Person
shoelשׁוֹאֵל
sho-EL
Borrower — liable for almost everything
A shoel is a borrower — one who receives another's object to use for free. Because he enjoys the entire benefit while giving nothing in return, he bears the heaviest liability of the four guardians: he must make good almost any loss, including unavoidable accidents (onsin) such as the object's death or breakage. The classic exception is meitah machmat melachah — if the borrowed item dies or breaks in the very course of the work it was lent for, he is exempt.
Where it comes up
6 mishnayot
- Bava Metzia 3:2The rented cow lent to a third manA borrower gets the use for free, so he bears the heaviest liability of all four bailees, even for an accident he could not prevent. That is exactly why he must pay here while the renter swears free.
- Bava Metzia 7:8The four guardiansThe borrower receives the object to use for free, so he bears the heaviest liability of the four — listed here second among the guardians.
- Bava Metzia 8:1Borrowing the cow — and its ownerA borrower normally bears the heaviest liability — he even pays when the animal dies in an unavoidable accident. This whole mishnah is the one exemption that lifts that liability off him.
- Bava Metzia 8:3Sending the cow by messengerA borrower's strict liability only begins once the animal reaches his domain. This mishnah pinpoints that moment by tracking who arranged for the cow to be sent.
- Shevuot 8:1The four guardians — who swears and who paysThe borrower enjoys the full benefit of the object while paying nothing, so he carries the heaviest liability of the four — he pays for nearly every mishap, even an unavoidable accident.
- Shevuot 8:5When the borrower lies but owes either wayThe mirror image of mishnah 2: where the unpaid guardian owed nothing in all these cases, the borrower owes in all of them — so swapping one liable claim for another still denies no money.