave to one kohen, [the kohen] returns five sela to him; if he gave to two kohanim, he cannot take it back from them — each kohen can say, "Mine was for the living son."

    The picture
    The picture in words
    1. He paid ten sela to one kohen for two boys, and one died within thirty days, so that son was never owed. The kohen surely holds five sela that were not due, so he returns them (Bartenura).
    2. Here he paid five sela to each of two kohanim. Each can say his five were for the living son, and the father cannot prove otherwise, so nothing comes back (Bartenura).
    2 notes

    יַחֲזִיר לוֹ חָמֵשׁ סְלָעִים

    • One son died within thirty days, so it turns out he was never owed redemption.
    • If both redemptions went to a single kohen, he must return five sela, since he received that amount unlawfully.

    Bartenura

    אֵינוֹ יָכוֹל לְהוֹצִיא מִיָּדָם

    • If the two payments went to two different kohanim, neither can be made to return anything.
    • Each kohen can say, "the five sela I hold is for the living child," and the father cannot prove otherwise.

    Bartenura

  3. 3Mixed births: five sela

    If the two wives between them bore a boy and a girl, or two boys and a girl, one boy is certainly firstborn, so he gives five sela.

    זָכָר וּנְקֵבָה אוֹ שְׁנֵי זְכָרִים וּנְקֵבָה, נוֹתֵן חָמֵשׁ סְלָעִים לַכֹּהֵן.

    A male and a female, or two males and a female — one boy is surely a firstborn — he gives five sela to the kohen.

    1 note

    נוֹתֵן חָמֵשׁ סְלָעִים לַכֹּהֵן

    • Whichever way you turn it, one firstborn male is certain.
    • If one wife bore two boys, the first is firstborn; if she bore a boy and a girl, then the other wife bore a lone boy, who is firstborn.
    • So a single five-sela redemption is owed; the son paired with a possible firstborn girl is exempt by doubt.

    Bartenura

  4. 4More females: nothing

    But two girls and a boy, or two boys and two girls — the kohen gets nothing, since a girl may have been born first to each mother.

    שְׁתֵּי נְקֵבוֹת וְזָכָר אוֹ שְׁנֵי זְכָרִים וּשְׁתֵּי נְקֵבוֹת, אֵין כָּאן לַכֹּהֵן כְּלוּם.

    Two females and a male, or two males and two females — perhaps each wife bore a girl first — the kohen has nothing here.

    The picture
    The picture in words
    1. With a boy and a girl, the boy is surely a firstborn, so the kohen gets five sela.
    2. With two boys and a girl, one boy is surely first to his mother, so again the kohen gets five sela.
    3. With two girls and a boy, a girl may have come first to each wife, so the kohen gets nothing.
    4. With two boys and two girls, again a girl may have come first to each. The kohen is the one claiming and must prove it, so he gets nothing (Bartenura).
    1 note

    אֵין כָּאן לַכֹּהֵן כְּלוּם

    • In these mixes it can always be claimed that a girl opened the womb first for each mother.
    • Since no male is certainly a firstborn, the kohen receives nothing.

    Bartenura

  5. 5One first-time: five sela

    Now one wife had given birth before and one had not, and both bore boys: one boy is certainly firstborn, so he gives five sela.

    אַחַת בִּכְּרָה וְאַחַת שֶׁלֹּא בִכְּרָה וְיָלְדוּ שְׁנֵי זְכָרִים. נוֹתֵן חָמֵשׁ סְלָעִים לַכֹּהֵן.

    One had given birth before and one had not, and they bore two males — only the first-time mother's son is a firstborn — he gives five sela to the kohen.

    1 note

    נוֹתֵן חָמֵשׁ סְלָעִים לַכֹּהֵן

    • The son of the first-time mother certainly opened her womb and is firstborn.
    • So one five-sela redemption is owed, even though the boys were mixed up.

    Bartenura

  6. 6One dies: exempt

    If one of the two boys then dies within thirty days, the father is exempt — perhaps the one who died was the firstborn.

    מֵת אֶחָד מֵהֶן בְּתוֹךְ שְׁלשִׁים יוֹם, הָאָב פָּטוּר.

    If one of them dies within thirty days, the father is exempt — the babies got mixed up, so the dead one may be the firstborn.

    1 note

    הָאָב פָּטוּר

    • It can be said that the son of the first-time mother — the firstborn — is the one who died.
    • Since redemption never takes hold on a child who dies within thirty days, and the doubt cannot be resolved, the father pays nothing.

    Bartenura

  7. 7Father died: a dispute

    If the father dies, Rabbi Meir and Rabbi Yehudah dispute the heirs' duty, as in the last mishnah.

    מֵת הָאָב וְהַבָּנִים קַיָּמִין, רַבִּי מֵאִיר אוֹמֵר, אִם נָתְנוּ עַד שֶׁלֹּא חָלְקוּ, נָתָנוּ. וְאִם לָאו, פְּטוּרִין. רַבִּי יְהוּדָה אוֹמֵר, נִתְחַיְּבוּ נְכָסִים.

    If the father died and the sons are alive, Rabbi Meir says: if they gave before they divided [the estate], they gave [validly]; but if not, they are exempt. Divided brothers count as buyers, and a debt not in writing is not collected from buyers. Rabbi Yehudah says: the property became obligated. The heirs must pay even after dividing.

    1 note

    אִם נָתְנוּ עַד שֶׁלֹּא חָלְקוּ

    • This is the same dispute as in the third mishnah.
    • Rabbi Meir treats brothers who divided as buyers, so a spoken debt cannot reach the divided estate and they are exempt.
    • Rabbi Yehudah treats them as full heirs, so the obligation reaches the property either way.
    • The halachah follows Rabbi Yehudah.

    Bartenura

  8. 8Male and female: nothing

    If the two wives bore a boy and a girl, the kohen gets nothing — perhaps the first-time mother bore the girl.

    זָכָר וּנְקֵבָה, אֵין כָּאן לַכֹּהֵן כְּלוּם:

    A male and a female — perhaps the first-time mother bore the girl — the kohen has nothing here.

    1 note

    אֵין כָּאן לַכֹּהֵן כְּלוּם

    • It can be said that the wife who had not given birth before bore the girl, while the boy belongs to the wife who had already given birth.
    • Then no firstborn male exists, so the kohen receives nothing.

    Bartenura

Summary

This mishnah counts redemptions when one man has two wives whose sons were mixed up. When both are first-time mothers and both bore boys, each son opened his own mother's womb, so two firstborns are certain and the father owes ten sela. If a son dies within thirty days, the refund depends on whether one kohen or two received the money: one kohen must return five, but two kohanim each keep their share by claiming it was for the living child. The mishnah then runs through the mixes of boys and girls — a single certain firstborn obligates five sela, while combinations where a girl could have come first to each mother free the father. When one wife had given birth before and one had not, one firstborn is again certain; and when the father dies, the dispute between Rabbi Meir and Rabbi Yehudah about the heirs returns.