Category

shenשֵׁן

SHEN

Damage by an animal's eating

Shen ('tooth') is one of the avot nezikin — damage an animal causes by eating. When an animal eats food fit for it, the damage is ordinary and foreseeable, so the owner is 'forewarned' and pays in full — but, like Regel, only on the injured party's property; in the public domain eating is exempt, since produce is left there at the owner's risk. Eating things unfit for it (clothing, vessels) is abnormal and is judged instead like Keren.

Where it comes up

4 mishnayot

  1. Bava Kamma 1:4Unwarned and warned — half the damage or fullEating produce fit for it is warned from the start, because an animal eating is entirely normal — the owner pays full damages without needing prior warnings.
  2. Bava Kamma 2:2Eating: the injured party's property, and 'what it benefited'This unit defines eating, one of the main kinds of damage. Like trampling it is routine and warned, so the owner pays in full when the animal eats food fit for it on the injured party's property.
  3. Bava Kamma 2:3Jumping animals — and the cake, the coal, and the haystackEating the cake on the owner of the haystack's property is plain eating damage — food fit for it, eaten on the injured party's ground — so the dog's owner pays in full.
  4. Bava Kamma 6:3The grain stack and the field owner's animalThe field owner's animal eating the stacked grain is classic damage by eating; but because the grain was placed there without permission, the owner of the animal does not pay.