Yevamot 2:1יְבָמוֹתHow does "a brother who did not live in his time" actually exempt?
The brother born too late
The question
How does the wife of a brother born after his death exempt her rival wife?
A question, a case of a brother born after one died, the ruling for both wives, then a ma'amar variation.
Tap a Hebrew word for its meaning. Tap a bold phrase to see the words it translates.
1How does this category work?
The framing question: how does the case of "a brother born after the deceased" actually trigger the exemption from mishnah 1?
כֵּיצַד אֵשֶׁת אָחִיו שֶׁלֹּא הָיָה בְעוֹלָמוֹ.
How [is it with] the wife of his brother who did not live in his time? She is one of the fifteen forbidden relatives who free their co-wives.
2The case: a brother born later
One brother died childless, a third brother was then born, and the second brother married the widow before dying himself.
שְׁנֵי אַחִים, וּמֵת אֶחָד מֵהֶם, וְנוֹלַד לָהֶן אָח, וְאַחַר כָּךְ יִבֵּם הַשֵּׁנִי אֶת אֵשֶׁת אָחִיו, וָמֵת.
Two brothers, and one of them died childless, and a brother was born to them, and afterward the second took his brother's wife in levirate marriage, and he died, leaving her and his own wife to the newborn brother.
1 note
וְנוֹלַד לָהֶן אָח
- The crux. The Torah's verse for yibum (Devarim 25:5) reads "כִּי יֵשְׁבוּ אַחִים יַחְדָּו" — "when brothers dwell together." The Sages derive: brothers who NEVER coexisted don't trigger yibum on each other.
- Reuven died childless; then Levi was born — Bartenura: he found her bound to a yavam, and to him she is forbidden as the wife of a brother who was not in his world. Afterward Shimon, who had another wife, did yibum with Reuven's widow.
- Now Shimon dies. His two widows — Reuven's original widow (now married to Shimon) and Shimon's own wife — both fall before Levi.
- But Levi was never "in Reuven's world" — they never coexisted. So Reuven's wife is forever forbidden to him. And once she's forbidden, she's a tzarah-of-ervah engine for the OTHER widow.
Bartenura
3Both wives go free
Both widows go free — the first as wife of a brother never alive with him, the second as her co-wife.
הָרִאשׁוֹנָה יוֹצֵאת מִשּׁוּם אֵשֶׁת אָחִיו שֶׁלֹּא הָיָה בְעוֹלָמוֹ, וְהַשְּׁנִיָּה מִשּׁוּם צָרָתָהּ.
The first goes free — the first brother's widow — as the wife of his brother who did not live in his time, and the second — the second brother's own wife — as her co-wife.
The picture The picture in words
- Brother 1 dies childless.
- A brother is born who never lived in brother 1's time.
- Brother 2, who has a wife, takes the widow in levirate marriage.
- Brother 2 dies, so both widows fall before the newborn brother.
- The first goes free, as the wife of a brother who did not live in his time.
- The second goes free as her co-wife.
1 note
הָרִאשׁוֹנָה יוֹצֵאת
- Reuven's widow is the ervah here — she's permanently the "wife of a brother who didn't coexist" with Levi, even though she now "belongs" to Shimon by virtue of yibum.
- That original status sticks: once she became forbidden to Levi via Reuven's death, no later marriage can erase it. Even now that Shimon is the technical husband, Levi still couldn't yibum her.
- Her tzarah (Shimon's own wife) is exempt by the chain rule of perek 1 — tzarah of an ervah goes free.
Bartenura · Tosafot Yom Tov
4If he only did ma'amar
If the second brother had made only a levirate betrothal before dying, his own widow performs chalitzah but not levirate marriage.
עָשָׂה בָהּ מַאֲמָר וָמֵת, הַשְּׁנִיָּה חוֹלֶצֶת וְלֹא מִתְיַבֶּמֶת:
If he made a levirate betrothal with her — the second brother, betrothing the first one's widow with money before marrying her — and he died, the second [wife] performs chalitzah, the release ceremony, but is not taken in levirate marriage: a levirate betrothal binds only partly, so she is only partly a forbidden relative's co-wife.
The picture The picture in words
Brother 2 only betrothed the first widow before he died. Bartenura explains that a levirate betrothal binds her only partly, so the second is only partly a forbidden relative’s co-wife. She does chalitzah, the release ceremony, but is not taken in levirate marriage.
Concepts here
2 notes
מַאֲמָר
- Ma'amar is the rabbinic ceremony of betrothing the yevamah with money or document, before the act of yibum-bi'ah completes the mitzvah.
- Torah-level: a yevamah is acquired only through bi'ah (intercourse). Money and shtar don't truly bind her; the Sages added ma'amar as a way to formalize the engagement.
- Bartenura: so ma'amar is a half-acquisition. She's partly Shimon's wife, partly still Reuven's widow.
Bartenura · Rambam Commentary
הַשְּׁנִיָּה חוֹלֶצֶת וְלֹא מִתְיַבֶּמֶת
- Why does the second widow now drop into the half-state?
- Because Shimon never fully made Reuven's widow his wife — only half. So Shimon's own wife is only "half a tzarah" of an ervah.
- Half-tzarah of an ervah → the standard fallback: chalitzah but no yibum. Don't fully exempt (the ervah link isn't absolute), but don't fully obligate (the ervah link IS partly there).
- This is the recurring pattern of the perek. Bartenura: wherever there are no complete kiddushin, she does chalitzah and not yibum.
- Tosafot Yom Tov (from the Gemara): since the halachah is that the levirate bond (zikah) is itself real, the second wife does chalitzah and not yibum even if he made no ma'amar at all. The mishnah mentions ma'amar to reject Beit Shammai, who hold that ma'amar is a full acquisition (3:5) — which would exempt her without chalitzah.
Bartenura · Tosafot Yom Tov
Summary
Perek 2 opens by unpacking the strangest entry in mishnah 1's list — "the wife of his brother who did not live in his time." The setup: Reuven dies childless; then Levi is born; afterward Shimon, who has a wife of his own, takes Reuven's widow in levirate marriage. Then Shimon dies, leaving two widows before Levi. But Levi never lived at the same time as Reuven — the Torah's "brothers dwelling together" excludes him. So Reuven's widow is forever forbidden to Levi, and her co-wife (Shimon's own wife) goes free as a forbidden relative's co-wife. The closing variation introduces the levirate betrothal — betrothing the widow with money before marrying her — which makes only half a marriage. Where the bond is partial, the mishnah falls back on chalitzah without levirate marriage. That "partial" pattern will return throughout the perek.