Principle

Onaahאוֹנָאָה

O-NA-AH

Price fraud of a sixth

Onaah is wronging the other party in a sale through price: overcharging a buyer or underpaying a seller beyond an item's true market value. The law sets the threshold at one-sixth (shtut) of the price. A gap below a sixth is overlooked; a gap of exactly a sixth lets the wronged party recover the difference while the sale stands; a gap larger than a sixth voids the sale entirely. The wronged party must act within a short window. Onaah applies only to ordinary movable goods, not to land, slaves, documents, or consecrated property.

Where it comes up

3 mishnayot

  1. Bava Metzia 4:3Overcharging: when a price is unfairThis is the perek's central topic: overcharging, or underpaying, that distorts a fair price. The mishnah fixes the threshold at a sixth: an overcharge that large must be paid back.
  2. Bava Metzia 4:4Who can claim overcharging, and the wronged party's choiceOvercharging cuts both ways: it is not only the buyer who can be cheated by overpaying, but also the seller who can be cheated by underselling. Either wronged party may invoke the law.
  3. Bava Metzia 4:9Four things with no law of overchargingThe law of overcharging applies only to ordinary movable goods. Four categories are left out of it — slaves, documents, land, and consecrated property — so a price gap on these, even a large one, gives no claim.