Person
socherשׂוֹכֵר
so-KHER
Renter — pays to use, liable like a paid bailee
A socher is a renter — one who pays a fee to use another's object for a set time. His level of responsibility falls between the lighter and heavier guardians: as the Mishnah rules (Bava Metzia 7:8), he is held like a paid bailee (shomer sachar), liable for theft and loss but exempt by oath for unavoidable accidents such as the object's natural death. Because he pays only for the use and not to own the item, an unavoidable accident is not charged to him.
Where it comes up
10 mishnayot
- Bava Metzia 3:2The rented cow lent to a third manA renter pays to use an object. He is the third bailee: like a paid guardian, he answers for theft and loss, but not for an unavoidable death like this one.
- Bava Metzia 6:3The renter who changes the routeThe renter agreed to one route and used another. Because he changed the terms of the rental, he becomes liable for the animal's death even when the new path was no more dangerous.
- Bava Metzia 6:4The plowshare, the terrain, and the threshing-floorThe same renter principle as the donkey cases, now with a cow and plow: liability for a broken plowshare turns on whether the renter's change of terrain made the break more likely.
- Bava Metzia 6:5Loading the donkey heavier than agreedThe renter agreed to one kind of load and brought a bulkier one of equal weight. Because greater volume strains the animal as much as greater weight, his change makes him liable for any injury.
- Bava Metzia 7:8The four guardiansThe renter pays to use the object, and the mishnah holds him to the same standard as the paid guardian — closing out the list of four.
- Bava Metzia 8:2Which period did the cow die in?A renter pays for use and is liable only like a paid guardian — not for an unavoidable death. The whole dispute here turns on whether the cow died while borrowed (full liability) or while rented (exempt for accidents).
- Bava Metzia 8:6Renting a house — the notice periodThese mishnayot shift from renting animals to renting real estate. The renter of a house gets legal protection: the landlord cannot simply throw him out without the required notice.
- Bava Metzia 8:7What the landlord must provideThe mishnah divides upkeep duties between landlord and renter: the skilled fittings fall on the landlord, the simple repairs on the renter who lives there.
- Bava Metzia 8:8Rent and the leap-year monthWhen the lease wording is genuinely ambiguous — both 'per year' and 'per month' — neither the landlord nor the renter clearly wins, so in this case Rabban Shimon ben Gamliel and Rabbi Yosei split the disputed month between them.
- Bava Metzia 8:9Providing a replacement houseThe mishnah protects the renter (socher) one more way: a house that collapses mid-lease doesn't simply void the deal — the landlord owes a replacement for the remaining term.