Principle

onessאֹנֶס

O-NESS

Unavoidable accident — exempt

An oness is a harm that occurs through no fault of the person involved — an unavoidable accident he could not reasonably have prevented. In damage law, an oness generally exempts: a person who merely stumbles, for example, is treated as the victim of circumstances rather than as negligent. Oness stands opposite peshiah, deliberate or careless negligence, which obligates. Much of this chapter turns on which side of that line a given mishap falls.

Where it comes up

6 mishnayot

  1. Bava Kamma 3:1The jug in the public domainRabbi Yehudah treats the breaking itself as an oness — an unavoidable accident — so the owner is exempt unless he then chose to keep the shards, which would make them his property again.
  2. Bava Kamma 6:1The flock in the foldA wall breached at night or by bandits is an unavoidable accident; the owner could not have prevented it, so he is exempt for what the escaped flock damages.
  3. Bava Kamma 6:4The laws of fire that spreadsWhen the wind, not a person, spreads the fire, the damage is an unavoidable accident, beyond anyone's control, so all the people involved are exempt.
  4. Bava Metzia 7:8The four guardiansInjury, capture, and death are accidents no guardian could prevent: the paid guardian and renter swear and go free for these, but pay for theft and loss, which they could have prevented.
  5. Bava Metzia 7:9One wolf, two wolves, and unavoidable accidentsThis mishnah draws the line of an unavoidable accident for a paid shepherd: a single wolf is something he could have driven off, so it is not beyond his control, but two wolves overwhelm him and count as an accident.
  6. Bava Metzia 7:10Accident, fault, and changing the termsNatural death is the clearest unavoidable accident, nothing the guardian could prevent, so he swears and goes free; but a death he caused through abuse is his fault, not an accident.