Principle
Eidut ishahעֵדוּת אִשָּׁה
EI-DUT I-SHAH
Relaxed testimony to free a widow
Testimony that a woman's husband has died, permitting her to remarry. Because leaving her bound forever would be a calamity, the Sages relaxed the ordinary rules of evidence here: a single witness suffices, even hearsay, even witnesses normally disqualified — and the woman herself may be believed. The counterweight is severe: if the husband returns, she loses everything. The whole structure balances leniency in evidence against stringency in consequences.
Where it comes up
10 mishnayot
- Yevamot 15:1Yevamot 15 opens — when one woman's word remarries herThe foundation of eidut isha: her own unsupported report that her husband died is accepted when there is peace at home and in the world, because she would not dare lie about something so checkable.
- Yevamot 15:2From the harvest, from anywhere — when does her testimony work?Beit Shammai persuade Beit Hillel that believing her is a general rule. The harvest in the precedent was just the case at hand, not a condition on the relaxed testimony.
- Yevamot 15:4Who can testify, and what happens when witnesses contradictThe relaxation throws the door wide open: anyone may testify that the husband died, except the five women presumed to wish her harm.
- Yevamot 15:5Two wives, conflicting reports — who remarries?Relaxed testimony still cannot beat an even contradiction. One valid voice against another leaves her where she was, unable to remarry.
- Yevamot 15:8Husband first, son second — vs. son first, husband secondShe is believed that her husband died before her son because, when she left, he had a son: her report merely continues her exemption from levirate marriage. The reverse order, which would create a new bond, is where her word stops.
- Yevamot 15:10A brother-in-law born overseas — and the limits of one witness's wordThe boundary of the relaxation: one witness frees a woman only from a husband whose death is unconfirmed; about her brother-in-law or her sister, her word gets no special trust.
- Yevamot 16:3Face and nose — the only valid identificationEven relaxed death-testimony needs a real identification, the face with the nose and within three days, so the leniency for the widow never rests on guesswork about the body.
- Yevamot 16:5Speaking in passing — testimony without intent to testifyHearsay suffices: overhearing women chat that a man died counts as eidut isha, because the Sages accepted any honest trace of the death to free the widow.
- Yevamot 16:6An unseen voice — when a voice alone frees a wifeFormal evidence rules fall away here: viewing by candlelight or moonlight, and even an unseen voice, can ground the testimony that frees her.
- Yevamot 16:7The tractate's close — one witness frees a wife whose husband is missingThe capstone tradition: Rabban Gamliel the Elder permitted a wife to remarry on a single witness, and the practice became fixed. The one-witness rule is the engine of the whole perek.