Menachot 1:2מְנָחוֹתWho may take the handful

Who may scoop, and how

The question

Who may scoop the handful from a meal-offering, and how must it be scooped?

A list of unfit scoopers, the left hand with Ben Beteira dissenting, a handful too full or too small, then the proper technique.

Tap a Hebrew word for its meaning. Tap a bold phrase to see the words it translates.

  1. 1Unfit scoopers disqualify

    A long list of people barred from taking the handful — if any of them takes it, the offering is invalid.

    אַחַת מִנְחַת חוֹטֵא וְאַחַת כָּל הַמְּנָחוֹת שֶׁקְּמָצָן זָר, אוֹנֵן, טְבוּל יוֹם, מְחֻסַּר בְּגָדִים, מְחֻסַּר כִּפּוּרִים, שֶׁלֹּא רְחוּץ יָדַיִם וְרַגְלַיִם, עָרֵל, טָמֵא, יוֹשֵׁב, עוֹמֵד עַל גַּבֵּי כֵלִים, עַל גַּבֵּי בְהֵמָה, עַל גַּבֵּי רַגְלֵי חֲבֵרוֹ, פָּסָל.

    Whether the sinner's meal-offering or any other meal-offering, if its handful was taken by a non-kohen, an acute mourner, one who immersed that day, one lacking [priestly] garments, one lacking atonement — one whose relative is not yet buried; one pure only at nightfall; one still owing his closing offering — one who had not washed his hands and feet, an uncircumcised [kohen], a [ritually] impure [kohen], one who [took it] sitting, or standing on vessels, on an animal, or on another's feet — he must stand, with nothing between his feet and the floor — has made it invalid.

    The picture
    The picture in words

    Only a fit kohen may take the handful. He must wear his priestly garments, wash his hands and feet, and stand on the floor itself with nothing in between. If any of the people listed here takes it, he has made the meal-offering invalid.

    Concepts here

    3 notes

    זָר, אוֹנֵן, טְבוּל יוֹם

    • Bartenura notes that all these unfit performers are explained at length in the second chapter of tractate Zevachim, where each is derived from a verse.
    • Zar: a non-kohen, who may not perform Temple service at all.
    • Onen: a kohen on the day a close relative died, before burial — barred from service that day.
    • Tevul yom: someone who was impure, immersed in a mikveh, but must wait until nightfall to be fully pure; until then he may not serve.

    Bartenura · Rambam Commentary

    עָרֵל

    • 'Arel' here means a kohen who is uncircumcised — specifically one whose brothers died as a result of circumcision, so he himself was never circumcised out of danger.
    • Even though his situation is no fault of his own, he is still unfit to perform the Temple service.
    • 'Mechusar kippurim' (lacking atonement) refers to someone mid-purification — for example after certain impurities — who immersed but still owes a final offering before he is fully fit.
    • Washing the hands and feet from the laver, the basin in the courtyard, was required before any service.

    Bartenura

    יוֹשֵׁב, עוֹמֵד עַל גַּבֵּי כֵלִים

    • The Temple service must be performed standing — Bartenura notes the Torah requires the kohen 'to stand and serve'.
    • So a kohen who scoops while sitting has disqualified the offering.
    • It also requires that nothing separate the kohen's feet from the Temple floor. Standing on vessels, on an animal, or on another person's feet creates a barrier (chatzitzah) between him and the floor — and disqualifies the service.

    Bartenura

  2. 2Left hand: Ben Beteira's view

    Taking the handful with the left hand makes it invalid; Ben Beteira says put it back and take it again with the right.

    קָמַץ בִּשְׂמֹאל, פָּסָל. בֶּן בְּתֵירָא אוֹמֵר, יַחֲזִיר וְיַחֲזֹר וְיִקְמֹץ בְּיָמִין.

    If he took the handful with his left hand, he has made it invalid. It must be taken with the right. Ben Beteira says: He puts it back, and takes the handful again with the right hand.

    2 notes

    קָמַץ בִּשְׂמֹאל, פָּסָל

    • The kemitzah must be done with the right hand. Tosafot Yom Tov cites the Gemara, which derives from the verses that wherever the Torah says 'kaf' (palm) regarding service, it means the right hand.
    • If a kohen scoops with his left hand, the first opinion holds the offering is simply disqualified — there is no fixing it.

    Bartenura · Tosafot Yom Tov

    בֶּן בְּתֵירָא אוֹמֵר, יַחֲזִיר

    • Ben Beteira disagrees: the kohen returns the scooped flour back into the meal-offering and then a fit kohen scoops again, this time with the right hand.
    • Bartenura notes Ben Beteira would say the same for all the unfit cases listed above — if one of them scooped, return it and let a fit kohen re-scoop.
    • Bartenura concludes: the halacha is NOT like Ben Beteira; once disqualified, it cannot be re-scooped.

    Bartenura · Rambam Commentary

  3. 3Something foreign in the handful

    If a pebble, a grain of salt, or a bit of frankincense came up in the handful, it is invalid for being too small.

    קָמַץ וְעָלָה בְיָדוֹ צְרוֹר אוֹ גַרְגִּיר מֶלַח אוֹ קֹרֶט שֶׁל לְבוֹנָה, פָּסַל, מִפְּנֵי שֶׁאָמְרוּ, הַקֹּמֶץ הַיָּתֵר וְהֶחָסֵר, פָּסוּל.

    If he took the handful and a pebble, a grain of salt, or a bit of frankincense came up in his hand — each takes up room meant for flour, leaving the handful short — he has made it invalid, for they said: A handful too large or too small is invalid.

    2 notes

    קָמַץ וְעָלָה בְיָדוֹ צְרוֹר

    • Before scooping, the kohen first pushes all the frankincense to one side, scoops the flour, then gathers the frankincense back to burn with the fistful.
    • If a pebble, a grain of salt, or a speck of frankincense ends up inside the scooped fistful, it occupies space that should have been pure flour — so the fistful is now short of the required measure of flour.
    • Bartenura explains the disqualification is therefore really about a 'lacking' fistful: the foreign object means there isn't a full kometz of flour.

    Bartenura · Tosafot Yom Tov

    הַקֹּמֶץ הַיָּתֵר וְהֶחָסֵר, פָּסוּל

    • A valid fistful must be an exact, full kometz — neither overflowing ('outsized', yater) nor short ('lacking', chaser).
    • An outsized fistful holds more than the hand can properly grip; a lacking one holds too little.
    • The next sentences define each of these precisely.

    Bartenura

  4. 4Overflowing or fingertips

    The mishnah defines the handful too large and the handful too small.

    אֵיזֶה הוּא הַיָּתֵר, שֶׁקְּמָצוֹ מְבֹרָץ. וְחָסֵר, שֶׁקְּמָצוֹ בְרָאשֵׁי אֶצְבְּעוֹתָיו.

    Which is the one too large? If he took it heaped up, so full it spills over. And the one too small? If he took it with the tips of his fingers, not across his whole palm.

    2 notes

    שֶׁקְּמָצוֹ מְבֹרָץ

    • 'Mevoratz' means full and heaped over — the flour overflows the hand so the fingers cannot properly close and grip it.
    • Bartenura defines it simply as 'full and overflowing'.
    • Because the fingers can't hold it in the proper way, this overflowing fistful is invalid.

    Bartenura · Rambam Commentary

    שֶׁקְּמָצוֹ בְרָאשֵׁי אֶצְבְּעוֹתָיו

    • The 'lacking' fistful is one taken only with the fingertips, without drawing the fingers across the full palm of the hand.
    • Such a scoop holds too little flour to be a valid kometz.
    • Bartenura: he did not spread his fingers across the whole palm of his hand.

    Bartenura

  5. 5The proper technique

    Finally, the mishnah describes the correct physical technique of scooping.

    כֵּיצַד הוּא עוֹשֶׂה, פּוֹשֵׁט אֶת אֶצְבְּעוֹתָיו עַל פַּס יָדוֹ.

    How does he do it? He spreads his fingers out over the palm of his hand, sweeping flour in and leveling it with his thumb above and little finger below.

    The picture
    The picture in words
    1. He spreads his three middle fingers over his palm, and his thumb and little finger level the flour above and below. That gives exactly a full handful, so it is valid.
    2. Here the flour is heaped up until it spills over his fingers. That is a handful too large, so it is invalid.
    3. Here he took the flour with only the tips of his fingers, not across his palm. That is a handful too small, so it is invalid.
    4. A pebble came up in his hand and takes up room meant for flour. The handful is short, so it is invalid.
    1 note

    פּוֹשֵׁט אֶת אֶצְבְּעוֹתָיו עַל פַּס יָדוֹ

    • The kohen draws the sides of his fingers through the flour, bringing it into his palm, then smooths off the excess — with his pinky below and his thumb above — so no flour spills past the fistful.
    • Bartenura calls this one of the most difficult services in the Temple, since it took great skill to scoop exactly a full kometz, neither lacking nor overflowing.
    • He cites Rambam, who held that the kohen simply fills his palm the way people normally grab a handful; Bartenura himself, however, defends the more demanding technique and says all his teachers explained it that way.

    Bartenura · Rambam Commentary

Summary

Having established the rule of a handful taken not for its own sake, the mishnah now turns to who may take the handful and how. A long list of people barred from the service — a non-kohen, a mourner before burial, one not yet fully purified, an uncircumcised or impure kohen, one who had not washed his hands and feet, and one who takes it sitting or off the floor — all make the offering invalid. So does taking it with the left hand, though Ben Beteira says to put it back and take it again with the right. The handful must be exactly full: a pebble or a grain of salt in it leaves it too small, a heaped one is too large, and both are invalid. The mishnah closes by describing the exact hand technique.