Principle

peshiahפְּשִׁיעָה

pe-shi-AH

Negligence — liable

Peshiah is carelessness or negligence — failing to take a precaution one should have taken, such as leaving a hazard in a public road or not getting up to clear the way when one could. A person who is poshei'a (negligent) is liable for the harm that follows, in contrast to one struck by an unavoidable accident (oness), who is exempt. Drawing the line between peshiah and oness is the recurring task of the damage cases in this chapter.

Where it comes up

5 mishnayot

  1. Bava Kamma 3:3Straw, stubble, and dung in the streetLeaving straw to rot in the public road is careless use of a shared space; because it is a needless hazard, the Sages add a fine — the material is forfeited to whoever takes it first.
  2. Bava Kamma 3:4Walking in a line — when the first one is to blameThe first potter must pay for the second's losses, so the mishnah treats his part in the accident as negligence (peshiah), not mere bad luck.
  3. Bava Kamma 6:1The flock in the foldFailing to lock properly is negligence; because the owner's own carelessness opened the way for the escape, he bears the damage.
  4. Bava Kamma 6:2Negligent keepers and the animal in the gardenLeaving the animal to suffer in the sun, or entrusting it to those who cannot guard it, is negligence, so the owner remains liable for the damage it causes.
  5. Bava Kamma 6:6The spark, the camel, and the lampPlacing the lamp out in the public street, where passing loads can catch fire, is the shopkeeper's negligence, so liability shifts to him.