Object

Gezelגֵּזֶל

GE-ZEL

Robbery / the stolen object

Gezel is robbery — property seized openly from its owner — and by extension the stolen object itself. The governing rule of restitution is that a robber pays according to the value of the gezel at the time of the robbery: if the object is intact and unchanged he returns it as is, but if it underwent a transformative change in his hands he has acquired it and pays its former value instead. Restoring the gezel is the precondition for atonement when a false oath was involved.

Where it comes up

7 mishnayot

  1. Bava Kamma 9:1A change that transfers ownershipThis is the perek's headline principle for robbery: restitution is pegged to the object's worth at the moment it was taken, so any later change in value belongs to the robber.
  2. Bava Kamma 9:5The false oath and returning the robbery in personWhen a robber compounds the robbery with a false oath, repentance requires that the stolen value reach the victim's own hand — the duty to restore is no longer satisfied by any shortcut.
  3. Bava Kamma 9:9Restoring a robbery to one's fellow heirsEven when the robber would inherit the very money he stole, the duty to remove the stolen object from his hand overrides his inheritance share — restitution comes first.
  4. Bava Kamma 10:9Buying from those who might be selling stolen goodsThe whole rule is a fence against unwittingly buying stolen goods: a shepherd tends another's flock, so wool or kids he offers for sale are presumed possibly stolen from the flock's owner.
  5. Bava Metzia 4:7The five cases of a perutahA robber who took even a perutah's worth and swore falsely about it cannot atone by sending it back through a messenger; he must personally carry the stolen object to its owner, even a great distance.
  6. Bava Metzia 4:8The five 'add a fifth' lawsA robber who denied the robbery under a false oath and then confesses must repay the principal plus a fifth (Vayikra 5:24) — the same surcharge that runs through this whole list.
  7. Bava Metzia 7:8The four guardiansTheft is a loss the paid guardian must make good, unlike the unpaid guardian, because his pay obliges him to guard more carefully.