Principle

horaahהוֹרָאָה

ho-ra-AH

A binding court ruling

A binding halachic ruling issued by the court. Tractate Horayot is named for this act and turns on it: when the great court issues a mistaken horaah and the community acts on it, the court brings the par helem davar and the individuals who relied on the ruling are exempt. A ruling counts as a horaah only if it carves away part of a mitzvah on contested interpretive ground; uprooting an entire mitzvah, or a ruling by an unfit court, is not a horaah at all and triggers no communal offering.

Where it comes up

5 mishnayot

  1. Horayot 1:1Horayot opens — relying on the court vs. relying on yourselfThe whole tractate turns on the court's ruling: here an individual relies on its mistaken ruling, and relying on the court is what exempts him.
  2. Horayot 1:2The court reverses — but the news hasn't reached himThe court issued a mistaken ruling and then reversed it; Rabbi Shimon and Rabbi Eliezer dispute whether one who still acts on it counts as relying on a ruling that no longer stands.
  3. Horayot 1:3A matter — not the whole bodyThis mishnah sets the limit of a court's ruling: uprooting a whole mitzvah ("there is no Shabbat in the Torah") does not make the court liable to bring the bull.
  4. Horayot 1:4What disqualifies the ruling — and who acted unwittingly or deliberatelyThe shared word "congregation" requires every judge to be fit to rule; if even one is a convert, a mamzer, a Gibeonite or a childless old man, the ruling does not make the court liable.
  5. Horayot 1:5Rabbi Meir, Rabbi Yehudah, Rabbi Shimon — and the SagesThe Sages limit the whole law: only a ruling of the great court in Yerushalayim brings liability for the bull, not a ruling of a tribe's court.