Category

mu'adמוּעָד

MU-AD

A warned, full-damage animal

An animal whose owner has been formally warned about its pattern of damage — classically an ox that has gored three times — is mu'ad, "forewarned." Its owner pays full damage (nezek shalem) for what it destroys, collected from his general property, not merely from the animal's own body. Mu'ad stands opposite tam (the innocuous animal that pays only half-damage from its own body), and the distinction runs throughout the laws of damage in Bava Kamma.

Where it comes up

7 mishnayot

  1. Bava Kamma 1:4Unwarned and warned — half the damage or fullThe mishnah sets the unwarned against the warned animal, whose owner has been warned and now pays in full, as the central distinction the whole chapter is building toward.
  2. Bava Kamma 2:4Unwarned and warned: how an ox earns and loses its recordAn ox becomes warned once witnesses testify that it gored on three days (Rabbi Yehudah) or three times (Rabbi Meir); from then its owner pays full damages from his best property.
  3. Bava Kamma 3:8Two oxen, two people — who pays how muchA warned ox has already gored three times and its owner was warned, so he now pays the full damage — here, the entire net difference rather than only half.
  4. Bava Kamma 3:11The pursuing ox and the claimant's burdenBecause a warned ox pays full damages and an unwarned one only half, the injured party wants to pin the harm on the warned ox; without proof, the rule that the one who would take money must bring proof decides against him.
  5. Bava Kamma 4:2An ox warned only some of the timeThe mishnah's whole point is that being warned is not all-or-nothing: an ox can be a known repeat-offender toward one target yet still unwarned toward another.
  6. Bava Kamma 4:5When an ox kills a personOnly the owner of a warned ox pays the ransom: the ox's proven, warned-about pattern of goring makes the owner answerable for the death, whereas an unwarned ox's first killing leaves him exempt from the ransom.
  7. Bava Kamma 4:9Handing the ox over, and the duty to guardThe custodian inherits the owner's exact liability: full damages if the ox is warned, half if unwarned — the same split that runs through the whole perek.