Principle

Nichsim be-chezkatanנְכָסִים בְּחֶזְקָתָן

NICH-SIM BE-CHEZ-KA-TAN

Property stays with its presumed holder

Beit Hillel's rule for resolving an unresolvable monetary doubt: rather than dividing the property, it is left in the presumed possession (chazakah) of whoever currently holds it, and the party who would extract it must bring proof. It is the counter-position to Beit Shammai's 'yachloku' (they divide), and it governs the collapse cases where the order of death — and therefore who inherited whom — cannot be determined.

Where it comes up

1 mishnah

  1. Bava Batra 9:8The house fell — father and son, and who inherited whomBeit Hillel's rule for an unresolvable doubt: property stays with whoever currently presumptively holds it. Since the father was the last certain owner, the estate is left in his heirs' hands, and the creditors — who would extract it — must bring proof they cannot supply.