Principle

simanimסִימָנִים

SEE-MA-NEEM

Identifying marks on a lost object

Distinguishing marks by which the owner of a lost object can prove it is his — a number, a position, a knot, an embedded item, a maker's distinctive shaping. Simanim are the hinge of the laws of lost objects: a find that bears a siman must be announced, because the owner can describe it and so has not despaired of recovery, while a mark-less find is presumed abandoned and belongs to the finder. To reclaim a lost object, a claimant must state its simanim, not merely name what kind of object it is.

Where it comes up

5 mishnayot

  1. Bava Metzia 1:8Returning found court documentsA lost object with a reliable identifying mark must be returned, since the owner can prove it is his; the pouch, the roll, and the bundle each serve as that mark.
  2. Bava Metzia 2:1Lost objects with no identifying marksEvery item on this list lacks an identifying mark, so the owner has no way to prove it is his and gives up hope, leaving it to the finder.
  3. Bava Metzia 2:2When the find carries a markEach item here carries a distinguishing mark — a container, a purse, a particular number, a position, a household's loaf-shape — so the owner can still describe and reclaim it, and the finder must announce.
  4. Bava Metzia 2:5The garment as the model for every findThe garment is the Torah's model case for every find that must be announced — and the two features that define it are exactly identifying marks and someone claiming it.
  5. Bava Metzia 2:7Marks, swindlers, and a working beastIdentifying marks are the currency of proof here: a claimant earns back his lost object only by describing its identifying marks, not merely by naming the kind of item it is.